220
T. Baran et al. / Journal of Molecular Catalysis A: Chemical 420 (2016) 216–221
Table 2
coordination of Pd(II) ions with the ligand. These observations are
in line with existing literature reports [22,23].
Effect of chitosan-Ulva supported Pd(II) catalyst on Suzuki C-C reactions.
X
Y
Reaction yield (%)
TON
TOF
3.2.4. EDAX spectrum
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Br
Br
Br
Br
Br
Br
Br
I
I
I
I
CI
CI
CI
2-OCH3
3-OCH3
4-OCH3
4-CH3
3-NH2
3-NO2
4-NO2
2-CH3
74
87
99
52
73
86
88
46
47
88
72
68
57
15
3700
4350
4950
2600
3650
4300
4400
2300
2350
4400
3600
3400
2850
750
56061
65909
75000
39394
55303
65152
66667
34848
35607
66667
54545
51515
43182
11364
To validate the coordination of Pd ions with the binding groups
on the surface of chitosan-Ulva composite beads, EDAX spectrum
of chitosan-Ulva supported Pd(II) catalyst was recorded and pre-
sented in Fig. 6. The peaks of palladium and chloride ions in the
spectrum demonstrated the formation of Pd(II) catalyst. The ele-
mental composition (%) of the catalyst was recorded from the
EDAX data as follows; C: 30.92, N: 9.91, O: 29.6, Cl: 9.32 and Pd:
20.25%. Palladium ion content of the catalyst was also determined
by ICP-OES as 19.36%. This high palladium content was desirable
for the catalyst. In our previous study we recorded palladium con-
tent of O-carboxymethyl chitosan Schiff bases-supported catalysts
([OCMCS-3a]·2H2O and [OCMCS-4a]·2H2O) as 13.02% and 15.63%
[8]. It appeared that chitosan-Ulva composite served as a better
ligand for palladium ions.
9
4-CH3
10
11
12
13
14
4-OCH3
3-NO2
4-OCH3
3-NO2
4-CH3
Reaction conditions: 1.12 mmol aryl halide, 1.87 mmol phenyl boronic acid,
3.75 mmol K2CO3, 0.02 mol% chitosan-Ulva supported Pd(II) catalyst, 50 ◦C, 4 min
under microwave irradiation.
TON: (turnover number, yield of product/per mol of Pd).
TOF: (turn over frequency, TON/time of reaction)
3.2.5. Crystallinity
Previous studies have established that chitosan polymer
exhibits high crystallinity due to inter-and intra-molecular hydro-
gen bonds [24]. Deformation of these strong hydrogen bonds via
cross-linking, Schiff base formation or metal coordination results
in a decrease in the crystallinity index of chitosan [21,25]. Analysis
of XRD patterns of chitosan-Ulva composite bead revealed that the
beads had lower crystalline structure than chitosan (Fig. 7). The
following equation gave the crystallinity indices of chitosan-Ulva
composite bead and the catalyst; 62% and 6%, respectively. Also, in
our previous study we calculated the crystallinity index of chitosan
as 82% [16].
Table 3
Effect of different Pd catalysts on C-C coupling reaction.
Catalyst
Reaction yield (%)
PdCl2
Na2PdCl4
39
52
99
Chitosan-Ulva supported Pd(II) catalyst
Reaction conditions: 1.12 mmol 4-bromoanisole, 1.87 mmol phenyl boronic acid,
3.75 mmol base, 0.02 mol% catalyst, 50 ◦C, 4 min under microwave irradiation.
are generally attributed to the ionic radii and bond dissociation
energies of halides [1,8]. In addition, the positions of substitu-
tion groups on phenyl rings, i.e., para-, meta- and ortho-, greatly
affected the reaction yields in all the C-C coupling reactions with
> meta- >ortho-substituent. As presented in Table 2, in the presence
TOF values are important properties for the catalyst systems for
industrial applications [28]. In this study excellent TON (4950) and
TOF (as high as 75000) were achieved for chitosan-Ulva supported
Pd(II) catalyst (Table 2, entry 3).
Crystallineindex(%) = [(I110 − Iam)/I110] × 100
(1)
where I110 denotes the maximum intensity at ∼20◦ and Iam is the
intensity of amorphous diffraction at 16◦.
This lower crystallinity likely stemmed from the cross-linking
treatment in which amino groups on chitosan reacted with alde-
hyde ends of the cross-linking agent by forming imine groups.
Chitosan-Ulva supported Pd(II) catalyst showed more amorphous
nature than chitosan and chitosan-Ulva composite bead. As
previously reported, amorphous nature of chitosan composites
facilitates diffusion of ions or molecules into chitosan matrices [26].
As noted in previous Section 3.2.4, high palladium content of the
catalyst could be attributed to the amorphous nature of chitosan-
Ulva composite beads.
3.3.1. Comparison of the performance of the catalyst with
commercial Pd catalysts
To determine the feasibility of chitosan-Ulva supported Pd(II)
cially available palladium salts (PdCl2 and Na2PdCl4) were also
carried out under optimized conditions. The catalytic productiv-
ity of chitosan-Ulva supported Pd(II) catalyst was compared to
those of PdCl2 and Na2PdCl4 in the model reaction. The results
were summarised in Table 3. Considering the product yields (4-
methoxybiphenyl), chitosan-Ulva supported Pd(II) catalyst showed
a far better catalytic performance than those of commercial Pd
catalysts PdCl2 and Na2PdCl4.
3.3. Catalytic performance of the catalyst in C-C coupling
reactions
Firstly, to prove the catalytic activity of chitosan-Ulva supported
Pd(II) catalyst, the control experiments were conducted with
catalyst-free model reactions under optimum conditions (Please,
refer to the Section 3.1.1). No product (4-methoxy biphenyl) for-
mation was observed in the catalyst-free media. Secondly, the
catalytic performance of chitosan-Ulva supported Pd(II) beads was
tested in 14 different C-C coupling reactions. In these experiments
aryl bromides, aryl iodides and aryl chlorides were reacted with
phenyl boronic acid. GC–MS spectra of the synthesized biaryls
were recorded (Please, refer to Supplementary data Fig. S1–S16).
The corresponding conversion yields, turnover number (TON) and
turnover number frequency (TOF) values are listed in Table 2.
Noticeably higher reaction productivity was observed for aryl
bromides. Aryl iodides also produced higher conversion yields com-
pared to aryl chlorides. Due to their poor activity, the coupling
reactions with aryl chlorides gave the lowest product yields [27].
These differences observed in the reaction yields of biaryl halides
3.3.2. Reusability of chitosan-Ulva supported Pd(II) catalyst
a better performance up to 8 runs, and then a slight decrease was
observed in its activity (Fig. 8). In earlier study, Pd nano-sized
particles supported-chitosan and 6-deoxy-6-amino chitosan cat-
alysts retained their activities after fifth run [1]. In another study