490
Russ.Chem.Bull., Int.Ed., Vol. 52, No. 2, February, 2003
Shipilov et al.
Table 2. Effects of the nature of the catalyst and the reaction
time on the percentage of the products in the fluorodechlorinaꢀ
tion of 4ꢀchloronitrobenzene (157.56 g, 1 mol) with potassium
fluoride (58 g, 1 mol)
of chloroarenes with potassium fluoride. As shown earꢀ
lier,6,10,12 the use of catalysts in fluorodechlorination of
chloroarenes either increases the concentration of active
potassium fluoride or enhances the reactivity of a subꢀ
strate (by means of stabilization of an intermediate
σꢀcomplex), while a combination of catalysts with differꢀ
ent mechanisms of involvement in fluorodechlorination
results in the observed synergism (i.e., nonadditive inꢀ
crease in the activity of the whole catalytic system). An
alternative version, where the catalytic activity increases
because of the mutual influence of catalysts (e.g., as a
result of specific solvation of an onium salt in a polyether,
which can change the anion transfer activity), seems to be
unlikely. In such a case, synergism arising in the fluorinaꢀ
tion of hexachlorobenzene16 from a combination of an
onium catalyst and potassium fluoride supported on an
inert carrier (CaF2, BaF2) finds no explanation. Certainly,
fine details of the mechanism of synergism in catalytic
halogenꢀexchange fluorination in a liquid—solid system
remain unclear so far and further, including kinetic, inꢀ
vestigations are required.
Comꢀ
pound
Reaction time/h
0.5
1
2
3
4
5
Entry 1. Catalyst 2 (9.98 g (0.025 mol))
C6H4FNO2
C6H4ClNO2
3.66
6.53
9.55 10.26 10.40 10.22
96.34 93.46 90.46 89.74 89.56 89.78
Entry 2. Catalysts 2 (9.98 g (0.025 mol))
+ 4 (2.78 g (0.0125 mol))
C6H4FNO2
C6H4ClNO2
6.97 11.35 12.09 13.43 15.23 17.25
92.77 88.65 87.90 86.57 84.77 83.75
Entry 3. Catalysts 2 (9.98 g (0.025 mol))
+ 4 (5.56 g (0.025 mol))
C6H4FNO2
C6H4ClNO2
5.28
8.78 15.28 15.54 15.64 18.08
94.72 91.21 84.72 84.46 84.34 81.90
Entry 4. Catalysts 2 (9.98 g (0.025 mol))
+ 4 (11.12 g (0.05 mol))
C6H4FNO2
C6H4ClNO2
7.34 13.78 16.03 18.47 18.79 18.33
92.70 86.22 83.97 81.53 81.21 81.67
Experimental
Entry 5. Catalysts 2 (9.98 g (0.025 mol))
+ 4 (44.48 g (0.2 mol))
19
F NMR spectra were recorded on a Bruker WPꢀ80 instruꢀ
ment (75.398 MHz) in deuteroacetone with hexafluorobenzene
as the internal standard. The course of the reaction was moniꢀ
tored by chromatography using a Hewlett Packard 5890 chroꢀ
matograph (katharometer as a detector, capillary column
30 m × 0.25 mm, SEꢀ54 phase, isothermal regime (100 °C),
helium as a carrier gas (20 mL min–1). Mass spectra were reꢀ
corded on a Finnigan Mat ITDꢀ800 instrument (ionization
chamber temperature 200 °C, ionizing voltage 70 eV).
Materials. Potassium fluoride, diethylene glycol and tetraꢀ
ethylene glycol dimethyl ethers, 18ꢀcrownꢀ6, 4ꢀchloronitroꢀ
benzene (highꢀpurity grade), (Et2N)4PBr, and hexaethylꢀ
guanidinium chloride were conditioned according to the known
procedure.10 Dichlorotetrafluorobenzene was isolated by fracꢀ
tional distillation (fraction with b.p. 152—153 °C) from a prodꢀ
uct obtained in the catalytic fluorodechlorination of hexachloroꢀ
benzene. The dichlorotetrafluorobenzene obtained was a
mixture of isomeric 1,3ꢀdichloroꢀ2,4,5,6ꢀtetrafluorobenzene
(94.5%), 1,2ꢀdichloroꢀ3,4,5,6ꢀtetrafluorobenzene (5%), and
1,4ꢀdichloroꢀ2,3,5,6ꢀtetrafluorobenzene (0.5%).
Fluorodechlorination of chlorobenzenes. Given amounts of
C6Cl2F4 or 4ꢀClꢀC6H4NO2, KF, and a catalyst (or a mixture of
catalysts) were heated with stirring at 140 °C. The reaction
mixture was periodically sampled and analyzed by GLC for
conversion degree.
The 19F NMR spectra of all starting reagents and reaction
products were identical with the literature data.19 Their mass
spectra contained the corresponding molecular ions.
C6H4FNO2
C6H4ClNO2
9.13 14.42 20.23 25.91 27.79 29.70
90.87 85.58 79.77 74.09 72.21 70.30
matic molecule, while a polyether activates potassium
fluoride).
This agrees with data obtained in the study of the
catalytic activity of tetraphenylphosphonium bromide.6
The replacement rate for chlorine in chloronitropyridine
was determined in different aprotic solvents in the presꢀ
ence and absence of tetraphenylphosphonium bromide.
It was concluded from the resulting dependence6 that
Ph4PBr not only increases the concentration of fluoride
ions in the organic phase, but also helps the solvent to
stabilize an intermediate Meisenheimer complex. At the
same time, other researchers12 who have studied the cataꢀ
lytic activity of crown ethers in fluorodechlorination reꢀ
actions believe that replacement of a chlorine atom by
fluorine accelerates mainly because of higher nucleophiꢀ
licity of potassium fluoride.
A similar synergistic effect was also observed in fluoroꢀ
dechlorination of hexachlorobenzene with potassium fluoꢀ
ride supported on calcium (or barium) fluoride in the
presence of (Et2N)4PBr.16 In this case, the concentration
of active KF probably increases because of its support on
CaF2 or BaF2, while (Et2N)4PBr activates the aromatic
substrate.
References
The experimental results presented here, as well as the
published literature data,17,18 fit well the proposed mechaꢀ
nism for synergism in the catalytic fluorodechlorination
1. N. N. Vorozhtsov, Jr., Zh. Vses. Khim. Oꢀva im. D.I.
Mendeleeva, 1970, 15, 1, 52 [Mendeleev Chem. J., 1970, 15,
No. 1 (Engl. Transl.)].