A.W.G. Platt, K. Singh / Journal of Molecular Structure 1111 (2016) 180e184
181
interaction with the metal had taken place. Attempts to obtain
crystalline materials from these reactions by slow evaporation,
cooling to ꢁ30 ꢀC or slow diffusion with diethylether or toluene
followed by cooling were not successful. The reactions led to either
recovery of unreacted Mes3PO, no solid materials or to the forma-
tion of oils. The reason for the apparent lack of coordination with
Ln(NO3)3 is probably a combination of the high affinity of lantha-
nide ions for nitrate and the increased steric demands of the ligand
limiting access of the phosphoryl oxygen to the coordination sites
on the metal.
Clearly there is some interaction between Mes3PO and the
lanthanide nitrates in solution, but this does not result in the for-
mation of complexes which are sufficiently stable to permit isola-
tion. The reactions of lanthanide and scandium trifluoromethane
sulfonates (triflates) were examined as the triflate ion has a low
coordinating ability and might thus lead to a less crowded coor-
dination environment around the metal. In reactions with LnTf3
Ln ¼ (Ln ¼ La, Nd, Eu, Er, Lu) in ethanol the initial suspensions of
Mes3PO cleared on addition of the lanthanide salt, again implying
some complex formation. The reaction mixtures, however, failed to
yield characterisable materials.
shows that, compared to Ph3PO, reduction in steric strain by
widening of the CePeC angle has the effect of making the methyl
groups effectively shield the phosphoryl oxygen and this probably
limits the availability of the P]O group to coordinate to the
lanthanide ion, where the environment around the metal will
already contain coordinated nitrate ions and/or water molecules.
The reaction with scandium triflate in CH3CN did produce
crystalline material which was suitable for x-ray diffraction study.
The solid does not, however, contain scandium but is
[Mes3PO]3H3Oþ CF3SO3ꢁ.2CH3CN (2). The hydronium ions are
formed are almost certainly by acid hydrolysis of hydrated Sc3þ. The
structure is shown in Fig. 2 and details of the data collection and
refinement are included in Table 1. Three Mes3PO molecules are
coordinated to H3Oþ via hydrogen bonding and the CH3CN and
triflate ions are not involved in hydrogen bonding interactions. The
P]O bonds are slightly longer (average 1.493 Å) than in Mes3PO as
expected on coordination to a positively charged centre. Larger
increases in bond distances in similar structures such as Ph3PO$HBr
(1.550 Å) [15] and Ph3PO$HNO3 (1.499 Å) [16] are probably due to
the proton being coordinated to one phosphine oxide rather than
three as in this study.
In order to assess the steric congestion around the oxygen in
Trimesitylphosphine oxide is bulkier than trialkylphosphine
t
t
trimesitylphosphine oxide the crystal structure of Mes3
oxides such as Bu3PO (the cone angle Bu3P is 182ꢀ) which forms
only 1:2 complexes with lanthanide nitrates [8]. Trimes-
itylphosphine itself forms complexes with a number of metals and
coordination compounds with Hg [17], Ag [18], Pt [19] and Au [20]
have been characterised. The inability of Mes3PO to form stable
complexes might thus be considered to be surprising as the cone
angle of the oxide will certainly be lower than that of the phos-
phine. A comparison of some of the parameters which might be
relevant to their relative coordinating ability are given in Table 3.
The approach of Mes3PO to the metal centre will be restricted by
steric interaction with the methyl groups. The proximity of the
methyls to the coordinating atoms indicates that the environments
in Mes3P and Mes3PO are similar with P … O and C … O distances
relatively short. Although the distances could be considered as
indicative of hydrogen bonding (C … O average in Mes3PO is 2.89 Å
compared to a sum of Van der Waals radii for C and O of 3.2 Å and C
… P average in Mes3P is 2.72 Å compared to a sum of Van der Waals
radii for P and C of 3.5 Å), it is more likely that these distances are
imposed by the geometrical constraints of the molecules [21].
The differences in coordinating ability probably lies in the strong
hydration of the lanthanide and scandium ions which combines
with the steric congestion of the ligand to make coordination
impossible under the conditions employed. In addition the metal
ions coordinated to Mes3P are likely to be less strongly solvated (for
example using CH2Cl2/THF as the reaction medium) and hence the
effective size of the metal ions will be lower than hydrated
lanthanide or scandium ions.
-
PO$0.5CH3CN (1) was determined. The structure is shown in Fig. 1
details of the data collection and refinement are given in Table 1
and selected bond distances and angles in Table 2. The compound
crystallises with two Mes3PO molecules and one CH3CN in the unit
cell. There are no close contacts between the acetonitrile and the
phosphine oxide. Comparison of this structure with Ph3PO, which
forms stable complexes with all simple lanthanide salts, indicates
that the structure of Mes3PO changes to reduce steric interactions
between the methyl groups and in doing so increases the crowding
of the environment around the O-atom, as described below. The P]
O bond distance is 1.486 Å which is very similar to those reported
for Ph3PO, for example 1.483 [13] and 1.487 [14]. The CePeC angles
widen to reduce steric interactions between the methyl groups in
Mes3PO with an average of 110.2ꢀ compared to 106.4ꢀ in Ph3PO.
There is also a significant increase in the PeC bond distance
compared with Ph3PO from 1.800 Å to 1.828 Å which will further
reduce steric crowding between the methyl groups. The structure
2.2. Solution NMR investigation
Given that there is clearly some interaction between the
lanthanide ions and Mes3PO several lanthanide triflate/Mes3PO
systems were investigated by 31-P NMR spectroscopy.
The results are shown in Table 4. The absence of any large co-
ordination shifts with the paramagnetic lanthanide ions indicates
that there is no direct interaction between the phosphine oxide and
the metal. However, the lines are broad and show a significant
temperature dependence of the chemical shifts which whilst
smaller than that observed for LneO]P systems, is an order of
magnitude greater than that of free Mes3PO. We recently reported
the structures of [Ln(H2O)5(Cy3PO)2]$2Cy3PO$3X (X ¼ Cl, Br) [11,12]
where Cy ¼ cyclohexyl, C6H11 in which the Cy3PO are either directly
bonded to the metal ion or through hydrogen bonding to the
Fig. 1. The structure of Mes3PO$CH3CN The acetonitrile molecule is omitted for clarity.