Introducing Seven Transition Metal Ions into Terpyridine-Based Supramolecules: Self-Assembly and Dynamic Ligand Exchange Study

Article abstract of DOI:10.1021/jacs.9b09497

In coordination-driven self-assembly, 2,2′:6′,2″-terpyridine (tpy) has gained extensive attention in constructing supramolecular architectures on the basis of a tpy-M-tpy?connectivity. In direct self-assembly of large discrete structures, however, the met

Full text of DOI:10.1021/jacs.9b09497

Subscriber access provided by UNIV OF NEBRASKA - LINCOLN
Article
Introducing Seven Transition Metal Ions into Terpyridine-Based
Supramolecules: Self-Assembly and Dynamic Ligand Exchange Study
Lei Wang, Bo Song, Sandra Khalife, Yiming Li, Li-June Ming, Shi
Bai, Yaping Xu, Hao Yu, Ming Wang, Heng Wang, and Xiaopeng Li
J. Am. Chem. Soc., Just Accepted Manuscript • DOI: 10.1021/jacs.9b09497 • Publication Date (Web): 07 Jan 2020
Downloaded from pubs.acs.org on January 8, 2020
Just Accepted
“Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted
online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical
Society provides “Just Accepted” as a service to the research community to expedite the dissemination
of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in
full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully
peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are citable by the
Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore,
the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After
a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web
site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes
to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and
ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or
consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.
is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W.,
Washington, DC 20036
Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society.
However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works
produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course
of their duties.

Page 1 of 11
Journal of the American Chemical Society
!"#$%&'(!) *+,+! -#.!/("($! 0+".1 $!/ (!"$ -+#23#(%(!+45./+%
*&2#.6$1+'&1+/7 *+184A//+6913 .!% :3!.6(' ;().!% <='>.!)+ *"&%3
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
!" #$%&'( )* +*%&'( +$%,-$ ./$0"1!'( 2"3"%& "'( "456%! 7"%&'( +/" )$"'8 2$9"%& :6'; <$* 26';
7"%& #$%&'; <!%& #$%&'='(' $%, :"$*9!%& "='(
(>!9$-?3!%? *1 @/!3"A?-B' C%"D!-A"?B *1 +*6?/ E0*-",$' F$39$' E0*-",$ GGHIJ' C%"?!, +?$?!A
8>!9$-?3!%? *1 @/!3"A?-B $%, )"*K/!3"A?-B' C%"D!-A"?B *1 >!0$L$-!' M!L$-N' >!0$L$-! OPQOH' C%"?!, +?$?!A
+?$?! .!B $R*-$?*-B *1 +69-$3*0!K60$- +?-6K?6-! $%, 7$?!-"$0A' @*00!&! *1 @/!3"A?-B' 5"0"% C%"D!-A"?B' @/$%&K/6%'
5"0"% OGJJOI' @/"%$
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
@*00!&! *1 @/!3"A?-B $%, S%D"-*%3!%?$0 S%&"%!!-"%&' +/!%T/!% C%"D!-A"?B' +/!%T/!%' U6$%&,*%& VOWJVV' @/"%$
!"#$%&'( )*+,-.))*/0+12 )345./6+*73+.5 78*/9):512 :*54159;9<*2 ;1<./97 +9=.<; *>78.<=*
A !"#A$"% X% K**-,"%$?"*%4,-"D!% A!014$AA!3R0B' I'IYZHY'I[4?!-9B-","%! \?9B] /$A &$"%!, !^?!%A"D! $??!%?"*% "% K*%A?-6K?"%&
A69-$3*0!K60$- $-K/"?!K?6-!A *% ?/! R$A"A *1 _?9B474?9B` K*%%!K?"D"?Ba X% ,"-!K? A!014$AA!3R0B *1 0$-&! ,"AK-!?! A?-6K?6-!A'
/*L!D!-' ?/! 3!?$0 "*%A L!-! 3$"%0B 0"3"?!, ?* @,\XX]' b%\XX] $%, E!\XX] "*%Aa <!-!"%' L! A"&%"1"K$%?0B R-*$,!% ?/! A9!K?-63
*1 3!?$0 "*%A L"?/ A!D!% ,"D$0!%? ?-$%A"?"*% 3!?$0 "*%A 7\XX] \7c7%' E!' @*' M"' @6' b%' @,] ?* $AA!3R0! $ A!-"!A *1
A69-$3*0!K60$- 1-$K?$0Aa X% 9$-?"K60$-' 7%\XX]' @*\XX]' M"\XX]' @6\XX] L!-! -!9*-?!, 1*- ?/! 1"-A? ?"3! ?* 1*-3 A6K/ 0$-&! $%,
,"AK-!?! A?-6K?6-!A L"?/_?9B474?9B` K*%%!K?"D"?Ba X% $,,"?"*%' ?/! A?-6K?6-$0 A?$R"0"?"!A *1 ?/*A! A69-$3*0!K60!A "% &$A 9/$A!
$%, ?/! N"%!?"KA *1 ?/! 0"&$%, !^K/$%&! 9-*K!AA "% A*06?"*% L!-! "%D!A?"&$?!, 6A"%& 3$AA A9!K?-*3!?-Ba +6K/ $ 16%,$3!%?$0
A?6,B &$D! ?/! -!0$?"D! *-,!- *1 A?-6K?6-$0 A?$R"0"?B "% &$A 9/$A! $%, -!D!$0!, ?/! "%!-?%!AA *1 K**-,"%$?"*% "% A*06?"*%
,!9!%,"%& *% ?/! 3!?$0 "*%Aa F/*A! -!A60?A L*60, &6",! ?/! 16?6-! A?6,B "% ?9B4R$A!, A69-$3*0!K60$- K/!3"A?-B "% ?!-3A *1
A!014$AA!3R0B' K/$-$K?!-"T$?"*%' 9-*9!-?B $%, $990"K$?"*%a
&'()*+,-(.*'
%!?L*-NAaIH F/! 3!?$0 "*%A $,*9?!, ?* K*%A?-6K? 0$-&!
,"AK-!?! A?-6K?6-!A ?/-*6&/ ,"-!K? A!014$AA!3R0B' /*L!D!-'
L!-! 3$"%0B 0"3"?!, ?* ?/-!! 3!?$0 "*%A L"?/ /"&/0B
-!D!-A"R0! K**-,"%$?"*%' D"Ta' @,\XX]' b%\XX] $%, E!\XX]aIQ g!-B
1!L K$A!A /$D! !^9$%,!, ?/! AK*9! ?* h6\XX] $%, iA\XX] L"?/
A"390! &!*3!?-B $%, 0*L K*390!^"?B !"?/!- RB ?!,"*6A 9*A?4
$AA!3R0B A!9$-$?"*% *- 6%,!- /$-A/ -!$K?"*% K*%,"?"*%
L"?/ 0*L B"!0,AaIW e!-/$9A' ?/! 0$KN *1 *?/!- 3!?$0 "*%A "%
?9B4R$A!, A69-$3*0!K60$- K/!3"A?-B "A ,6! ?* ?/! D$-"$R0!
#"?/ ?/! &*$0 *1 6%,!-A?$%,"%& ?/! *-&$%"T"%& 9-"%K"90! *1
%$?6-!
1*-
K*%A?-6K?"%&
3$K-*3*0!K60!A
$%,
A69-$3*0!K60$- K*390!^!A "% R"*ABA?!3A' A69-$3*0!K60$-
K/!3"A?-B /$A &-$,6$00B ,!D!0*9!, $ 3B-"$, *1 AB%?/!?"K
ABA?!3A L"?/ ,B%$3"K 1!$?6-!A ?/-*6&/ A!014$AA!3R0B "% ?/!
9$A? 1!L ,!K$,!AaO X% 9$-?"K60$-' ?/! $K?"D! -!A!$-K/ "%?!-!A?
"% ?/! 1"!0, *1 K**-,"%$?"*%4,-"D!% A!014$AA!3R0B /$A
L"?%!AA!,
$
L",! $--$B *1 L!004,!1"%!, 3!?$00*4
A!014$AA!3R0B
K*%,"?"*%A'
$%,
K/$00!%&"%&
A69-$3*0!K60$- $-K/"?!K?6-!AaI #"?/ $ 0$-&! A?-6K?6-$0
,"D!-A"?B *1 *-&$%"K R6"0,"%& R0*KNA $%, $KK!AA"R"0"?B ?*
,"11!-!%? 3!?$0 "*%A' 3!?$00*4A69-$3*0!K60!A /$D! R!!%
$AA!3R0!, L"?/ ,"11!-!%? ?*9*0*&"!A' A6K/ $A *%!4
,"3!%A"*%$0 \O>] /!0"K$?!A'G ?L*4,"3!%A"*%$0 \I>]
K*390!^!A \!a&a' 9*0B&*%A'd 1-$K?$0A'V N%*?A $%, 0"%NAH]' $%,
?/-!!4,"3!%A"*%$0 \G>] K$&!A \!a&a' e0$?*%"K A*0",A'Q
A-K/"3!,!$% A*0",A'W U*0,R!-& 9*0B/!,-*%AP' $%,
9-"A3AOJ]a F/*A! 3!?$00*4A69-$3*0!K60!A L"?/ "%K-!$A"%&
K*390!^"?B $%, ,"D!-A"?B /$D! $0A* &"D!% -"A! ?* 16-?/!-
!^90*-$?"*%A *1 ?/!"- 1$AK"%$?"%& 9/BA"K$0 $%, K/!3"K$0
9-*9!-?"!A' 0!$,"%& ?* ?/! $990"K$?"*%A "% /*A?f&6!A?
K/!3"A?-B'OO K$?$0BA"A'OI A!%A"%&'OG &$A A?*-$&!'Od ,-6&
,!0"D!-B $%, $%?"3"K-*R"$0 3$?!-"$0A'OV !?Ka
K/$-$K?!-"T$?"*%aIR <!-!"%' L! 9-!A!%? $ A!-"!A *1 /!^$3!-"K
A69-$3*0!K60!A L"?/ 1-$K?$0 K/$-$K?!-"A?"KAVK'V! $AA!3R0!,
RB ?L* ?!?-$?*9"K ?9B 0"&$%,A L"?/ A!D!% ,"11!-!%? ,"D$0!%?
?-$%A"?"*% 3!?$0 "*%A 7\XX] \7c7%' E!' @*' M"' @6' b%' @,]
6%,!- 3"0, K*%,"?"*%A $1?!- 3$%B ?-"$0A \E"&6-! O$]a F/*A!
A69-$3*0!K60$- 1-$K?$0A /$D! A"&%"1"K$%?0B R-*$,!%!, ?/!
A9!K?-63 *1 3!?$0 "*%A 6A!, "% A!014$AA!3R0B *1 ,"AK-!?!
A69-$3*0!K60$- $-K/"?!K?6-!A L"?/ "%K-!$A"%& ,"D!-A"?Ba
E6-?/!-3*-!' ?/! "%?-*,6K?"*% *1 ,"11!-!%? ?B9!A *1 3!?$0
"*%A "A !^9!K?!, ?* $,D$%K! ?/! 16?6-! A?6,B "% 3!?$04
,!9!%,!%? 16%K?"*%A $%, $990"K$?"*%Aa
@*39$-!, ?* ?/! K*%D!%?"*%$0 AB%?/!?"K K/!3"A?-B L/"K/
,!$0A L"?/ K*D$0!%? R*%,A' *%! *1 ?/! R$A"K 1!$?6-!A
"%/!-!%? "% A69-$3*0!K60$- K/!3"A?-B "A "?A ,B%$3"K
K$9$R"0"?B L/"K/ K$% *-&$%"T! ?/! 3*0!K60$- K*39*%!%?A
"%?* $ A69-$3*0!K60$- !%?"?B RB D"-?6! *1 %*%4K*D$0!%?
