Communication
product in poor yields. Control experiments also confirmed
that the rhodium catalyst is necessary.
tion was detected (by TLC and HPLC) when it was allowed to
react for 30 min, which is line with the failure of the catalytic
reaction under our standard conditions.[13]
The scope and limitations of this coupling system were next
explored by using the optimized conditions. Installation of vari-
ous electron-donating, -withdrawing, and halogen groups at
the para position of the phenyl ring had limited effects on the
outcome of the coupling system (3ba–ia; Scheme 2), and
there was no direct correlation between the electronic effect
of the substituent and the reaction yield. The compatibility of
halogen (3ia), ester (3ga), and aldehyde (3ha) groups should
allow further manipulation of the coupled product. An excep-
tion was found for the coupling of 2-(4-fluorophenyl)pyridine,
from which essentially no desired product was detected under
the standard conditions. However, prolonging the pre-stirring
in the first stage to 15 h increased the yield of product 3ja to
35%. Introduction of electron-withdrawing and -donating sub-
stituents into the pyridine ring of 2-phenylpyridines was well
tolerated and the sulfonylated product was isolated in moder-
ate yields (3qa–sa). Discrepancies in site selectivity of different
meta-substituted substrates were observed. The coupling oc-
curred at the less hindered site for m-methyl and -bromo sub-
stituted arenes (3ka–ma). Decreasing the substituent size to
a m-OMe group caused formation of a mixture of two re-
gioisomers (3na and 3na’). In contrast, only sulfonylation at
the more hindered ortho position was detected for m-fluoro-
substituted arene 3oa, a trend that was also observed in our
previous studies.[5a] In addition, an o-chloro-substituted sub-
strate exhibited comparable activity (3pa). The arene scope
was not limited to phenyl rings and the reaction of a thiophene
substrate afforded product 3ta in moderate yield.
Although most 2-phenylpyridines reacted efficiently under
the standard conditions, essentially no desired reaction oc-
curred for 1-phenylpyrazole. To address this limitation, 1-phe-
nylpyrazole was hyperiodinated to afford 5 by following our
previously reported protocol.[5d] Treatment of 5 with 2a afford-
ed the corresponding product 6 in 59% yield [Eq. (3)].
In addition to identification of the intermediate hypervalent
iodine species, the mechanism of the sulfonylation reaction
was explored. Cyclometalated RhIII sulfinate complex 7a was
prepared and tested as a catalyst [Eq. (4)]. However, no desired
catalytic reaction occurred. This suggests that it is not an
active catalyst, which stands in stark contrast to the efficacy of
the previously reported cyclometalated RhIII nitrate complex in
the nitration of 2-phenylpyridines with NaNO2.[5a] Thus, reduc-
tive CÀS bond formation from 7a is likely irrelevant and an oxi-
dative coupling process that involves the oxidation of a low-
valent RhI species to RhIII is not plausible (Scheme 1a). This
result also suggests that the sulfinate anion exhibits an inhibi-
tive effect at the hyperiodination stage.
Variation of the sulfinate coupling partner was also well tol-
erated. Introduction of (hetero)arenesulfinate bearing different
electron-donating and -withdrawing substituents at different
positions were viable, and the coupled products were isolated
in consistently moderate to high yields (3ac–ai; Scheme 2).
Furthermore, the sulfinate scope could be extended to (tri-
fluoro)methanesulfinate with no obvious deterioration of the
reaction efficiency (3aj, 3ak).
During pre-stirring of a mixture of 2-phenylpyridine, the RhIII
catalyst, the 2-mesitylenecarboxylic acid (MesCOOH), and
PhI(OH)OTs in acetone,
a white precipitate was formed
[Eq. (1)], which may indicate formation of a reactive intermedi-
ate. Indeed, this intermediate (4) was isolated in 75% yield
after simple filtration and was identified as an unsymmetrical
diaryliodonium salt on the basis of NMR spectroscopy and
HRMS analyses. The NMR spectra of 4 are in close agreement
with those of its tosylate analogue.[5d] To probe the intermedia-
cy of this hypervalent iodine species, a mixture of 4 (recrystal-
lized) and 2a (recrystallized) was stirred in acetone. Interesting-
ly, the sulfonylated product 3aa was isolated in 91% yield
from a reaction at 608C, even in the absence of any catalyst
[Eq. (2)].[11,12] Thus, the overall catalytic reaction comprises
a RhIII-catalyzed hyperiodination of the arene followed by an
uncatalyzed nucleophilic sulfonylation reaction. Furthermore,
the intermediacy of a hypervalent iodine species seems in
agreement with the poor efficiency of the coupling of
2-(4-fluorophenyl)pyridine, because essentially no hyperiodina-
To probe the CÀH activation process, rhodacyclic complex
7b was also applied as a catalyst [Eq. (4)]. It follows that com-
plex 7b exhibited comparable activity to the real catalyst
Chem. Eur. J. 2016, 22, 511 – 516
513
ꢀ 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim