M. Chidambaram et al. / Tetrahedron 63 (2007) 7696–7701
7697
used in T-reactions (mainly reactions of organic anions) but
perform poorly where the extraction mechanism is domi-
to high cost and limited availability. This has evidently
changed since the syntheses of the latter compounds have
been recently dramatically simplified via a procedure based
10
nant. Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTMAB) is
also a weak catalyst in I-reactions but quite active in
solid–liquid mass transferred controlled PTC reactions.
1
8,19
on simple and mild alkylation of dimethylformamide.
1
1
DDAB is being used in various industrial fields including
2
0
It was concluded that for reactions proceeding via the extrac-
tion mechanism, the preferred catalysts were the more orga-
bio-chemical industries. DDAB has not been previously
proposed as a phase-transfer catalyst except for one example
in which we have demonstrated its unique activity in an
oxidation reaction using aqueous hydrogen peroxide, where
1
2
nophilic and symmetrical quaternary cations. The latter
demonstrate higher extraction coefficients and more reactive
nucleophilic anions (due to lower Coulombic interaction
energies with the larger cation). Conversely, in transfer con-
trolled reactions the supreme phase-transfer catalysts are the
more ‘accessible’ or ‘open faced’ quaternary ammonium
2
1
it showed superior activities among the PTCs screened.
2. Results and discussion
1
3
cations. The latter carry smaller alkyl groups, and thus
readily occupy positions close to the interphase thus creating
a higher catalyst concentration at the site of the rate-
Prior to our catalytic experiments, we assessed the physio-
chemical properties of DDAB in comparison with some
standard phase-transfer catalysts such as TEBA (Makosza’s
1
4
determining step. Mason et al. have demonstrated the cor-
relation between the surface properties of several quaternary
ammonium salts (quats) and their catalytic activity in C-
alkylation process, a typical I-reaction. It was concluded
that quats that more effectively reduce the surface pressure
at the water–organic interphase are also the more potent
PT catalysts. It was also proven that the catalytic activity
did not directly stem from the reduction in surface pressure.
A quantitative empirical parameter q introduced by Hal-
2
2
catalyst),
336, Starks’ catalyst), and TBAB (Brandstrom’s cata-
tricaprylmethylammonium chloride (aliquat
2
3
2
4
lyst). According to the standard evaluation of quaternary
ammonium salts as phase-transfer catalysts, Makosza’s
catalyst is unsymmetrical but has a shorter alkyl chain, and
hence is an accessible catalyst. Starks’ catalyst possesses
one short alkyl chain, and is liphophilic in nature but inferior
from the symmetry perspective, and Brandstrom’s catalyst is
in perfect symmetry but is only partially accessible due to
the masking of C4 alkyl chains. Considering the extraction
mechanism, the relative performance of these three catalysts
is: Starks’ catalyst>Brandstrom’s catalyst>Makosza’s cata-
lyst, whereas for the interfacial mechanism, the order is:
Makosza’s catalyst>Brandstrom’s catalyst>Starks’ cata-
lyst. In comparison with the above, DDAB has a potential
advantage in being both highly accessible and highly orga-
nophilic at the same time. Initially, the surface pressure
was measured for water/air and toluene/air interfaces in
the presence of DDAB. It was found to be 2.78 dynes/cm
and 2.41 dynes/cm, respectively. These figures are an order
of magnitude smaller than the surface pressure reported
15
pern can be used to assess the T versus I activity of various
quaternary ammonium catalysts. The q value is calculated
by adding the reciprocals of the number of carbons on
each of the alkyl chains of the ammonium cations. Thus
for TEBA q¼1.64 and for tetrahexylammonium bromide
(
THAB) q¼0.67. It is generally accepted that for T-reactions
the q-value should be higher than 1. Best results are obtained
with catalysts with q value between 1.5 and 2.0. It should be
noted, however, that a certain critical level of organophilicity
is still required for interfacial reactions. Thus tetramethyl-
and tetraethylammonium catalysts are not considered as ac-
tive T-type catalysts. For I-reactions q should preferably be
<
(
1. Despite the high q value of surfactants such as CTAB
q>3), these are not useful catalysts due to the formation
1
4
for other PTCs such as TBAB, TEBA, and aliquat 336 sig-
nifying that DDAB is a potentially more active catalyst.
of emulsions in water–organic mixtures when the latter are
present. Another important criterion in phase-transfer cata-
lyst selection is the thermal and chemical stability of the cat-
Further, we have examined the thermal stability of DDAB in
comparison with both TBAB and tributylmethylammonium
bromide (TBMAB). This was performed using differential
scanning calorimetry (DSC). The substances were dissolved
in a neutral organic medium (isopropanol) and heated at
a rate of 10 C/min and the thermal events recorded. We
established that DDAB decomposed at 255 C, TBAB at
213 C, and TBMAB at 206 C. At a second stage we
assessed the thermal stability of these catalysts under basic
conditions. This was accomplished using the catalytic iso-
1
6
alyst, and also the ease of its separation from the reaction
mixture after the process is completed.
1
7
In view of these and other guidelines, most practitioners
have chosen tetrabutylammonium bromide (TBAB) (q¼1)
as the default catalyst for exploratory PTC applications.
Indeed this catalyst performs satisfactorily in essentially
all I- and T- PTC reactions and it is also reasonably stable
to alkaline and thermal conditions and swiftly washed
away from product mixtures once the reaction is completed.
However it is rarely the optimal catalyst for a given process.
ꢀ
ꢀ
ꢀ
ꢀ
2
5
merization reaction of anethole in the presence of 50%
aqueous NaOH (Eq. 1) as a reporter reaction indicative to
the presence of an active catalyst.
We have now recognized that another family of quaternary
ammonium salts, represented by the commercially available
surfactant didecyldimethylammonium bromide (DDAB), is
far more pertinent to the label of ‘universal’ or ‘default’
phase-transfer catalyst. As is demonstrated in this work,
DDAB is an excellent PT catalyst in both I- and T-reactions.
The group of dialkyldimethylammonium halides has been
overlooked in the past by PTC researchers, probably due
Table 1 presents the maximum conversions obtained in Eq. 1
at different temperatures in the presence of 8 mol % of
TBMAB, TBAB, and DDAB. The table also displays the
time required to achieve the maximum conversion. The latter
is actually the life span of the particular catalyst under the
given conditions, as the reaction stops once the catalyst is
totally decomposed. We can safely conclude that DDAB is