A3*%& ?/! ,"D!-A! 0"R-$-B *1 *-&$%"K ,*%*- R6"0,"%&
R0*KNA' !a&a' 9B-","%!'OH R"9B-","%!'OQ 9/!%$%?-*0"%!'OW
?!-9B-","%!'OP 9B-","%!4,"$3",!'IJ $%, K$-R*^B0"K $K",A'IO
I'IYZHY'I[4?!-9B-","%! \?9B] /$A R!!% !^?!%A"D!0B 6A!, $A $
?-",!%?$?! 3*?"1 R!K$6A! *1 "?A !^K!00!%? K*390!^"%& $R"0"?B
?*L$-,A ,"11!-!%? 3!?$0 "*%A' "a!a' 3$"% &-*69' ?-$%A"?"*%
3!?$0A $%, 0$%?/$%",! K$?"*%AaII AA A6K/' 3$%B
"%?!-$K?"*%Aa
F/!
,B%$3"K
%$?6-!
$00*LA
?/!
A69-$3*0!K60$- A9!K"!A ?* -!D!-A"R0B ,"AA*K"$?! $%,
$AA*K"$?! ?* 60?"3$?!0B &!%!-$?! ?/! /"&/0B K*390!^
$-K/"?!K?6-!AaIP F/!-!1*-!' A?6,B"%& ?/! A!014$AA!3R0B
,B%$3"KA %*? *%0B !%/$%K!A ?/! 6%,!-A?$%,"%& *1 ?/!
9-*K!AA!A R6? $0A* 1$K"0"?$?!A ?/! ,!A"&% $%, K*%A?-6K?"*% *1
A69-$3*0!K60$- $-K/"?!K?6-!A L"?/ ,!A"-!, 16%K?"*%$0"?Ba
<*L!D!-' "? -!3$"%A $ 1*-3",$R0! K/$00!%&! ?* K/$-$K?!-"T!
A69-$3*0!K60$-
$-K/"?!K?6-!A
L"?/
_?9B474?9B`
K*%%!K?"D"?B /$D! R!!% ,!3*%A?-$?!, 1*- R*?/ ,"AK-!?!
A?-6K?6-!A A6K/ $A 3$K-*KBK0!AIG' K$&!A'Id $%, "%1"%"?!
A?-6K?6-!A "%K06,"%& A69-$3*0!K60$- 9*0B3!-AIV $%,
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 2 of 11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Page 3 of 11
Journal of the American Chemical Society
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 4 of 11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Page 5 of 11
Journal of the American Chemical Society
1-$K?$0AaIQ S^K!9? ?/! 6%A$?"A1$K?*-B -!A60?A *1 7%\XX]
E!\XXX]lE!\XX] K*690! \SOlIcOaJg' tS9 cOdJ 3g] $%,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
1-$K?$0A' ?/! A9!K?-$ *1 $00 *?/!-A ,"A90$B!, -!0$?"D!0B %$--*L
E!\XX]lE!\X] K*690! \SOlI c4OaIGg' tS9 cOIJ 3g] L!-!
*RA!-D!,aGWR AA 1*- @* $%, 7%' *%0B -!,6K?"*% 9-*K!AA L$A
,"A90$B!,' "a!a @*\XX]l@*\X] K*690! \SOlI c 4JaHGg' tS9cQJ 3g
] $%, 7%\XX]l7%\X] K*690! \SOlIc4OaIHg' tS9 cOWJ 3g]aGWK
F/! *^",$?"*% 9-*K!AA!A *1 ?/!A! ?L* 3!?$0A 3"&/? R!
*D!-0$99!, L"?/ ?/! R-*$, 9!$NA *1 ?-"9/!%B0$3"%! 6%"?Aa
E6-?/!-3*-!' "--!D!-A"R0! *^",$?"*% 9!$NA $-*6%, JaJQg
$%, JaVQg "% @6 1-$K?$0 "%,"K$?!, ?/! $,A*-9?"*% *% ?/!
!0!K?-*,! A6-1$K!aGW,
R$%,A *1 A"&%$0A L"?/ $ ,"116A"*% K*!11"K"!%? \>' 3IlA]
4OJ
-$%&"%& 1-*3 OaPI OJ ?* IaId OJ4OJ' "%,"K$?"%& ?/!
,"AK-!?! $-K/"?!K?6-! L"?/ $ A"3"0$- ,"$3!?!- 1*- !$K/
1-$K?$0 \E"&6-! d' $%, E"&6-!A +OJQ4+OOI]aF/! K$0K60$?!,
/B,-*,B%$3"K -$,"6A 1-*3 ?/! ,"116A"*% K*!11"K"!%? 6A"%&
?/! 3*,"1"!, +?*KNA4S"%A?!"% !s6$?"*% R$A!, *% ?/! *R0$?!
A9/!-*", 3*,!0GQ "A $-*6%, GaV r daI %3' L/"K/ "A
K*%A"A?!%? L"?/ ?/! 3*0!K60$- 3*,!0"%& -!A60? L! -!9*-?!,
9-!D"*6A0BV! 1*- ?/! b%\XX] 1-$K?$0a A00 ?/! -!A60?A $-!
A633$-"T!, "% F$R0! +Ia
!
!
9
!(,+= *9 (?1 4(),-(,)65 4(6<.5.(= .' 064 D?641 6'+
+='6;.- 5.06'+ 1K-?6'01 .' 4*5,(.*'8 F* !D$06$?! ?/!
A?$R"0"?B *1 ?/! A69-$3*0!K60!A L"?/ ,"11!-!%? 3!?$0 "*%A'
&-$,"!%? ?$%,!3 3$AA A9!K?-*3!?-B \&7+I]GP L$A
!390*B!, RB $990B"%& $ &-$,6$?! "%K-!$A! *1 K*00"A"*%
!%!-&B ?* $% "A*0$?!, K/$-&!, A9!K"!A *1 ?/!
A69-$3*0!K60!Aa F/! -!A60?A A/*L!, ?/$? ?/*A! 1-$K?$0A L"?/
,"11!-!%? _?9B474?9B` K*%%!K?"D"?B L!-! K*390!?!0B
,"AA*K"$?!, $? ,"11!-!%? K*00"A"*% !%!-&B \F$R0! O] 6%,!-
&7+Ia E*- "%A?$%K!' !A:$, L$A ,"AA*K"$?!,
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
#! 16-?/!- "%D!A?"&$?!, ?/! !0!K?-*K/!3"K$0 9-*9!-?"!A *1
?/!A! 1-$K?$0A "% $ ?/-!!4!0!K?-*,! !0!K?-*K/!3"K$0 K!00 L"?/
)6dMeEH \JaJJO 7] $A !0!K?-*0B?!a F/! *^",$?"*%A *1
?-"9/!%B0$3"%! 6%"?A L!-! *RA!-D!, $? $-*6%, JaP g ?* OaI
g "% !$K/ 1-$K?$0 L"?/ R-*$, 9!$N K*--!A9*%,"%& ?*
A6KK!AA"D! *%! !0!K?-*% -!3*D$0'GW$ $%, ?/! ?9B40"&$%,4
K!%?!-!, -!,*^ 9-*K!AA *KK6--!, $? 4OaJg ?* 4Oadg $KK*-,"%&
?* ?/! 0"?!-$?6-!V! \E"&6-! +OOG]a X% E! 1-$K?$0' R*?/ *1 ?/!
"$3
"$3
"$3
0:2
072
"&3
"&3
"&3
"#3
"#3
"'3
"43
"'3
"#3
"'3
"43
"53
"43
"53
""3
""3
"53
" 3
""3
" 3
"63
#!3
" 3
"63
"63
"!3
"!3
"!3
"#!!
"#3
!"
082
!!
"!!!
"&3
!"
4!!
!!
"!!!
"#!!
092
"#3
""3
!"
!"
"#3
"$3
"$3
"!!!
"$3
"!!!
!!
"&3
"'3
"&3
"'3
"'3
"43
"43
"53
"53
" 3
" 3
"43
"53
" 3
"63
!!
0/2
;<0=>2
;A0=>2
$%!
$%!
&%!
&%!
'%!
'%!
4%!
()*+, -*./ 0.12
()*+, -*./ 0.12
@A$@<$=>"#
@A&@<#=>"#
@A4@<!=>"#
@A'@<"=>"#
@A!@<4=>"#
@A#@<&=>"#
@A"@<'=>"#
## ?
"6 ?
"4 ?
"& ?
"# ?
"! ?
! ?
66!
"!!!
"!"!
"!#!
!"
/.0,)1 L8 >B%$3"K 0"&$%, !^K/$%&! A?6,B *1 !A:$* $%, ! :$* $? OIJ *@a S+X47+ A9!K?-$ *1 !Al! :$* 3"^!, $1?!- \$] J / $%, \K] ?L*
,$BAj F#X747+ 90*? \/?@ DAa ,-"1? ?"3!] *1 !Al! :$* 3"^!, $1?!- \R] J / $%, \,] ?L* ,$BA \T**3!,4"% A9!K?-63 *1 OGm "*%A "% ?/!
"%A!?]j \!] ?/! 3$&%"1"!, A9!K?-$ *1 OGm "*%A 1-*3 ?/! 3"^?6-! *1 !Al! :$* $? ,"11!-!%? ?"3! A9*?Aa
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 6 of 11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Page 7 of 11
Journal of the American Chemical Society
!,DD*)(.'0 &'9*);6(.*'a
F$R0! Oa @,\XX] 1-$K?$0A A/*L!, ?/! /"&/!A? !^K/$%&! -$?!
K*%A?$%? B60) *1 IaP
$ B60) $A 0*L $A OaQ
OJG 74OA4O' L/"0! @*\XX] *%!A ,"A90$B!,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
+B%?/!?"K ,!?$"0A' 0"&$%,A $%, K*390!^!A K/$-$K?!-"T$?"*%
"%K06,"%& O< M7h' OG@ M7h' I> @i+2' I> MiS+2' S+X47+'
F#X747+' ,!?$"0A 1*- ,B%$3"K 0"&$%, !^K/$%&! $-! "%K06,!, "%
A699*-?"%& "%1*-3$?"*%a F/"A 3$?!-"$0 "A $D$"0$R0! 1-!! *1
K/$-&! D"$ ?/! X%?!-%!? $? /??9Zll96RAa$KAa*-&a
!
!
*
OJ4P 74OA4O $? IV @a F/! ,"11!-!%K!
R!?L!!% ?/*A! ?L* L$A $A /"&/ $A $ 1$K?*- *1 OJOIa
"6<51 28 !,;;6).C1+ #14,5(4 *9 0A!@ 6'+ PK-?6'01
#6(1 $*'4(6'( !"#$ 6( @L *$
AB-C?D AE?D0A- ?A
@*--!A9*%,"%& A6?/*-A
^"$*9!%&0"Ox6A1a!,6
/!%&L$%&x3$"0a6A1a!,6
7%
OW
E!
