Communications
Table 1: Optimization of the active template PdII-promoted Michael
shows that the coordination mode[11] of L22ꢀ and the shape
of the ring holds the nitrile ligand occupying the fourth PdII
coordination site centrally within the macrocycle cavity. The
crystal structures suggested that the first alkylation of the a-
methylene group should result in one face of the macrocycle
being blocked such that the second Michael addition must
proceed from the other side, generating a [2]rotaxane.
Pleasingly, the four component assembly of [(L2)Pd-
(CH3CN)], 1 ( 2), and L1 at room temperature in CH2Cl2 in
the presence of DIPEA led to [2]rotaxane [(L3)Pd], initially
in 47% yield (Scheme 1 and Table 1, entry 1). The assignment
of [(L3)Pd] as a rotaxane was initially made by mass
spectrometry (no dissociation of the components observed
in the fragmentation pattern without cleavage of a stopper)
and 1H NMR spectroscopy (for a stack plot of the spectra of
[(L3)Pd] and the corresponding thread showing upfield shifts
of the encapsulated regions of the rotaxane axle,[12] see the
Supporting Information). Confirmation of the mechanically
interlocked structure came from demetalation of [(L3)Pd]
(1m HCl (aq):CH2Cl2 (1:1), 92%, Scheme 1, step b), which
gave the weakly hydrogen bonded rotaxane H2L3 rather than
the dethreaded components. The 1H NMR spectrum (see the
Supporting Information) shows that the macrocycle in H2L3
preferentially resides over, and rapidly shuttles between, the
two thread ketone groups in CDCl3, even at 250 K. Finally,
single crystals of [(L3)Pd] were grown from a saturated
solution in butanone/methanol. The solid-state structure[10]
(Figure 1c) confirms that the Pd–nitrile coordination bond is
maintained in the metalated rotaxane and is responsible for
holding the macrocycle and thread in the well-defined co-
conformation observed in solution.
The rotaxane-forming reaction shown in Scheme 1 was
optimized in terms of reagent stoichiometry and conditions
(Table 1). The amount of base was decreased to 10 mol% to
minimize the background non-palladium promoted reaction
(Table 1, entry 2).[13] A concomitant increase in reaction
temperature (to 313 K,[14] Table 1, entry 3) was then required
for the reaction to achieve significant conversion within a
reasonable timeframe (76% yield of double Michael addition
products after 7 days). Under these conditions and using a
modest excess of the thread building blocks (2.5 versus
1.0 equiv), the yield of [2]rotaxane [(L3)Pd] was increased to
over 99% (Table 1, entry 6). Thus, this active template
reaction is among the most efficient, albeit rather slowly
proceeding, rotaxane-forming procedures reported to date.
Since the nitrile functionality is preserved in the product
of the active template reaction, it can in principle be used as a
binding site or “station” for the macrocycle–Pd component in
a molecular shuttle. To incorporate two such units into a
rotaxane, the reaction pattern for formation of the thread was
reversed, so that shuttle [(L4)Pd] was synthesized by Michael
additions of two “mono-stoppered” a-cyano esters (L5) to
bis(vinyl ketone) spacer 2 in the presence of [(L2)Pd-
(CH3CN)] (Scheme 2, step a).
addition synthesis of rotaxane [(L3)Pd][a]
Entry Thread components DIPEA
Total conver- Yield of
[equiv][b]
[equiv]
sion [%][c]
[(L3)Pd][%]
1[d]
2[e]
3[f]
4[f]
5[f]
6[f]
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
1.0
0.1
0.1
0.1
0.1
0.1
69
70
76
77
71
67
47
53
60
85
96
>99
[a]Reaction conditions: [( L2)Pd(CH3CN)], thread components 1 (2)
and L1, DIPEA, CH2Cl2. [b]2:1 stoichiometry of 1:L1. [c]For L1+
[(L2)Pd(CH3CN)]+21![(L3)Pd]+noninterlocked thread. [d]5 days
at room temperature. [e]19 days at room temperature. [f]7 days at
313 K.
catalyze asymmetric 1,4-conjugate additions of a-cyano esters
to alkyl vinyl ketones in the presence of N,N-diisopropyle-
thylamine (DIPEA).[8] It seemed that a suitably constructed
tridentate macrocycle–PdII complex[9] might promote the
double Michael addition between ethyl cyanoacetate (L1)
and two suitably derivatized vinyl ketone “stoppers” (1) to
generate [2]rotaxanes with the intercomponent recognition
motif intact (Scheme 1).
Palladium(II)–macrocycle complex [(L2)Pd(CH3CN)]
was prepared in five steps from commercially available
materials (see the Supporting Information). Treatment of
[(L2)Pd(CH3CN)] with ethyl cyanoacetate in CH2Cl2 and
subsequent removal of the solvent and acetonitrile under
reduced pressure afforded complex [(L2)Pd(L1)], which
crystallized from a saturated solution in CH2Cl2/Et2O in a
form suitable for investigation by X-ray diffraction.[10] The
solid-state structure of both [(L2)Pd(L1)] (Figure 1a and b)
and [(L2)Pd(CH3CN)] (see the Supporting Information)
Figure 1. X-ray crystal structures[10] of [(L2)Pd(L1)]from a) face-on and
b) side-on views and c) rotaxane [(L3)Pd]. Selected bond lengths []
and angles [8] : [(L2)Pd(L1)]: N1–Pd 2.02, N2–Pd 1.92, N3–Pd 2.04,
N4–Pd 2.02; N1-Pd-N3 161.7, N2-Pd-N4 177.9. [(L3)Pd]: N1–Pd 2.02,
N2–Pd 1.92, N3–Pd 2.03, N4–Pd 2.00; N1-Pd-N3 161.8, N2-Pd-N4
178.9.
There are few examples[15] of metal-complexed molecular
shuttles, and the investigation of their dynamics is of interest.
At room temperature in CDCl3, the exchange of the
palladium-coordinated macrocycle between the thread nitrile
groups in [(L4)Pd] is slow on the NMR timescale. Ligand
3382
ꢀ 2008 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2008, 47, 3381 –3384