368
CANADIAN JOURNAL OF ANESTHESIA
AIN is an integral part of life and, as such,
attempts to relieve pain must be as old as
human-kind. Some of the earliest pharmaco-
logical methods of pain relief included the
1 ounce powder of cinnamon, and 1 ounce powder of
cloves.6 Sydenham’s laudanum was used in Europe
and North America into the early 20th century.
Several other opioid preparations were popular in the
18th and 19th centuries. “Black-drop”, otherwise
known as Lancaster or Quaker’s Black Drop, con-
tained opium, verjuice, nutmeg, saffron and yeast, and
was reputedly three times stronger than laudanum.
Paregoric was a weaker preparation, named after the
Greek word for “soothing” or “consoling” and
included opium, honey, licorice root, camphor,
aniseed and wine. Dover’s powder, first developed by
the English physician and buccaneer Thomas Dover
(1660-1742), contained opium, salt peter, tartar,
licorice and ipecacuanha.7 Dover claimed, “In two or
three hours at furthest the patient will be free from
pain”. In addition to producing his opium-containing
“sweating powder”, Thomas Dover was the second
captain aboard the privateer Duke that rescued
Alexander Selkirk (Robinson Crusoe) from one of the
Juan Fernández islands in 1709.
The first record of postoperative analgesia was the
use of opium in 1784 by the Glasgow-born London
surgeon James Moore (1763-1834). He clearly real-
ized the limitations of opium for surgical anesthesia,
but praised its postoperative benefits when he wrote:
“Opium...is highly expedient to abate the smarting of
the wound after the operation is over, and to induce
sleep; but the strongest dose we dare venture to give
has little or no effect in mitigating the suffering of the
patient during the operation”.8 In the same year,
Moore also devised an appliance for compression of
nerves producing numbness in a limb before surgery,
presumably by neuropraxia.8
P
plant derivatives: alcohol, cannabis, mandrake, and
opium.1 These analgesics were used for surgical anal-
gesia as long as 2500 yr ago. For example, in the
ancient Indian work the Sushruta Samhita, written
perhaps as early as 400 BC, it was advised that alcohol
be used before surgery to produce insensibility to
pain.2 Dioscorides (Circa 54-58 AD), a Greek physi-
cian and surgeon, recommended patients should take
mandrake mixed with wine before limb amputation:
“For such as cannot sleep, or are grievously pained,
and upon whom being cut, or cauterized they wish to
make a not-feeling pain”.3 Celsus (AD 14-37) in De
Medicina suggests the use of opium before surgery.4
In the Middle Ages, Theodoric, a 13th century monk
and physician, described the spongia somnifera, a mix-
ture of several narcotic substances including, opium,
mandrake, henbane, mulberry, lettuce and hemlock,
all boiled within a sponge, which was then sniffed to
provide anesthesia for surgery.5
Despite the widespread use of these compounds for
surgery there were no concomitant descriptions of
their application for pain relief after surgery, although
it seems logical they would have been so employed.
Only opium and related compounds are still used as
analgesics. The evolution of opium and its derivative
morphine for postoperative pain relief will be
reviewed.
Opium
Opium has been known for millennia to relieve pain
and its use for surgical analgesia has been recorded for
several centuries as noted above. However, its use as
an agent for postoperative pain relief has only been
described since the late 18th century, although it may
have previously been used for this purpose but not
recorded. Over the past two centuries, opium and its
derivatives have emerged as the most effective anal-
gesics for postoperative pain relief.
Five years later, the Scottish surgeon, Benjamin Bell
(1749-1806) also found opium compounds to be
good postoperative analgesics: “In general they prove
most useful when given immediately after, when they
very commonly alleviate that pungent soreness of
which patients at this time usually complain; and by
continuing to give them in adequate doses from time
to time, we are often enabled to keep the patient easy
and comfortable....9
Oral administration
Analgesia following laparotomy was first described
by Ephraim McDowell (1771-1830) in May of 1816.
McDowell gave “...a wine glass full of cherry bounce,
and thirty drops of laudanum...” to a woman follow-
ing laparotomy and surgical removal of a six pound
ovarian tumour, following which she recovered
uneventfully.1 0 Of the five cases of laparotomy and
ovariotomy in his two reports, this was the only one in
which McDowell recorded using postoperative anal-
gesia.10,11
Laudanum, or tincture of opium, was a mixture of
opium, alcohol, and various other ingredients. It was
often given in whiskey or rum and became a widely
used agent to prepare patients for surgery until the
discovery of effective anesthesia. There were many
recipes for laudanum, the most famous being that of
Thomas Sydenham (1624-89). Sydenham’s recipe,
given in his work on dysentery in 1669, contained 1
pound sherry wine, 2 ounces opium, 1 ounce saffron,