II
4
@*
IH
M"
GO
4
@6
IO
b%
Id
@,
OP
0A!@
MQN
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
!
"#$
MA:24:
OJ4
!
OaQ
OJ4P
!
I
!
IaP
OJG
OPa
O
OQa
H
OaW
ih@X>
2N
!" #$%&Z JJJJ4JJJI4GQQW4IWOd
)* +*%&Z JJJJ4JJJI4dGGQ4WdW:
"456%! 7"%&Z JJJJ4JJJG4JJId4PVVd
7"%& #$%&Z JJJJ4JJJI4VGGI4JWJd
)$" +/"Z JJJJ4JJJG4IOIH4dVJ:
<!%& #$%&Z JJJJ4JJJI4HWIP4QIJV
:"$*9!%& "Z JJJJ4JJJO4PHVV4PVVO
M*?!A
+"3"0$- ?* ?/! -!0$?"D! *-,!- *1 A?-6K?6-$0 A?$R"0"?B "% &$A
9/$A!' ?/! A?-6K?6-$0 "%!-?%!AA *1 3!?$00*4A69-$3*0!K60!A
1 1 1
"% A*06?"*% L$A K*%K06,!, $A E!lM"
@* b%
@6 `
7% ` @,a F/! -!A60?A !06K",$?!, ?/$? ?/! 3!?$0 "*%A 90$B!,
$% "39*-?$%? -*0! 1*- ?/! A?-6K?6-$0 A?$R"0"?B "% &$A 9/$A!
$%, N"%!?"KA \"%!-?%!AA *- 0$R"0"?B] "% A*06?"*%a @*39$-!,
L"?/ ?/! A?-6K?6-$0 A?$R"0"?B "% &$A 9/$A! L/"K/ -!10!K?!, ?/!
"%?-"%A"K R"%,"%& A?-!%&?/ *1 ?/! 3!?$040"&$%, "% ?/! K*390!^
"% $ A*0D!%?41-!! !%D"-*%3!%?'dJ$ L/"0! ?/! ,B%$3"K
R!/$D"*- "% A*06?"*% L$A ,!?!-3"%!, RB N"%!?"K 0"$R"0"?B *-
-!D!-A"R"0"?B *1 ?/! 3!?$040"&$%, "%?!-$K?"*%A L/"K/
"%D*0D!, 360?"90! 9-*K!AA!A "%K06,"%& ,"AA*K"$?"*%'
$AA*K"$?"*%' $11"%"?"D! $??$K/3!%?' !?KadJR'dJK F/! N"%!?"K
A?6,B "% A*06?"*% 9-*D",!A 6A "%1*-3$?"*% $R*6? /*L 1$A?
?/! 0"&$%, !^K/$%&! 9-*K!AA K*60, R! K*390!?!, $%, &6",!A
6A ?* *9?"3"T! A!014$AA!3R0B K*%,"?"*% "% A*06?"*% 1*- !$K/
3!?$0a F/! ?/!-3*,B%$3"K A?$R"0"?B *R?$"%!, "% &$A 9/$A!
L*60, 9-*D",! 6A &6",$%K! "% A!0!K?"%& $ 9-*9!- 3!?/*, 1*-
K/$-$K?!-"T$?"*%a F/!-!1*-!' ?/! A?$R"0"?B *-,!- *1
A69-$3*0!K60!A "% &$A L"?/ ,"11!-!%? 3!?$0 "*%A K*60, R!
,"11!-!%? 1-*3 ?/! N"%!?"KA \!^K/$%&! -$?!] "% A*06?"*%a AA
A6K/' ?/! 3!?/*, L! ,!D!0*9!, ?* s6$%?"?$?"D!0B A?6,B ?/!
!^9!-"3!%?$0 N"%!?"KA *1 ?/! K*390"K$?!, ,B%$3"K 0"&$%,
!^K/$%&! 9-*K!AA RB S+X47+ $0*%& L"?/ ?/! -!0$?"D! A?$R"0"?B
*1 &"$%? A69-$3*0!K60!A ,!9!%,"%& *% ?/! 3!?$0 "*%A L*60,
$,D$%K! 16?6-! A?6,B "% K**-,"%$?"*%4,-"D!% A!014$AA!3R0Ba
F/! $6?/*-A ,!K0$-! %* K*39!?"%& 1"%$%K"$0 "%?!-!A?a
A@FA?G;<:H0<A-
F/! $6?/*-A &-$?!1600B $KN%*L0!,&! ?/! A699*-? 1-*3 MX<
\OhJOU7OIWJGQ]a
D<E<D<A@<*
\O] \$] @-$3' >a 5a F/! >!A"&% *1 7*0!K60$- <*A?A' U6!A?A' A%,
F/!"- @*390!^!Aa A<=*CA D8*/A E<:A !;A !<=+A 2RSS' FG' OJJP4OJIJa
\R] !/%' 5a47a +69-$3*0!K60$- @/!3"A?-By+K*9! $%,
e!-A9!K?"D!Aa 7*0!K60!A' +69!-3*0!K60!A' $%, 7*0!K60$- >!D"K!Aa
A<=*CA D8*/A E<:A !;A !<=+A 2RSS' FG' PJ4OOIa \K] e!,!-A!%' @a 5a F/!
>"AK*D!-B *1 @-*L% S?/!-Aa A<=*CA D8*/A E<:A !;A !<=+A 2RSS' FG'
OJIO4OJIQa \,] !!' 5a #aj +$3$0' +aj +!0D$9$0$3' Maj ."3' <a45aj ."3'
.a @6K6-R"?6-"0 <*3*0*&6!A $%, >!-"D$?"D!AZz M!L i99*-?6%"?"!A "%
+69-$3*0!K60$- @/!3"A?-Ba A77A D8*/A %*)A @OOF' HI' HIO4HGJa \!]
$&*%$' 5aj 76N/*9$,/B$B' eaj @/$N-$R$-?"' +aj XA$$KA' a F/!
@6K6-R"?v%w6-"0 E$3"0Ba A<=*CA D8*/A E<:A !;A @OOL' JJ' dWdd4dWQJa
\1] 7!B!-' @a >aj 5*"%!-' @a +aj +?*,,$-?' 5a Ea F!390$?!4>"-!K?!,
+B%?/!A"A S390*B"%& h!D!-A"R0! X3"%! )*%, E*-3$?"*%a D8*/A '67A
%*KA @OOT' HI' OQJV4OQIGa \&] g6N*?"K' ga Maj *!R' +a 5a @**-,"%$?"*%
e*0B3!-A @*%?$"%"%& h*?$^$%! "%N!-Aa D8*/A '67A %*KA @O2@' JL'
VWPH4VPJHa
\I] \$] i0!%B6N' )aj !"%"%&!-' +aj +?$%&' ea 5a +!014AAA!3R0B *1
>"AK-!?! @BK0"K M$%*A?-6K?6-!A 7!,"$?!, RB F-$%A"?"*% 7!?$0Aa
D8*/A %*KA@OOO' LMM' WVG4PJWa \R] E6{"?$' 7aj F*3"%$&$' 7aj <*-"'
Aaj F/!--"!%' )a @**-,"%$?"*% AAA!3R0"!A 1-*3 $ e,\XX]4@*-%!-!,
+s6$-! @*390!^a A77A D8*/A %*)A @OOL' HN' GHP4GQWa \K] >$0&$-%*'
+a 5aj e*L!-' Ma eaj A?L**,' 5a a 7!?$00*4+69-$3*0!K60$- @$9A60!Aa
D665;A D8*/A %*KA @OOS' FOF' WIV4WdOa \,] <$%' 7aj S%&!0/$-,' >a
7aj @0!D!-' Ua <a +!014AAA!3R0!, @**-,"%$?"*% @$&!A )$A!, *%
)$%$%$4+/$9!, "&$%,Aa D8*/A '67A %*KA @O2J' JH' OWdW4OWHJa \!]
7K@*%%!00' Aa 5aj #**,' @a +aj M!!0$N$%,$%' ea eaj M"?AK/N!' 5a ha
+?"360"4h!A9*%A"D! 7!?$0f "&$%, AAA!3R0"!Aa D8*/A %*KA @O2L'
LLO' QQIP4QQPGa \1] @/!%' a45aj 2$%&' <a4)aj +/"*%*B$' 7a @/"-$0
7!?$00*A69-$3*0!K60$- A-K/"?!K?6-!Aa D8*/A '67A %*KA @O2T' JI'
IVVV4IVQHa \&] 5$%AT!' +a 7aj +!D!-"%' .a @0$?/-*K/!0$?!
7!?$00*0"&$%,A "% +69-$3*0!K60$- @/!3"A?-B $%, 7$?!-"$0A
+K"!%K!a A77A D8*/A %*)A @O2S' OL' IOGP4IOdQa
$*'-5,4.*'48
X% A633$-B' $ A!-"!A *1 3!?$00*4A69-$3*0!K60!A L"?/ 1-$K?$0
1!$?6-!A L!-! 9-!9$-!, ?/-*6&/ K**-,"%$?"*%4,-"D!% A!014
$AA!3R0B 6A"%& ?L* ?!?-$?*9"K ?9B 0"&$%,A L"?/ A!D!%
,"11!-!%? ,"D$0!%? ?-$%A"?"*% 3!?$0 "*%A 7\XX] \7c7%' E!' @*'
M"' @6' b%' @,] 6%,!- 3"0, K*%,"?"*%Aa 7%\XX]' @*\XX]' M"\XX]'
@6\XX] L!-! -!9*-?!, /!-!"% 1*- ?/! 1"-A? ?"3! ?* 1*-3 &"$%?
$%, ,"AK-!?! A?-6K?6-!A "% ?9B4R$A!, A69-$3*0!K60$-
K/!3"A?-Ba F/!-!1*-!' ?/"A A?6,B /$A 0$-&!0B !^9$%,!, ?/!
A9!K?-63 *1 _?9B474?9B` K*%%!K?"D"?B 1*- ?/! K*%A?-6K?"*%
*1 L!004,!1"%!, A69-$3*0!K60$- $-K/"?!K?6-!A L"?/
"%K-!$A"%& A?-6K?6-$0 K*390!^"?B $%, ,"D!-A"?Ba X% $,,"?"*%'
?/! A?-6K?6-$0 A?$R"0"?B *1 ?/*A! 1-$K?$0A "% ?/! &$A 9/$A! L$A
"%D!A?"&$?!, RB &-$,"!%? ?$%,!3 3$AA A9!K?-*3!?-Ba F/!
N"%!?"KA *1 ?/! ,B%$3"K 0"&$%, !^K/$%&! 9-*K!AA R!?L!!%
?L* ,"AK-!?! A69-$3*0!K60!A "% A*06?"*% L$A $0A*
$99-*$K/!, s6$%?"?$?"D!0B 6A"%& S+X47+a X? "A !^9!K?!, ?/$?
