1
4
water they range between -2 and -6. Based on the relationship
between pK values in water and acetonitrile, those for ether
conjugate acids can be estimated to be between 3 and 6, suggesting
proton transfer coupled to C–O bond fission is anticipated for the
formation of the stable 4,4¢-dimethoxytrityl carbocation.
Typically, the formation of relatively unstable carbocations
would be more favoured in polar solvents due to increased
stabilisation of the charged species. The equilibrium and kinetic
studies reported here where solvent polarity is not having these
expected effects on either the rate or equilibrium, are the result of
the 4,4¢-dimethoxytrityl carbocation being a stable species due to
extensive delocalisation.
a
-
10
-13
that K
The value of the unimolecular rate constant for the breakdown
of the protonated trityl ether, k , for the hypothetical A1 mech-
anism (Scheme 8) can be calculated from the ratio of the actual
second-order rate constant for detritylation and K indicating that
= 10 –10 s . This extremely high value indicates
1
= 10 –10
.
2
1
1
1
14 -1
k
2
= kHA/K
1
that the lifetime of the conjugate acid intermediate (Scheme 8) is
15
close to or less than that expected for an intermediate to exist,
Experimental
and therefore the formation of this intermediate and consequently
the A1 mechanism seem unlikely. A more likely mechanism for
detritylation in acetonitrile and in other non-aqueous solvents
is a concerted general acid-catalysed process (Scheme 9). The
microscopic reverse of this reaction is the concerted general
base-catlysed addition of water to the carbocation, which is the
mechanism that has been proposed for triarylmethyl carbocations
Equilibrium studies were performed on a Cary 1E UV-Visible
spectrophotometer with 1 cm quartz cuvettes. All solvents were
˚
dried over 4 A molecular sieves under dry argon for at least
4 hours prior to use. In a typical experiment, solutions of 5¢-
2
-
5
O-(4,4¢-dimethoxytrityl)-2¢-deoxythymidine (3.6 ¥ 10 M, 2 ml)
were pipetted into the cuvette and dichloroacetic acid (12 M,
1–20 ml) was then titrated. After each aliquot of acid was added
the sample was shaken and left to equilibrate for five minutes
prior to recording of the UV spectrum over a wavelength range of
16
in water.
2
50–600 nm.
1
13
H and C NMR spectra were recorded on a Bruker 400 MHz
or Bruker 500 MHz spectrometer with deuterated acetonitrile as
solvent.
Kinetic measurements were performed on an Applied Photo-
physics SX.18 MV-R1 Stop-flow spectrophotometer with a 25 : 1
syringe ratio. In a typical experiment, a solution of 5¢-O-(4,4¢-
-
4
dimethoxytrityl)-2¢-deoxythymidine (9 ¥ 10 M) was loaded into
the smaller of the two syringes and dichloroacetic acid (0.2–3.5 M)
was loaded into the larger syringe. Injection of the contents of the
two syringes into the reaction cell initiated the reaction, which was
followed by measurement of the increase in the absorbance of the
produced carbocation, an average of 20–30 results being taken for
each run.
Scheme 9
17
18,19
Jencks and Fife
have both proposed a number of re-
quirements to determine whether a mechanism will be stepwise
or concerted. Jencks suggests that for a reaction to occur by a
concerted general acid-catalysed mechanism there must be a large
Synthesis of 4,4¢-dimethoxytrityl alcohol
Sodium hydroxide (10 ml, 2.95 mmol) was added to a solution
of 4,4¢-dimethoxytritylchloride (1 g, 2.95 mmol) in acetonitrile
(25 ml). As the reaction proceeded the solution was kept basic with
further additions of sodium hydroxide (approx. 3 ml). On addition
of water (20 ml) to the solution, a yellow–brown oil, which was
found to be the crude form of the 4,4¢-dimethoxytrityl alcohol,
and a white precipitate was formed. The oil was dissolved in ether
(25 ml) and water (25 ml) and the organic layer extracted with
ether (3 ¥ 15 ml). After drying over sodium sulfate and filtration,
the solvent was removed and the resulting very viscous orange
pK
have a pK
the substrate site. During the course of the detritylation reaction
in acetonitrile there is a large change in the pK of the protonated
ether from 3–6 to that of the alcohol liberated (thymidine) of >
2 while the pK of 16 for the proton donor, dichloroacetic acid,
a
change during the course of the reaction and the catalyst must
a
intermediate between the initial and final pK values of
a
a
2
a
is intermediate between those of the ether conjugate acid and the
alcohol. Fife has also proposed a number of requirements for
a concerted general acid-catalysed mechanism based mainly on
the study of the mechanisms of hydrolysis of acetals and ketals.
These state that concerted mechanisms occur when either the
leaving group is very good and/or the product cation is very
stable. A concerted general acid-catalysed mechanism for the
detritylation of 5¢-O-(4,4¢-dimethoxytrityl)-2¢-deoxythymidine is
compatible with all of these criteria.
Experimentally, the small dependence of the rate constants
for the acid-catalysed detritylation of 5¢-O-(4,4¢-dimethoxytrityl)
thymidine on solvent (Table 3), the negative entropies of activation
and their small variation with solvent (Table 4) are all compatible
with a bimolecular process leading to an early transition state with
little charge development (Scheme 9). A concerted mechanism for
1
oil was the 4,4¢-dimethoxytrityl alcohol (0.76 g, 81%). H NMR:
d (CD
H, J = 2.2 Hz), 6.82 (4H, d, aromatic H, J = 2.2 Hz), 4.24
(1H, s, OH) (lost on D O shake), 3.57 (6H, s, OCH ). C NMR: d
(CD CN) 159.9, 149.0, 140.9, 130.0, 128.6, 127.7, 113.8, 81.6, 55.8.
IR: n/cm 3485.0 (OH), 3058.1 (Ph-H), 2835.3 (OCH
3
CN) 7.23 (5H, m, aromatic H), 7.12 (4H, d, aromatic
1
3
2
3
3
-
1
3
), 1607.5,
-
1
1583.1, 1508.7 (Ph) cm .
References
1
2
C. H. Paul and A. T. Royappa, Nucleic Acids Res., 1996, 24, 3048.
S. P. Adams, K. S. Kavka, E. J. Wykes, S. B. Holder and G. R. Galluppi,
J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1983, 105, 661.
5
6 | Org. Biomol. Chem., 2009, 7, 52–57
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2009