.
Angewandte
Communications
(Figure 4). By contrast, compound 7 was not susceptible to
derivatization by benzyl azide, which indicates the absence of
a terminal alkyne moiety. By using preparative HPLC, we
achieved the isolation of trace amounts of this compound,
which finally allowed its structural elucidation. 13C NMR
analysis clearly revealed that the terminal triple bond was
missing. Instead, the presence of a methyl carbon atom and an
additional methine carbon atom was noticed; a chemical shift
of d = 56.7 ppm for C-17 pointed to proximity to an oxygen
atom. H,H-COSY coupling of the methyl protons H-18 and
H-17 and HMBC coupling of H-18 and H-17 with C-16 and C-
posed as defensive chemicals, since most polyynes possess
strong antimicrobial properties.[2,5b] The discovery of the
molecular basis of polyyne biosynthesis in bacteria will now
help in the identification of further bacterial polyacetylenes
by genome mining and may thus lead to a better under-
standing of their ecological function.
In conclusion, we have identified the first biosynthesis
gene cluster coding for a polyyne biosynthetic pathway in
bacteria. A crucial role for novel desaturase genes in bacterial
polyyne formation was revealed, and these enzymes seem to
have evolved independent of the equivalent genes known
from plant metabolism. Bacterial polyyne pathways appear to
be rare but comparative genome analyses unveiled numerous
orthologues in diverse bacteria, and through metabolic
profiling, we verified that the important phytopathogen B.
gladioli produces caryoynencin too. Knowledge of the
molecular basis of bacterial polyyne biosynthesis and the
discovery of several polyyne biosynthesis gene clusters will
greatly aid functional studies and set the basis for the
genomics-based discovery of new bacterial polyynes. To
tackle the challenging handling of fragile polyynes, we
successfully employed an in situ click reaction. Although
Huisgen azide-alkyne cycloadditions have been used for the
chemical derivatization of biomolecules and their chemical
derivatives,[21] this is the first report of the successful trapping
of highly reactive polyynes from the crude metabolite mixture
of a microbial culture. This generally applicable approach
enabled the isolation and full characterization of the polyyne
natural products, thus providing spectral data that is other-
wise difficult or impossible to retrieve. As a proof of concept,
we could rigorously determine the structures of a tetrayne
pathway intermediate from a targeted knockout mutant
(DcayG) and elucidate the absolute configuration of caryoy-
nencin. Furthermore, analysis of the metabolites of the
mutant revealed that a cytochrome P450 monooxygenase
plays a key role in the formation of the allylic alcohol residue
of caryoynencin and that the presence of a terminal alkyne
residue is not crucial for bioactivity. These results thus not
only shed light on bacterial polyyne biosynthesis but also
demonstrate the power of combining synthetic methods and
genetics to analyze the biosynthesis of highly reactive path-
way intermediates.
15, respectively, finally established the structure of
7
(Figure 4). The discovery of an alcohol residue in lieu of
a triple bond can be rationalized by the mechanistic link
between hydroxylation and desaturation.[16] Alcohol 7 thus
likely represents a shunt product of terminal alkyne forma-
tion.
It is remarkable that the deletion of the cytochrome P450
enzyme (CayG) results in the accumulation of compounds
lacking not only the hydroxy group but also one double bond.
To test whether CayG could belong to the family of CYP450
desaturases, we performed a phylogenetic analysis including
representatives from secondary metabolite pathways (see the
Supporting Information). CayG is most closely related to
polyketide tailoring enzymes, in particular to the multifunc-
tional CYP450 monooxygenase AurH[17] from the aureothin
pathway, and it is only remotely related to studied CYP450
desaturases from plants and yeasts. However, in geldanamy-
cin biosynthesis, deletion of a CYP450 monooxygenase gene
(gdmP) leads to the accumulation of a dihydro variant of
geldanamycin, which suggests that GdmP acts as a desatur-
ase.[18] By analogy, CayG could introduce the double bond by
desaturation or through
a
hydroxylation–dehydration
sequence (potentially leading to the observed E/Z-isomers),
followed by hydroxylation at the allylic position (Scheme S1).
This model is in agreement with reported cases of competing
desaturation and hydroxylation by CYP450 enzymes.[19]
In terms of bioactivity, it is surprising that 5b, in which the
terminal alkyne was converted into a triazole moiety, is still
active in antibacterial assays (minimum inhibitory concen-
tration (MIC): B. subtilis 3.12 mgmLÀ1, 7.6 mm; MRSA
12.5 mgmLÀ1, 30.3 mm). This finding contrasts with earlier
studies on structure–activity relationships, carried out with
synthetic model compounds, which suggested that the termi-
nal alkyne is indispensable for the antibacterial activity.[6]
The discovery of the novel polyyne biosynthesis gene
cluster in three plant-pathogenic Burkholderia spp. raises the
question of how widespread related gene clusters are amongst
other bacteria. In a broader genome-mining analysis, we
found six orthologous gene clusters in other bacterial species
from the genera Burkholderia, Pseudomonas, Collimonas,
and Mycobacterium (Figure S3). This result is particularly
interesting since many Burkholderiales and Pseudomonales
live in close association with eukaryotes and their metabolic
capabilities are often essential for the eukaryotic partner.[20]
The potent antibacterial activity of 3 and the specific
occurrence of polyyne gene clusters among these genera
may suggest an ecological function for the producing organ-
isms. In plants and insects, polyacetylenes have been pro-
Received: March 14, 2014
Published online: && &&, &&&&
Keywords: biosynthesis · caryoynencin · click chemistry ·
.
polyynes · transposon mutagenesis
[1] a) M. Brøndsted Nielsen, F. Diederich, Chem. Rec. 2002, 2, 189 –
[4] a) W. L. Parker, M. L. Rathnum, V. Seiner, W. H. Trejo, P. A.
4
ꢀ 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2014, 53, 1 – 6
These are not the final page numbers!