?/"A 16%,$3!%?$0 A?6,B L*60, $,D$%K! ?9B4R$A!,
A69-$3*0!K60$- K/!3"A?-B "% ?!-3A *1 K/$-$K?!-"T$?"*%'
9-*9!-?B $%, $990"K$?"*% !^90*-$?"*%Aa
\G] \$] .-|3!-' haj !/%' 5a 7aj >! @"$%' Aaj E"AK/!-' 5a +!014
AAA!3R0B' +?-6K?6-!' $%, +9*%?$%!*6A h!A*06?"*% *1 $ F-"%6K0!$-
F-"90! <!0"^ 1-*3 $% i0"&*R"9B-","%! "&$%, $%, M"XX X*%Aa A<=*CA
D8*/A E<:A !;A !<=+A 2RRF' HF' QJG4QJH8 \R] .-$3!-' haj !/%' 5a47aj
7$-s6"A4h"&$60?' Aa +!014h!K*&%"?"*% "% <!0"K$?! +!014AAA!3R0BZ
+9*%?$%!*6A E*-3$?"*% *1 <!0"K$0 7!?$0 @*390!^!A 1-*3 7"^?6-!A
A**?@ A-<: @?A-<A-
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 8 of 11
*1 "&$%,A A%, 7!?$0 X*%Aa P567A Q.:A A7.;A '79A 2RRF' RM' VGPd4
M"?AK/N!' 5a ha +?!-!*K/!3"K$0 e0$A?"K"?B 7*,60$?!A @**9!-$?"D!
VGPWa \K] <$A!%N%*91' )aj !/%' 5a47aj )$63' Uaj E!%AN!' >a +!014
AAA!3R0B *1 $ <!?!-*,690!^ <!0"K$?! 1-*3 FL* >"11!-!%? "&$%,
+?-$%,A A%, @6\XX] @$?"*%Aa P567A Q.:A A7.;A '79A 2RRE' RH' OGPQ4
OdJJa
)"%,"%& "% $ @*XX H @6R*K?$/!,-*%a Q.:A D8*/A @O2T' R' PJG4PJWa
1
2
3
OI
\P] E6{"?$' >aj C!,$' 2aj +$?*' +aj 7"T6%*' Maj .63$A$N$' Faj E6{"?$'
7a +!014AAA!3R0B *1 F!?-$D$0!%? U*0,R!-& e*0B/!,-$ 1-*3 Odd
+3$00 @*39*%!%?Aa Q.:35* @O2E' OJM' VHG4VHHa
4
5
6
7
8
9
\d] \$] #}-?/%!-' Eaj 2*6' @a4@aj +$/$47~00!-' @a ha
7!?$00*A69-$3*0!K60$- +s6$-!AZ 1-*3 +?-6K?6-! ?* E6%K?"*%a D8*/A
'67A %*KA @OOJ' HH' OGG4OdHa \R] "99!-?' )aj +$%T 7"&6!0' ea 5a
7!?$00$?-"$%&0!A A%, 7!?$00$As6$-!AZ F/! >"D!-A"?B )!/"%,
+?-6K?6-$00B @/$-$K?!-"T!, S^$390!A A%, ?/! @-6K"$0 h*0! *1
"&$%, +B33!?-Ba D8*/A '67A %*KA @O22' JM' ddQV4ddWQa \K] e-6A?B'
+aj 2$T$N"' .aj 2*A/"T$L$' 7aj @/$%,' >a .a A F-6%K$?!, 7*0!K60$-
+?$-a D8*/A !35A SA @O2T2 FH2 OIdVH4OIdHOa \,] b/$%&' Faj b/*6' a4
eaj U6*' :a4Äaj @$"' a4:aj +6%' Äa4Ea A,$9?"D! +!014AAA!3R0B $%,
X%,6K!,41"? F-$%A1*-3$?"*%A *1 A%"*%4)"%,"%& 7!?$04i-&$%"K
7$K-*KBK0!Aa Q.:A D6//3<A @O2T' N' OVWPW4OVPJHa
\OJ] \$] #$%&' 7aj b/!%&' 2a4haj U/*A/' .aj +?$%&' ea 5a
7!?$00*A69-$3*0!K60$- F!?-$&*%$0 e-"A3A D"$ 760?"K*39*%!%?
@**-,"%$?"*%4>-"D!% F!390$?!4E-!! +!014AAA!3R0Ba SA A/A D8*/A
'67A @O2O' LHF' HIWI4HIWGa \R] h",,!00' Xa Aaj +360,!-A' 7a 7a 5aj
@0!&&' 5a .aj <-"A?*D$' 2a haj )-!"%!-' )aj F/*R6-%' 5a >aj M"?AK/N!' 5a ha
A%"*%4X%,6K!, h!K*%A?"?6?"*% *1 $ +!014AAA!3R0"%& +BA?!3 ?*
S^9-!AA $ @/0*-",!4)"%,"%& @*OJ e!%?$&*%$0 e-"A3a Q.:A D8*/A
OV
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
@O2@' J' QVO4QVHa \K] 26' Uaj @**N' Fa haj "' 2aj 2$%' :aj #6' >aj +/$*'
aj +/!%' 5aj F$%&' Uaj <6$%&' Eaj @/!%' :aj +?$%&' ea 5a
F!?-$9/!%B0!?/!%!4R$A!, <"&/0B S3"AA"D! 7!?$00$K$&! $A
$
@*39*%!%? *1 F/!-$%*A?"K +69-$3*0!K60$- M$%*9$-?"K0!Aa P567A
Q.:A A7.;A '79A @O2E' LLH' OGQIJ4OGQIVa \,] i0,$K-!' Aa Maj
E-"!,3$%' Aa Saj @**N' Fa ha A +!014AAA!3R0!, @*1$K"$0 @*R$0?
e*-9/B-"% e-"A3 1*- i^B&!% h!,6K?"*% @$?$0BA"Aa SA A/A D8*/A '67A
@O2T' LHR' OdId4OdIQa
\OO] \$] A{$3"' >aj h!R!N' 5a 7*-! @/!3"A?-B "% +3$00 +9$K!Aa A77A
D8*/A %*)A @O2F' JI' PPJ4PPPa \R] b$--$' +aj #**,' >a 7aj h*R!-?A'
>a Aaj M"?AK/N!' 5a ha 7*0!K60$- K*%?$"%!-A "% K*390!^ K/!3"K$0
ABA?!3Aa D8*/A '67A %*KA @O2L' JJ' dOP4dGIa \K] 7$0' eaj )-!"%!-' )aj
h"AA$%!%' .aj M"?AK/N!' 5a ha #/"?! e/*A9/*-6A "A A"-4+?$R0! L"?/"%
$ +!014AAA!3R0!, F!?-$/!,-$0 @$9A60!a '79*<7* @OOR' HFJ' OHPQ4
OHPPa \,] <$%' 7aj 7"K/!0' haj <!' )aj @/!%' 2a4+aj +?$0N!' >aj 5*/%' 7aj
@0!D!-' Ua <a "&/?4F-"&&!-!, U6!A? C9?$N! $%, h!0!$A! RB $
e/*?*K/-*3"K @**-,"%$?"*% @$&!a A<=*CA D8*/A E<:A !;A @O2F' OF'
OGOP4OGIGa \!] e-!A?*%' >aj !L"A' 5a Saj @-*L0!B' 5a >a 760?"K$D"?B
ve,% dwI%m @$&!A L"?/ @*%?-*00!, +!&-!&$?!, )"%,"%& *1 >"11!-!%?
U6!A?Aa SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2T' LHR' IGQP4IGWHa
\OI] \$] )-*L%' @a 5aj F*A?!' Ea >aj )!-&3$%' ha Uaj h$B3*%,' .a Ma
+69-$3*0!K60$- K$?$0BA"A "% 3!?$0f0"&$%, K06A?!- /*A?Aa D8*/A %*KA
@O2L' LLO' GJOI4GJGVa \R] !!%,!-A' +a <a Aa 7aj U-$3$&!4>*-"$' haj
,! )-6"%' )aj h!!N' 5a Ma <a F-$%A"?"*% 7!?$0 @$?$0BA"A "% @*%1"%!,
+9$K!Aa D8*/A '67A %*KA @O2L' JJ' dGG4ddWa \K] e06?/' 7a >aj
)!-&3$%' ha Uaj h$B3*%,' .a Ma AK", @$?$0BA"A "% )$A"K +*06?"*%Z A
+69-$3*0!K60$- <*A? e-*3*?!A i-?/*1*-3$?! <B,-*0BA"Aa '79*<7*
@OOT' HLI' WV4WWa \,] <*L0$,!-' eaj >$A' eaj b$%&-$%,*' Saj
76N/!-{!!' ea +a C-!$4E6%K?"*%$0"T!, +!014AAA!3R0!, 7*0!K60$-
e-"A3 1*- <!?!-*&!%!*6A @$?$0BA"A "% #$?!-a SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2E'
LHN' OHHW4OHQHa
\OG] \$] ."3' >a +aj +!AA0!-' 5a a @$0"^ vdw 9B--*0!AZ D!-A$?"0!
3*0!K60$- K*%?$"%!-A L"?/ "*% ?-$%A9*-?' -!K*&%"?"*%' $%,
3*0!K60$- AL"?K/"%& 16%K?"*%Aa D8*/A '67A %*KA @O2L' JJ' VGI4VdHa
\R] @/!%' a45aj h!%' 2a42aj #6' Ma4#aj +6%' )aj 7$' 5a4Äaj b/$%&' aj F$%'
<aj "6' 7aj "' :aj 2$%&' <a4)a <"!-$-K/"K$0 +!014AAA!3R0B *1 >"AK-!?!
i-&$%*90$?"%63 \XX] 7!?$00$KBK0!A L"?/ e*0BA$KK/$-",! D"$
S0!K?-*A?$?"K X%?!-$K?"*%A $%, F/!"- A990"K$?"*% 1*- <!9$-"%
>!?!K?"*%a SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2L' LHG' OOQIV4OOQGVa \K] "6' 2aj
e!-!T' aj U"00' Aa >aj 7!??-B' 7aj "' aj #$%&' 2aj <**0!B' ha 5aj b/*%&'
#a +"?!4+!0!K?"D! +!%A"%& *1 <"A?*%! 7!?/B0$?"*% S%TB3! AK?"D"?B
D"$ $% A--$B!, +69-$3*0!K60$- F$%,!3 AAA$Ba SA A/A D8*/A '67A
@O2T' LHR' OJPHd4OJPHQa
\V] M!LN*3!' Ua haj 7**-!1"!0,' @a Ma E-*3 OÅG >!%,-"?"K
>!A"&%A
?*
E-$K?$0
+69-$3$K-*3*0!K60$-
@*%A?-6K?AZ
C%,!-A?$%,"%& ?/! e$?/L$B ?* ?/! +"!-9"ÇAN" U$AN!?a D8*/A '67A
%*KA @O2L' JJ' GPVd4GPHQa \R] M!LN*3!' Ua haj #$%&' eaj
7**-!1"!0,' @a Maj @/*' Fa 5aj 7*/$9$?-$' ea eaj "' +aj <L$%&' +a4<aj
6N*B$%*D$' iaj SK/!&*B!%' aj e$0$&$00*' 5a Aaj X$%K6' gaj <0$' +a4#a
M$%*$AA!3R0B *1 $ E-$K?$0 e*0B3!-Z A 7*0!K60$- [+"!-9"%AN"
<!^$&*%$0 U$AN!?[a '79*<7* @OOE' HLF' OQWI4OQWVa \K] #$%&' 7aj
#$%&' @aj <$*' :a4Äaj "6' 5aj "' :aj :6' @aj *9!T' Aaj +6%' aj +*%&' 7a4
eaj 2$%&' <a4)aj "' :a <!^$&*% #-!$?/AZ +!014AAA!3R0B *1 >"AK-!?!
