Communications
after 18 h. The observed compo-
sition of 30:26:40:4 for the four
amine diastereomers 3a–3d
clearly shows a low enantioselec-
tivity in the amination reaction.
Remarkably, the ratios of the
(1R)- to the (1S)-amines of 30:26
and 40:4 indicate that ATA-Vfl in-
troduces the amino group with
R enantiopreference (see below;
Figure S4A and B in the Sup-
porting Information). This is in
contrast with the well-docu-
Scheme 1. The combination of an ERED with an ATA in a cascade reaction enables access to optically pure
1-amino-3-methylcyclohexanes. Glucose dehydrogenase (GDH) can be used for cofactor recycling in the ERED-cat-
alyzed reaction, whereas lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) and GDH allow a shift of the equilibrium in the ATA-cata-
lyzed reaction. Note that different combinations of EREDs and ATAs with complementary enantiopreferences are
required to obtain all four diastereomers. The boxed diastereomers were obtained in this study.
mented[16]
S enantiopreference
of ATA-Vfl and the previously re-
ported high S selectivity in the
conversion of the related six-
membered cyclic ketone methyl
and with high enantioselectivity, preferentially regardless of
the configuration of the 3-methyl group. Enoate reductases,
which are flavin-mononucleotide-containing (FMN-containing)
NAD(P)H-dependent oxidoreductases, are well known to con-
vert a/b-unsaturated ketones or aldehydes into the corre-
sponding enantiopure compounds.[10] ATAs introduce amine
groups, often with excellent enantioselectivities,[7b,11] into a
wide range of ketones, but enantioselectivity drops drastically
if the size difference between the two substituents on either
side of the carbonyl group is too small or if the ketones are
small cyclic molecules such as our target ketone 2. If (dia)ste-
reoselectivity is not sufficient for a ketone bearing a chiral
center in the a- or b-position, this can in principle be improved
by protein engineering. One example was shown by Limanto
et al., who used ATA to convert 2-[2-(3,4-dimethoxyphenyl)-
ethoxy]cyclohexanone;[6a] after three rounds of evolution selec-
tive enzymes for both chiral centers were found.
(3-oxocyclohexyl)acetate.[8] Obviously, the type and size of sub-
stituents at the b-position in a cyclic ketone such as 2 strongly
influence enantioselectivity and -preference in the amination
reaction.
To identify amino acid positions governing enantioselectivity,
we modeled the internal aldimine intermediate of 2 into the
structure of ATA-Vfl by using YASARA[17] (Figure 1A). From
visual inspection, we chose Leu56 as target for mutagenesis
because its side chain would be in contact with the methyl
substituent in the PLP intermediates of 3b and 3c, so muta-
tions of Leu56 might induce a change in selectivity. Analysis of
the amino acid distribution at position 56 by use of the 3DM
database[14] identified six amino acids (Ile, Val, Ala, Trp, Tyr, Phe)
besides leucine as most frequently occurring in PLP fold type I
proteins (Figure 1B). In a subset containing only subfamilies
harboring S-selective ATA sequences, leucine is found in 90%
of the sequences. These six mutants were generated by Mega-
Whop PCR, overexpressed in E. coli Bl21 (DE3), and purified by
His-tag affinity chromatography (Figures S1–S3). Only the
Leu56Ile, Leu56Val, and Leu56Ala mutants showed sufficient
activity. Because of its lower activity, in combination with enan-
tioselectivities that were similar to those of the Leu56Val
mutant, the Leu56Ala mutant was also excluded.
The aim of this work was to demonstrate the applicability of
the envisioned cascade and, in this context, to identify enan-
tiocomplementary ATAs, preferably with high stereoselectivity
towards 2. Identification of suitable ATAs can be achieved by
methods of protein discovery[7b,12] and protein engineer-
ing,[2a,13] which can be guided by bioinformatics tools. One of
these tools is the 3DM software package, which connects
a high-quality, structure-guided sequence alignment of a pro-
tein superfamily[14] with bioinformatics analysis tools. 3DM inte-
grates data from various sources, including sequences, struc-
tural information, protein ligand contacts, and mutational data
from the literature, using a unified amino acid residue number-
ing system for all proteins. We have previously used this plat-
form to guide the degree of randomization for the creation of
“small, but smart” libraries in multiple-site saturation mutagen-
esis experiments.[15] In this work, we have used information
from 3DM to guide the identification of variants of the ATA
from Vibrio fluvialis (ATA-Vfl) with suitable stereoselectivity and
enantiopreference for the synthesis of different diastereomers
of 3, because an initial screening had identified this ATA as
having sufficient activity. Unfortunately, ATA-Vfl exhibited only
moderate selectivity, with rac-2 having been fully converted
GC analysis revealed that variant Leu56Ile showed an im-
proved 1R enantioselectivity in the amination of the R enantio-
mer of rac-2 (Table 1, entry 2). Interestingly, the enzyme ami-
nated (S)-2 with inverted enantiopreference. The Leu56Val mu-
tation improved the R enantioselectivity in the amination of
(S)-2, but had no effect on the R enantiomer of 2 (Table 1,
entry 3, Figure S4B). In the case of 2, the carbonyl group is
part of a flexible aliphatic ring: 2 is an almost symmetric com-
pound because only a small methyl group is present in the b-
position. Thus, the typical steric constraints originating from
the interaction of a substrate bearing well-defined small and
large substituents with the enzyme’s active site[7a,16b] do not
apply for 2. This difference could lead to the switch of the
commonly observed stereoselectivity of the ATA from V. fluvia-
lis resulting in the R configuration here. We were thus able to
show that subtle changes in the active site geometry produced
&
ChemBioChem 0000, 00, 0 – 0
2
ꢀ 0000 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ÝÝ These are not the final page numbers!