+69-$3*0!K60$- E-$K?$0 A-K/"?!K?6-!A CA"%& 760?"?*9"K
F!-9B-","%! "&$%,Aa SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2J' LHI' HHHd4HHQOa \,]
5"$%&' baj "' 2aj #$%&' 7aj "6' >aj 26$%' 5aj @/!%' 7aj #$%&' 5aj
M!LN*3!' Ua haj +6%' #aj "' :aj #$%&' ea @*%A?-6K?"%& <"&/4
U!%!-$?"*% +"!-9"ÇAN" F-"$%&0!A RB 7*0!K60$- e6TT0"%&a A<=*CA
D8*/A E<:A !;A @O2T' OI' OOdVJ4OOdVVa \!] #$%&' aj "6' haj U6' 5aj
+*%&' )aj #$%&' <aj 5"$%&' :aj b/$%&' .aj <$%' :aj <$*' :a4Äaj )$"' +aj
#$%&' 7aj "' :aj :6' )aj "' :a +!014AAA!3R0B *1 +69-$3*0!K60$-
E-$K?$0A 1-*3 U!%!-$?"*% O ?* Va SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2S' LJM' OdJWQ4
OdJPHa
\H] \$] E*-&$%' ha +aj +$6D$&!' 5a4eaj +?*,,$-?' 5a Ea @/!3"K$0
F*9*0*&BZ @*390!^ 7*0!K60$- .%*?A' "%NA' $%, S%?$%&0!3!%?Aa
D8*/A %*KA @O22' LLL' VdGd4VdHda \R] AB3!' 5a4Eaj )!D!A' 5a Saj
@$39R!00' @a 5aj !"&/' >a Aa F!390$?! AB%?/!A"A *1 3*0!K60$- N%*?Aa
D8*/A '67A %*KA @O2F' JF' OQJJ4OQOIa \K] @/"K/$N' .a +aj @$%?-"00' +a
5aj e!$A!' Aa haj @/"6' +a4<aj @$D!' Ua #a gaj A?L**,' 5a aj +?*,,$-?' 5a Ea
7*0!K60$- )*--*3!$% h"%&Aa '79*<7* @OOJ' HMJ' OGJW4OGOIa \,]
>$%*%' 5a 5aj .-}&!-' Aaj !"&/' >a Aaj !3*%%"!-' 5a4Eaj +?!9/!%A' Aa 5aj
g"?*-"K$42-!T$R$0' Xa 5aj #*0?!-"%&' +a a )-$","%& $ 7*0!K60$- .%*?
L"?/ S"&/? @-*AA"%&Aa '79*<7* @O2T' HOO' OVP4OHIa \!] b/$%&' aj
+?!9/!%A' Aa 5aj M6AAR$63!-' Aa aj !3*%%"!-' 5a4Eaj 56-É!N' eaj
g"?*-"K$42-!T$R$0' Xa 5aj !"&/' >a Aa +?!-!*A!0!K?"D! +B%?/!A"A *1 $
@*39*A"?! .%*? L"?/ M"%! @-*AA"%&Aa Q.:A D8*/A @O2S' LM' OJWG4
OJWWa
\Q] \$] <"-$*N$' +aj <$-$%*' .aj +/"-*' 7aj iT$L$' 2aj 2$A6,$' Maj
F*-"63"' .aj +/"*%*B$' 7a XA*A?-6K?6-$0 @**-,"%$?"*% @$9A60!A 1*- $
+!-"!A *1 OJ >"11!-!%? ,Vf,OJ F-$%A"?"*%47!?$0 X*%Aa A<=*CA D8*/A
E<:A !;A @OOE' JO' HdWW4HdPOa \R] 7$0' eaj +K/60?T' >aj )!B!/' .aj
h"AA$%!%' .aj M"?AK/N!' 5a ha A% C%0*KN$R0!fh!0*KN$R0! X-*% @$&! RB
+6RK*39*%!%? +!014AAA!3R0Ba A<=*CA D8*/A E<:A !;A @OOS' JG'
WIPQ4WGJOa \K] )"0R!"A"' ha Aaj h*%A*%' Fa .aj M"?AK/N!' 5a ha A +!014
\Od] \$] >6-"AN$' 7a )aj M!D"00!' +a 7aj 6' 5aj X-!3*%&!-' +a +aj )*$A'
5a Eaj .!9!-?' @a 5aj )$??!%' +a ha +BA?!3$?"K 7!?$0 g$-"$?"*% $%,
+*0D!%? $%, <B,-*&!%4U$A +?*-$&! "% +69-$3*0!K60$- M$%*R$00Aa
A<=*CA D8*/A E<:A !;A @OOR' JN' WPOP4WPIIa \R] "' 5a4haj 2$N*D!%N*'
Aa Aaj 6' #aj F"33*%A' >a 5aj b/6$%&' #aj 26$%' >aj b/*6' <a4@a
AAA!3R0!, vE!XX OIw @$9A60! L"?/ $% XK*A$/!,-$0 E-$3!L*-Na
OI
A<=*CA D8*/A E<:A !;A @O2F' OF' PJIQ4PJGJa
\W] \$] i0!%B6N' )aj #/"?!1*-,' 5a Aaj E!K/?!%N~??!-' Aaj +?$%&' ea 5a
+!014AAA!3R0B *1 M$%*AK$0! @6R*K?$/!,-$ RB @**-,"%$?"*%
@/!3"A?-Ba Q.:35* 2RRR' GPW' QPH4QPPa \R] +K/L!"&!-' 7aj
2$3$3*?*' Faj +?$%&' ea 5aj )0|A!-' >aj )*!A!' ha +!014AAA!3R0B *1
M$%*AK$0! +69-$3*0!K60$- F-6%K$?!, F!?-$/!,-$a SA $5=A D8*/A
@OOL' GM' dWHOfdWHda \K] +6%' Äa4Eaj XL$A$' 5aj i&$L$' >aj XA/",*' 2aj
+$?*' +aj iT!N"' Faj +!"' 2aj 2$3$&6K/"' .aj E6{"?$' 7a +!014AAA!3R0!,
"&$%,
)-",&"%&4A%&0!4>-"D!%
AAA!3R0B
*1
7*0!K60$-
A-K/"?!K?6-!A )$A!, *% Ä6$,-690B )*%,!, 7*Ñ7* >"33!-Aa SA A/A
D8*/A '67A @O2O' LHF' OQVPP4OQHOJa \K] 7$"' <a >aj .$%&' eaj ."3' 5a
.aj 2**' <a A @*R$0? +69-$3*0!K60$- F-"90!4+?-$%,!, <!0"K$?!4
R$A!, >"AK-!?! 7*0!K60$- @$&!a '79A %*4A @O2T' G' dGddW4dGdVVa
\OV] \$] A/3$,' Maj 2*6%6A' <a Aaj @/6&/?$"' Aa <aj g!-9**-?' Ea
7!?$0fi-&$%"K 7*0!K60$- @$&!AZ A990"K$?"*%A *1 )"*K/!3"K$0
X390"K$?"*%Aa D8*/A '67A %*KA @O2L' JJ' P4IVa \R] #!RR!-' 7a 5aj
$%&!-' ha >-6& >!0"D!-B RB +69-$3*0!K60$- >!A"&%a D8*/A '67A %*KA
7Id e*0B/!,-$ $%, F/!"- +/$-9 +?-6K?6-$0 +L"?K/ 69*% +6R?0!
dW
"&$%, g$-"$?"*%a '79*<7* @O2O' HFN' OOdd4OOdQa \,] h"TT6?*' Ea 5aj
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Page 9 of 11
Journal of the American Chemical Society
@O2T' JI' HHJJ4HHIJa \K] +$3$%?$' +a .aj 7*%K!0!?' >aj )-"N!%' gaj
e*0B/!,-$a Q.:A D8*/A @O2O' F' WPG4WPWa \K] e$-N' 5aj +6%' a4)aj
@/!%' 2a4eaj e!--B' baj b/*6' <a4@a AT*R!%T!%!4E6%K?"*%$0"T!,
7!?$0fi-&$%"K e*0B/!,-$ 1*- ?/! i9?"K$00B h!A9*%A"D! @$9?6-! $%,
h!0!$A! *1 U6!A? 7*0!K60!Aa A<=*CA D8*/A E<:A !;A @O2J' OH' VWdI4
VWdHa
XA$$KA' a 7!?$0fi-&$%"K e*0B/!,-*% @$99!, L"?/ @6K6-R"?vWw6-"0
>!0"D!-A >*^*-6R"K"% ?* @$%K!- @!00Aa SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2E' LHW'
OddWW4OddPHa \,] #$%&' <aj Ä"$%' :aj #$%&' .aj +6' 7aj <$*B$%&' #a4
#aj 5"$%&' :aj )-T*T*LAN"' haj #$%&' 7aj U$*' :aj "' 2aj :6' )aj SAL$-$'
eaj <$*' :a4Äaj U*%&' #aj <*6' 5a4 aj @$"' 5aj "' :a +69-$3*0!K60$-
.$%,"%ANB @"-K0!A L"?/ <"&/ A%?"R$K?!-"$0 AK?"D"?Ba Q.:A D6//3<A
@O2S' R' OWOV4OWIda
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
\II] \$] 7!"!-' 7a Aaj */3!"{!-' )a Uaj +K/6R!-?' Ca +a h!0$?"D!
R"%,"%& A?-!%&?/ *1 ?!-9B-","%! 3*,!0 K*390!^!A 6%,!- 3$?-"^4
$AA"A?!, 0$A!- ,!A*-9?"*%l"*%"T$?"*% 3$AA A9!K?-*3!?-B
K*%,"?"*%Aa SA U.)) '4*7:56/A @OOF' HN' VOJ4VOHa \R] #$%&' aj
b/$%&' baj 5"$%&' :aj X-D"%' 5a Aaj "6' @aj #$%&' 7aj "' :a +!014AAA!3R0B
*1 F!?-$3!-"K $%, <!^$3!-"K F!-9B-","%!4)$A!, 7$K-*KBK0!A
CA"%& @,\XX]' b%\XX]' A%, E!\XX]a E<65=A D8*/A @O2S' OG' GVdW4GVVWa
\IG] \$] #$%&' 5a4 aj "' :aj 6' :aj <A"!/' Xa Eaj @$*' 2aj 7**-!1"!0,'
@a Maj #!A,!3"*?"A' @aj @/!%&' +a ba >aj M!LN*3!' Ua ha
+?*"K/"*3!?-"K +!014AAA!3R0B *1 +/$9!4e!-A"A?!%? I> @*390!^!AZ A
E$K"0! h*6?! ?* $ +B33!?-"K +69-$3$K-*3*0!K60$- +9*N!, #/!!0a
SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O22' LHH' OOdVJ4OOdVGa \R] #$%&' 7aj #$%&' .aj
#$%&' @aj <6$%&' 7aj <$*' :a4Äaj +/!%' 7a4baj +/"' Ua4Äaj b/$%&' baj
+*%&' )aj @"A%!-*A' Aaj +*%&' 7a4eaj :6' )aj "' :a +!014AAA!3R0B *1
@*%K!%?-"K <!^$&*%A $%, <"!-$-K/"K$0 +!014AAA!3R0B *1
+69-$3*0!K60$- 7!?$0fi-&$%"K M$%*-"RR*%A $? ?/! +*0",l "s6",
X%?!-1$K!a SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2E' LHN' PIVW4PIHWa \K] +*%&' )aj
.$%,$9$0' +aj U6' 5aj b/$%&' .aj h!!A!' Aaj 2"%&' 2aj #$%&' aj #$%&' <aj
"' 2aj #$%&' 7aj 6' +aj <$*' :a4Äaj "' :aj :6' )aj "' :a +!014AAA!3R0B
*1 e*0BKBK0"K +69-$3*0!K60!A CA"%& "%!$- 7!?$04i-&$%"K "&$%,Aa
Q.:A D6//3<A @O2S' R' dVQV4dVWda
\Id] \$] :"!' Fa4baj U6*' .aj U6*' baj U$*' #a42aj #*{?$A' aj M"%&' Ua4
<aj <6$%&' 7aj 6' :aj "' 5a42aj "$*' +a42aj @/!%' 2a4+aj 7**-!1"!0,' @a
Maj +$6%,!-A' 7a 5aj @/!%&' +a ba >aj #!A,!3"*?"A' @aj M!LN*3!' Ua ha
e-!K"A! 7*0!K60$- E"AA"*% $%, E6A"*%Z Ä6$%?"?$?"D! +!014AAA!3R0B
$%, @/!3"A?-B *1 $ 7!?$00*4@6R*K?$/!,-*%a A<=*CA D8*/A E<:A !;A
@O2L' OJ' PIId4PIIPa \R] @/!%' 7aj #$%&' 5aj "6' >aj 5"$%&' baj "6'
Äaj #6' Faj "6' <aj 26' #aj 2$%' 5aj #$%&' ea <"&/0B +?$R0! +9/!-"K$0
7!?$00*4@$9A60! 1-*3 $ )-$%K/!, <!^$9*,$0 F!-9B-","%! $%, X?A
+!014AAA!3R0!, )!--B4?B9! M$%*A?-6K?6-!a SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2S'
LJM' IVVV4IVHOa
\OH] \$] )/$?' Xa Aaj +$3$%?$' >aj 76N/!-{!!' ea +a A e,Id e-!&%$%?
7*0!K60$- M$%*R$00Z +!014F!390$?!, +?!00$?"*% RB e-!K"A! 7$99"%&
*1 @**-,"%$?"*% +"?!Aa SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2L' LHG' PdPQ4PVJIa \R]
#6' .aj "' .aj <*6' 2a45aj e$%' 7aj b/$%&' a42aj @/!%' aj +6' @a42a
<*3*K/"-$0 >d4+B33!?-"K 7!?$0fi-&$%"K @$&!A 1-*3 +?!-!*&!%"K
h6\XX] 7!?$00*0"&$%,A 1*- S11!K?"D! S%$%?"*A!9$-$?"*% *1
A?-*9"A*3!-"K 7*0!K60!Aa Q.:A D6//3<A @O2E' G' OJdWQ4OJdPQa \K]
@!K*?' Uaj 7$-3"!-' 7aj U!-!3"$' +aj >! b*-T"' haj g*0*&T/$%"%$' Aa gaj
e$??"A*%' eaj +*0$-"' Saj E$,$!" F"-$%"' Eaj +K*9!00"?"' haj +!D!-"%' .a F/!
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
X%?-"K$?! +?-6K?6-$0 @/!3"A?-B *1 7XX %4FB9! AAA!3R0"!Aa SA A/A
I%
D8*/A '67A @O2T' LHR' WGQO4WGWOa \,] U6' 2aj A0?' Sa Aaj #$%&' <aj "'
:aj #"00$-,' Aa eaj 5*/%A*%' 5a Aa e/*?*AL"?K/"%& F*9*0*&B "% e*0B3!-
M!?L*-NA L"?/ 7!?$0!i-&$%"K @$&!A $A @-*AA0"%NAa Q.:35* @O2S'
VHJ' HV4HPa \!] b/*6' baj <$6N!' @a Saj +*%&' )aj "' :aj +?$%&' ea 5aj
@**N' Fa ha C%,!-A?$%,"%& ?/! S11!K?A *1 @**-,"%$?"*% $%, +!014
AAA!3R0B *% $% S3"AA"D! e/!%*?/"$T"%!a SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2R'
LJL' GQOQ4GQIIa
\OQ] \$] .$!A' @aj .$?T' Aaj <*AA!"%"' 7a #a )"9B-","%!ZzF/! 7*A?
#",!0B CA!, "&$%,a A h!D"!L *1 7*0!K60!A @*39-"A"%& $? !$A?
FL* I'IÖ4)"9B-","%! C%"?Aa D8*/A %*KA @OOO' LMM' GVVG4GVPJa \R]
!"&/' >a Aaj e-"?K/$-,' ha Uaj +?!9/!%A' Aa 5a A +?$- *1 >$D", K$?!%$%!a
Q.:A D8*/A @O2J' I' PQW4PWIa \K] #**,' @a +aj h*%A*%' Fa .aj
)!0!%&6!-' Aa 7aj <*0A?!"%' 5a 5aj M"?AK/N!' 5a ha FL*4+?$&! >"-!K?!,
+!014AAA!3R0B *1 $ @BK0"KvGw@$?!%$%!a Q.:A D8*/A @O2L' Q' GVd4GVWa
\OW] \$] AKK*-A"' Uaj "A?*-?"' Aaj 2**A$1' .aj A-3$-*0"' Ma O'OJ4
e/!%$%?/-*0"%!AZ g!-A$?"0! )6"0,"%& )0*KNA E*- 63"%!AK!%?
7*0!K60!A' 7$?!-"$0A A%, 7!?$0 @*390!^!Aa D8*/A '67A %*Ka @OOR'
HN' OHPJ4OQJJa \R] @a ia >"!?-"K/4)6K/!KN!-' 5a U6"0/!3' @a e$AK$-,
$%, 5a4ea +$6D$&!a +?-6K?6-! *1 $ +B%?/!?"K F-!1*"0 .%*? @**-,"%$?!,
?* FL* @*99!-\X] @!%?!-Aa A<=*CA D8*/A2 E<:A !;A !<=+A2 2RRO' FR'
OOVd4OOVHa \K] Ua h$9!%%!' @a >"!?-"K/4)6K/!KN!- $%, 5a4ea
+$6D$&!a @*99!-\X]4 *- X-*%\XX]4F!390$?!, +B%?/!A"A *1 7*0!K60$-
.%*?A @*%?$"%"%& FL* F!?-$/!,-$0 *- iK?$/!,-$0 @**-,"%$?"*%
+"?!Aa SA A/A D8*/A '67A 2RRR' LFL' PPd4OJJOa
\OP] \$] <*13!"!-' <aj +K/6R!-?' Ca +a h!K!%? >!D!0*93!%?A "% ?/!
+69-$3*0!K60$- @/!3"A?-B *1 F!-9B-","%!f7!?$0 @*390!^!Aa
D8*/A '67A %*KA @OOJ' HH' GQG4GPPa \R] #"0,' Aaj #"%?!-' Aaj
+K/0}??!-' Eaj +K/6R!-?' Ca +a A,D$%K!A "% ?/! E"!0, *1 Ü4@*%{6&$?!,
I' InZHn' Io4F!-9B-","%!Aa D8*/A '67A %*KA @O22' JM' OdVP4OVOOa \K]
@/$N-$R*-?B' +aj M!LN*3!' Ua ha F!-9B-","%!4)$A!,
7!?$00*A69-$3*0!K60$- @*%A?-6K?AZ F$"0*-!, 7*%*3!-A ?* e-!K"A!
I>47*?"1A A%, G>47!?$00*K$&!Aa D8*/A '67A %*KA @O2S' JG' GPPO4
dJOHa
\IJ] \$] 7"A/-$' Aaj U69?$' ha +69-$3*0!K60$- A-K/"?!K?6-!A L"?/
eB-","%!4A3",! )$A!, "&$%,AZ >"AK-!?! 7*0!K60$- AAA!3R0"!A $%,
F/!"- A990"K$?"*%Aa &.+:6< T5.<)a' @O2J' JH' QHHW4QHWIa \R]
A-*6AA"' )a Saj b!R-!?' +aj )!A%$-,' @aj e!--*??!?' eaj <$3$K!N' 5a
h$?"*%$0 ,!A"&% *1 $ ?!-%$-B A69-$3*0!K60$- ABA?!3Z +!014$AA!3R0B
*1 9!%?$%6K0!$- 0$%?/$%",! /!0"K$?!Aa SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O22' LHH'
OJQHd4OJQHQa \K] "' :a4baj b/*6' a4eaj 2$%' a4 aj 26$%' >a4Äaj "%' @a4
+aj +6%' Äa4Ea SD*06?"*% *1 63"%!AK!%? +69-$3*0!K60$- $%?/$%",!
7I% G% @*390!^!A 1-*3 <!0"K$?!A $%, F!?-$/!,-$ ?* @6R!Aa SA A/A
D8*/A '67A @O2T' LHR' WIGQ4WIdda \,] "' :a4baj b/*6' a4eaj 2$%' a4
aj >*%&' 2a47aj )$"' ba4 aj +6%' :a4Äaj >"L6' 5aj #$%&' +aj )}%T0"' 5a4@aj
+6%' Äa4Ea A A69-$3*0!K60$- 0$%?/$%",! A!9$-$?"*% $99-*$K/ R$A!,
*% 360?"D$0!%? K**9!-$?"D! !%/$%K!3!%? *1 3!?$0 "*% A!0!K?"D"?Ba
Q.:A D6//3<A @O2S' R' VdQ4VVQa
\IV] \$] +$N$3*?*' haj #6' .a4<aj 7$?A6*N$' haj 7$!,$' <aj
2
M"A/"/$-$' <a
4@*%{6&$?!, )"A\F!-9B-","%!]7!?$0 @*390!^
7*0!K60$- #"-!Aa D8*/A '67A %*KA @O2L' JJ' QHPW4QQOda \R]
<*13!"!-' <aj <**&!%R**3' haj #*6?!-A' 7a Sa aj +K/6R!-?' Ca +a
<"&/ 7*0!K60$- #!"&/? +69-$3*0!K60$- e*0B3!-A @*%?$"%"%& )*?/
F!-9B-","%! 7!?$0 @*390!^!A $%, C-!",*9B-"3","%*%! Ä6$,-690!
<B,-*&!%4)*%,"%& C%"?A "% ?/! 7$"% @/$"%a SA A/A D8*/A '67A @OOL'
LFG' IPOG4IPIOa \K] @/!%' eaj "' Äaj U-"%,B' +aj <*0?!%4A%,!-A!%' Ma
#/"?!4 "&/?4S3"??"%& $%?/$%",! 7!?$00*&!0A L"?/ F6%$R0!
63"%!AK!%K! $%, h!D!-A"R0! +?"360"4h!A9*%A"D! e-*9!-?"!Aa SA
A/A D8*/A '67A @O2L' LHG' OOVPJ4OOVPGa \,] "' baj U6' 5aj Ä"' +aj #6'
>aj U$*' aj @/!%' baj U6*' 5aj "' :aj #$%&' 2aj 2$%&' :aj F6' 2a +/$KN0"%&
Sq!K? X%,6K!, e-*9!-?B >"q!-!%K!A "% 7!?$00*+69-$3*0!K60$-
e*0B3!-Aa SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2T' LHR' OdGHd4OdGHQa \!] .L$A%B'
7a Faj b/6' aj <"KN%!-' 7a Aaj F!L' Ua Ma F/!-3*,B%$3"KA *1
@*6%?!-"*% h!0!$A! XA @-"?"K$0 1*- A%"*% S^K/$%&! 7!3R-$%!
@*%,6K?"D"?Ba SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2S' LJM' QPHO4QPHPa
\IH] \$] "3' ba )aj "' <aj +6%' +aj !N' 5a 2aj F-!L"%' Aaj $3' 2a 7aj
U-"3A,$0!' Aa @a M!L G> +69-$3*0!K60$- b%\XX]4@**-,"%$?!, +!014
AAA!3R0!, i-&$%"K M!?L*-NAa SA U.:*5A D8*/A2 @O2@' FF' HIOW4
HIGOa \R] E!-3"' Aaj )!-&$3"%"' Uaj h*B' 7aj U"%&-$A' 7aj @!-*%"' ea
F6-%4*% e/*A9/*-!AK!%K! RB 7!?$0 @**-,"%$?"*% ?* $ 760?"D$0!%?
F!-9B-","%! "&$%,Z A M!L e$-$,"&3 1*- 63"%!AK!%? +!%A*-Aa SA
A/A D8*/A '67A @O2J' LHI' HGPV4HdJJa \K] "%' baj F/$KN!-' Ma @aj
+$L$%*' Faj >-$N!' Faj 5"' eaj $%' Uaj @$*' aj "6' +aj #$%&' @aj "%' #a
7!?$04i-&$%"K $B!-A +?$R"0"T! S$-?/4AR6%,$%? 7!?$04F!-9B-","%!
>"-$,"K$0 @*390!^!A 1*- @$?$0B?"K @f< AK?"D$?"*%a D8*/A '79A @O2S'
R' OdG4OVOa
\IQ] \$] E6' 5a4<aj !!' 2a4<aj <!' 2a45aj @/$%' 2a4Fa E$K"0! +!014
AAA!3R0B *1 7!?$00*4+69-$3*0!K60$- h"%&4"%4h"%& $%, +9",!-L!R
+?-6K?6-!A CA"%& 760?"D$0!%? F!-9B-","%! "&$%,Aa A<=*CA D8*/A
E<:A !;A @O2L' OJ' HIGO4HIGVa \R] #$%&' +a42aj E6' 5a4<aj "$%&' 2a4eaj
<!' 2a45aj @/!%' 2a4+aj @/$%' 2a4Fa 7!?$00*4+69-$3*0!K60$- +!014
\IO] \$] F-$%K/!3*%?$&%!' >a 5aj M"' baj iY.!!11!' 7aj 2$&/"' ia 7a
h!?"K60$- @/!3"A?-B *1 7!?$0fi-&$%"K e*0B/!,-$a A<=*CA D8*/A E<:A
!;A @OOS' JG' VOGH4VOdQa \$] "' 5a4haj b/*6' <a4@a )-",&"%&40"&$%,4
A6RA?"?6?"*% A?-$?!&B 1*- ?/! e-!9$-$?"*% i1 7!?$0fi-&$%"K
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 10 of 11
AAA!3R0B *1 $ 760?"K*39*%!%? >"?-"&*% )$A!, *% @*390!3!%?$-B
S%$%?"*-!A*06?"*% *1 <*3*K/"-$0 E!\XX]fe,\XX] @**-,"%$?"*% @$&!A
F!-9B-","%! "&$%, e$"-"%&a SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2E' LHN' GHVO4
GHVda \K] "' 2aj 5"$%&' baj #$%&' 7aj 26$%' 5aj "6' >aj 2$%&' :aj @/!%'
7aj 2$%' 5aj "' :aj #$%&' ea U"$%?' <*00*L I> 7!?$00*$-K/"?!K?6-!Z
+?!9L"A! +!014AAA!3R0B *1 $ <!^$&*%$0 +69-$3*0!K60$- M6?a SA A/A
D8*/A '67A @O2E' LHN' OJJdO4OJJdHa \,] 5"$%&' baj "' 2aj #$%&' 7aj
+*%&' )aj #$%&' .aj +6%' 7aj "6' >aj "' :aj 26$%' 5aj @/!%' 7aj U6*' 2aj
2$%&' :aj b/$%&' Faj 7**-!1"!0,' @a Maj M!LN*3!' Ua haj :6' )aj "' :aj
#$%&' ea +!014AAA!3R0B *1 $ +69-$3*0!K60$- <!^$&-$3 $%, $
+69-$3*0!K60$- e!%?$&-$3a Q.:A D6//3<A @O2T' N' OVdQH4OVdWVa
\IW] \$] :"!' Fa4baj "$*' +a42aj U6*' .aj 6' :aj >*%&' :aj <6$%&' 7aj
7**-!1"!0,' @a Maj @/!%&' +a ba >aj "6' :aj #!A,!3"*?"A' @aj M!LN*3!'
Ua ha @*%A?-6K?"*% *1 $ <"&/0B +B33!?-"K M$%*A9/!-! D"$ $ i%!4e*?
h!$K?"*% *1 $ F-"A?!-9B-","%! "&$%, L"?/ h6\XX]a SA A/A D8*/A '67A
@O2J' LHI' WOHV4WOHWa \R] 6,0*L' 5a 7aj U6*' baj +K/60?T' Aaj +$-N$-'
haj 7**-!1"!0,' @a Maj #!A,!3"*?"A' @aj M!LN*3!' Ua ha U-*69 W
7!?$00*3$K-*KBK0!A f +B%?/!A"A' @/$-$K?!-"T$?"*%' $%, +?$R"0"?Ba
!35A SA E<65=A D8*/A @O2L' FMLO' VHHI4VHHWa
1-*3 +?!-!*0$R"0! 7!?$00*0"&$%,AZ +?!-!*K/!3"K$0 +?$R"0"?B $%,
S%$%?"*A!0!K?"D! +!9$-$?"*%a SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2S' LJM' OWOWG4
OWOPOa
\Gd] E6{"?$' >aj F$N$/$A/"' Aaj +$?*' +aj E6{"?$' 7a +!014AAA!3R0B *1
e?\XX] +9/!-"K$0 @*390!^!A g"$ F!39*-$-B $R"0"T$?"*% *1 ?/!
7!?$0f "&$%, AAA*K"$?"*% "% I'I'I4F-"106*-*!?/$%*0a SA A/A D8*/A
'67A @O22' LHH' OGGOQ4OGGOPa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
\GV] \$] +K$-11' @a Aaj +%!00"%&' 5a haj .%6A?' 7a 7aj #"0N"%A' @a aj
+K-"D!%A' 5a <a M!L +?-6K?6-$0 X%A"&/?A "%?* 7!K/$%"K$00B
X%?!-0*KN!, e*0B3!-A h!D!$0!, RB X*% 7*R"0"?B 7$AA
+9!K?-*3!?-Ba SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2@' LHJ' POPG4POPWa \R] +/"' aj
<*00",$B' Aa Saj +/"' <aj b/6' Eaj SL"%&' 7a Aaj h6AA!00' >a <aj @0!33!-'
>a Sa @/$-$K?!-"T"%& X%?!-3!,"$?!A A0*%& ?/! F-$%A"?"*% 1-*3
e*0B9-*0"%! X ?* e*0B9-*0"%! XX CA"%& X*% 7*R"0"?B +9!K?-*3!?-B4
7$AA +9!K?-*3!?-Ba SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2J' LHI' OIQJI4OIQOOa
\GH] \$] @/*L' <a +aj @*%A?$R0!' Sa @aj <*6A!K-*1?' @a Saj .60"KN!' .a
5aj F$*' 2a #/!% S0!K?-*% S^K/$%&! XA @/!3"K$0 S^K/$%&!f
AAA"&%3!%? *1 O< M7h +9!K?-$ *1 e$-$3$&%!?"K @*R$0?\X"]4
I'InZHn'Io4F!-9B-","%! @*390!^!Aa &.+:6< T5.<)A2 @OOL' F' IGH4IGQa
\R] @*%A?$R0!' Sa @aj <$--"A' .aj <*6A!K-*1?' @a Saj M!6R6-&!-' 7aj
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
\IP] \$] >$D"A' Aa gaj 2!/' ha 7aj h$B3*%,' .a Ma +69-$3*0!K60$-
AAA!3R0B >B%$3"KAa P567A Q.:+A A7.;A '79A VA'AAA @OO@2 RR2 dQPG4
dQPHa \R] !/%' 5a47a E-*3 +69-$3*0!K60$- @/!3"A?-B F*L$-,A
@*%A?"?6?"*%$0 >B%$3"K @/!3"A?-B $%, A,$9?"D! @/!3"A?-Ba D8*/A
'67A %*KA @OOT' HI' OVO4OHJa
b$39!A!' 5a Aa F6-%"%& à7\F9B]Iâ%m S3R-$K!A $%, @<ä
2
X%?!-$K?"*%A *% $%, *11 "% <*3*0!9?"K @*R$0?\XX] $%, @*R$0?\XXX]
)"A\I'InZHn'Io4F!-9B-","%!] @*390!^!Aa D51):!<=D6// @O2O' LF'
IPdP4IPHOa
\GJ] \$] <"-$*N$' +aj F$%$N$' Faj +/"*%*B$' 7a S0!K?-*A?$?"K$00B
@*%?-*00!, <"!-$-K/"K$0 A--$%&!3!%? *1 7*%*K$?"*%"K +"0D!-\X] $%,
>"K$?"*%"K 7!-K6-B\XX] X*%A R!?L!!% >"AN4+/$9!, F!390$?!
"&$%,Aa SA A/A D8*/A '67A @OOE' LFN' OGJGW4OGJGPa \R] FA6{"3*?*'
2aj .*{"3$' Faj <"-$*N$' +a h$?!4>!?!-3"%"%& +?!9 "% ?/! +!014
AAA!3R0B e-*K!AA *1 +69-$3*0!K60$- @**-,"%$?"*% @$9A60!Aa D8*/A
'79A @O2J' O' dOHQ4dOQIa \K] )$R$' Aaj .*{"3$' Faj <"-$*N$' +a +!014
AAA!3R0B e-*K!AA *1 >*,!K$%6K0!$- e?\XX]4 "%N!, @BK0"K <!^$&*%a
SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2L' LHG' QHHd4QHHQa \,] #6' .aj "' .aj <*6' 2a4
5aj e$%' 7aj b/$%&' a42aj @/!%' aj +6' @a42a <*3*K/"-$0 >d4+B33!?-"K
7!?$0fi-&$%"K @$&!A E-*3 +?!-!*&!%"K h6\XX] 7!?$00*0"&$%,A 1*-
S11!K?"D! S%$%?"*A!9$-$?"*% *1 A?-*9"A*3!-"K 7*0!K60!Aa Q.:A
D6//3<A @O2E' Q' OJdWQa \!] .*3"%!' +aj F$N$/$A/"' +aj .*{"3$' Faj
+$?*' <aj <"-$*N$' +a +!014AAA!3R0B e-*K!AA!A *1 iK?$/!,-*%4
+/$9!, e,H d @$&!Aa SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2R' LJL' GOQW4GOWHa
\GO] \$] b/!%&' 2a4haj +?$%&' ea 5a >"-!K? $%, Ä6$%?"?$?"D!
@/$-$K?!-"T$?"*% *1 >B%$3"K "&$%, S^K/$%&! R!?L!!%
@**-,"%$?"*%4>-"D!% +!014AAA!3R0!, +69-$3*0!K60$- e*0B&*%Aa SA
A/A D8*/A '67A @OOR' LHL' GdWQ4GdWPa \R] +$?*' +aj XA/",*' 2aj E6{"?$'
7a h!3$-N$R0! +?$R"0"T$?"*% *1 7OI Id +9/!-"K$0 E-$3!L*-NA
?/-*6&/ ?/! @**9!-$?"*% *1 dW e,\XX]4eB-","%! X%?!-$K?"*%Aa SA A/A
D8*/A '67A @OOR' LHL' HJHd4HJHVa \K] 5"$%&' #aj +K/|1!-' Aaj 7*/-'
ea @aj +K/$00!B' @a Aa 7*%"?*-"%& +!014+*-?"%& RB S0!K?-*A9-$B
X*%"T$?"*% 7$AA +9!K?-*3!?-BZ E*-3$?"*% X%?!-3!,"$?!A $%,
S--*-4@*--!K?"*% ,6-"%& ?/! +!014AAA!3R0B *1 760?"90B F/-!$,!,
eA!6,*-*?$^$%!Aa SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2O' LHF' IGJP4IGIJa \,]
AB3!' 5a4Eaj )!D!A' 5a Saj @$39R!00' @a 5aj !"&/' >a Aa e-*R"%& ?/!
>B%$3"KA *1 ?/! X3"%!4)$A!, e!%?$1*"0 .%*? $%, e!%?$3!-"K
@"-K60$- <!0"K$?! AAA!3R0Ba SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2R' LJL'
GHJVÑGHOIa
\GI] \$] )$--!??' Sa +aj >$0!' Fa 5aj h!R!N' 5a +!014AAA!3R0B
>B%$3"KA *1 $ @B0"%,-"K$0 @$9A60! 7*%"?*-!, RB E06*-!AK!%K!
h!A*%$%K! S%!-&B F-$%A1!-a SA A/A D8*/A '67A @OOT' LFR' WWOW4
WWIda \R] )$--!??' Sa +aj >$0!' Fa 5aj h!R!N' 5a +?$R"0"?B' >B%$3"KA' $%,
+!0!K?"D"?B "% ?/! AAA!3R0B *1 <B,-*&!%4)*%,!, <!^$3!-"K
@$9A60!Aa SA A/A D8*/A '67A @OOS' LHM' IGdd4IGVJa \K] <6$%&' @a4)aj
:6' aj b/6' 5a4 aj #$%&' 2a4:aj +6%' )aj "' :aj 2$%&' <a4)a h!$04F"3!
7*%"?*-"%& ?/! >B%$3"KA *1 @**-,"%$?"*%4>-"D!% +!014AAA!3R0B RB
E06*-!AK!%K!4h!A*%$%K! S%!-&B F-$%A1!-a SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2T'
LHR' PdVP4PdHIa
\GG] \$] )$A*0*' Eaj <$B!A' 5a @aj M!63$%%' <a 7a 7!K/$%"A3 *1
h$K!3"T$?"*% *1 @*390!^ X*%Aa XXa ."%!?"KA *1 ?/! >"AA*K"$?"*% $%,
h$K!3"T$?"*% *1 F-"A4\O'OJ49/!%$%?/-*0"%!]4"-*%\XX] $%, F-"A4
\I'Iá4,"9B-",B0]4"-*%\XX] @*390!^!Aa SA A/A D8*/A '67A 2RLJ' QH'
GWJQÑGWJPa \R] <*6' 2a45aj #6' .aj #!"' ba4#aj "' .aj 6' 2a4 aj b/6'
@a42aj #$%&' 5a4+aj e$%' 7aj 5"$%&' 5a45aj "' Ua4Äaj +6' @a42a >!A"&% $%,
\GQ] \$] U"6A!99*%!' Maj +K/3"??' 5a4 aj A00*6K/!' aj !/%' 5a47a
>i+2 M7h S^9!-"3!%?A $A
$ F**0 1*- ?/! A%$0BA"A *1
@*%A?"?6?"*%$0$%, 7*?"*%$0 >B%$3"K e-*K!AA!AZ X390!3!%?$?"*%
1*- ?/! >-"D!%SD*06?"*% *1 >B%$3"K @*3R"%$?*-"$0 "R-$-"!A *1
<!0"K$0 +?-$%,Aa A<=*CA D8*/A E<:A !;A @OOS' JG' IIGV4IIGPa \R]
+K/60T!' )a 7aj #$?N"%A' >a aj b/$%&' 5aj U/"D"-"&$' Xaj @$A?!00$%*' ha
.a SA?"3$?"%& ?/! A/$9! $%, A"T! *1 A69-$3*0!K60$- $AA!3R0"!A RB
D$-"$R0! ?!39!-$?6-! ,"116A"*% *-,!-!, A9!K?-*AK*9Ba $5=A W96/6+A
D8*/A @O2J' LF' QPGI4QPGHa \K] b/$%&' baj #$%&' <aj #$%&' :aj "' 2aj
+*%&' )aj )*0$-"%L$' iaj h!!A!' ha Aaj b/$%&' Faj #$%&' :a4Äaj @$"' 5aj
:6' )aj #$%&' 7aj "6' @aj 2$%&' <a4)aj "' :a +69!-A%*L10$N!AZ
+?!9L"A! +!014AAA!3R0B $%, >B%$3"K S^K/$%&! *1 h/*3R6A +?$-4
+/$9!, +69-$3*0!K60!Aa SA A/A D8*/A '67a @O2T' LHR' WOQd4WOWVa
\GW] \$] :6' :a4>aj 2$*' @a45aj @/!%' a45aj 2"%' Ua4Äaj b/*%&' 2a4#aj
2$%&' <a4)a E$K"0! @*%A?-6K?"*% *1 +?-6K?6-$00B >!1"%!, e*-*6A
7!3R-$%!A 1-*3 +69-$3*0!K60$- <!^$N"A?-"9/!%B0$3"%!
7!?$00$KBK0!A ?/-*6&/ S0!K?-*9*0B3!-"T$?"*%a D8*/A !35A SA @O2E'
FF' VIOO4VIOWa \R] 7$!,$' <aj +$N$3*?*' haj M"A/"/$-$' <a 7!?$0
@*390!^ i0"&*3!- $%, e*0B3!- #"-!A *% S0!K?-*,!AZ F$K?"K$0
@*%A?-6K?"*%A $%, g!-A$?"0! E6%K?"*%$0"?"!Aa P6+1/*5 @O2F' OJ'
dGWG4ddJda \K] S0&-"A/"' Maj @/$3R!-A' 7a )aj A-?!-*' gaj E*%?!K$D!'
7a F!-9B-","%! @*390!^!A *1 E"-A? h*L F-$%A"?"*% 7!?$0A $%,
S0!K?-*K/!3"K$0 h!,6K?"*% *1 @iI ?* @ia P81)AD8*/AD8*/AP81)A2
@O2J' LI' OGHGV4OGHdda \,] F$06N,$-' .aj XAA$' Aaj 56-AA' 5a #a
+B%?/!A"A *1 $ h!,*^4AK?"D! MMe4FB9! e"%K!- "&$%, $%, X?A
A990"K$?"*% ?* S0!K?-*K$?$0B?"K @iI h!,6K?"*% L"?/ E"-A?4h*L
F-$%A"?"*% 7!?$0 @*390!^!Aa @O2R' G' O4OOa
\GP] \$] e!-!-$' +aj "' :aj +*0!-' 7aj +K/60?T' Aaj #!A,!3"*?"A' @aj
7**-!1"!0,' @a Maj M!LN*3!' Ua ha <!^$3!-"K e$00$,"63\XX]
F!-9B-",B0 7!?$00*3$K-*KBK0!AZ AAA!3R0B L"?/ d'dn4)"9B-","%!
$%, @/$-$K?!-"T$?"*% RB F#X7 7$AA +9!K?-*3!?-Ba A<=*CA D8*/A
E<:A !;A @O2O' JR' HVGP4HVdda \R] "' :aj @/$%' 2a4Faj M!LN*3!' Ua haj
#!A,!3"*?"A' @a U-$,"!%? F$%,!3 7$AA +9!K?-*3!?-B X%?!-1$K!,
L"?/ X*% 7*R"0"?B +!9$-$?"*% 1*- ?/! @/$-$K?!-"T$?"*% *1
+69-$3*0!K60$- A-K/"?!K?6-!Aa A<.+A D8*/A @O22' NH' OIWd4OIPJa
\K] +*%&' )aj b/$%&' baj #$%&' .aj <A6' @a4<aj )*0$-"%L$' iaj #$%&' 5aj
"' 2aj 2"%' Ua4Äaj h"D!-$' Saj 2$%&' <a4)aj "6' @aj :6' )aj "' :a >"-!K?
+!014AAA!3R0B *1 $ I> $%, G> +?$- *1 >$D",a A<=*CA D8*/A E<:A !;A
@O2T' OI' VIVW4VIHIa
\dJ] \$] +$??!-1"!0,' 7aj )-*,R!0?' 5a +a h!0$?"D! )"%,"%& S%!-&"!A
*1 U$A4e/$A! eB-",B0 "&$%,l7!?$0 @*390!^!A RB S%!-&B4g$-"$R0!
@*00"A"*%$00B AK?"D$?!, >"AA*K"$?"*% "% $ Ä6$,-69*0! X*% F-$9a
E<65=A D8*/A @OO2' JM' VGPG4VdJJa \R] <*&&' haj #"0N"%A' ha Ua
S^K/$%&! +?6,"!A *1 @!-?$"% @/!0$?! @*39*6%,A *1 ?/! F-$%A"?"*%
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Page 11 of 11
Journal of the American Chemical Society
7!?$0Aa gXXXa I'In'Io4F!-9B-","%! @*390!^!Aa SA D8*/A '67a 2RE@' M'
\dO] )6-N!' 7a 5aj M"K/*0' Ua +aj 6ARB' ea 5a i-?/*&*%$0 +!0!K?"*%
$%, E"^"%& *1 @**-,"%$?"*% +!014AAA!3R0B e$?/L$BA 1*- h*R6A?
7!?$00*4*-&$%"K S%A!3R0! @*%A?-6K?"*%a SA A/A D8*/A '67A @O2E'
LHN' PGJW4PGOVa
GdO4GVJa \K] <*0B!-' ha <aj <6RR$-,' @a >aj .!??0!' +a Ea Aaj #"0N"%A' ha
Ua F/! ."%!?"KA *1 h!90$K!3!%? h!$K?"*%A *1 @*390!^!A *1 ?/!
F-$%A"?"*% 7!?$0A L"?/ I'IY'I[4F!-9B-","%!a E<65=A D8*/a 2REE' O'
HII4HIVa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
!UBVW!&! "V$
9
!"#$%&'(!) *+,+! -#.!/("($! 0+".1 $!/ (!"$ -+#23#(%(!+45./+%
*&2#.6$1+'&1+/7 *+184A//+6913 .!% :3!.6(' ;().!% <='>.!)+ *"&%3
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
!" #$%&'( )* +*%&'( +$%,-$ ./$0"1!'( 2"3"%& "'( "456%! 7"%&'( +/" )$"'8 2$9"%& :6'; <$* 26'; 7"%&
#$%&'; <!%& #$%&'='( $%, :"$*9!%& "='(
ACS Paragon Plus Environment