3980
A. Chen et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 21 (2011) 3976–3981
described in Scheme 1 could have been serviceable for this cam-
paign, we again felt it was more prudent to re-design the synthesis
so that the diversification step (i.e., amide coupling) could be post-
poned to the end. In this regard, a scalable route to access the req-
uisite chiral hydroxyl acid 22 was developed (Scheme 2). Briefly,
Friedel–Crafts acylation of 1,2-difluorobenzene (16) with 3-
chloro-propionyl chloride (17) in carbon disulfide afforded ketone
18 in 95% yield. Its subsequent amination with commercially avail-
able 3-(benzylamino)propanenitrile proceeded quantitatively with
triethylamine as base. In the presence of 1.5 equiv of potassium
tert-butoxide, ketone 19 underwent intramolecular cyclization to
afford the desired hydroxyl nitrile as a single diastereomer. Follow-
ing chiral separation on a Chiralpak AD column, the desired enan-
tiomer 20 was hydrolyzed to the corresponding acid 21 by a two
step process: an initial oxidation to the intermediate amide with
lithium peroxide followed by hydrolysis with ethanolic potassium
hydroxide. Finally, a protecting group switch from benzyl amine 21
to tert-butyl carbamate 22 under a hydrogen atmosphere was best
accomplished with Pearlman’s catalyst in the presence of di-tert-
butyl-dicarbonate and triethylamine.
renin potency (i.e., 40 vs 39, 43 vs 42). For analogues capped with
either a benzyl or a pyridyl group, ortho- and para-substitutions
were also not tolerated (i.e., 46 vs 45, 48 vs 45, 53 vs 51). On the
other hand, small substituents at the meta-position (i.e., 49 and
54) were beneficial for renin potency.
Although great strides in terms of renin potency were made and
several low picomolar renin inhibitors were identified, closer exam-
ination would reveal that these gains were often achieved at the ex-
pense of the off-target profile (i.e., hERG binding, CYP3A4 inhibition
or both). Consequently, in order to ascertain whether the judicious
introduction of polarity could free the current series from this
zero-sum quagmire, the tertiary alcohol of compound 4911 was
functionalized as depicted in Scheme 3. Starting from its tert-butyl
carbamate 55, alkylation with allyl bromide was best accomplished
by heating the reactants with sodium hydride in DMF. Subsequent
dihydroxylation of the olefin in 56 using modified Upjohn condi-
tions12 afforded the desired diol 57 as a ꢀ1:1 mixture of diastereo-
mers. Finally, removal of the BOC protecting group with excess
zinc(II) bromide delivered compound 58 uneventfully.7
The key characteristics of compounds 49 and 58 are summa-
rized in Table 4. As expected, the introduction of polarity did im-
With hydroxyl acid 22 in hand, all the amides shown in Table 3
were prepared from the requisite amines with HATU as the cou-
pling agent followed by cleavage of the BOC protecting group. As
expected,4 the best amine identified for the earlier generation
renin inhibitors6 was no longer optimal for our current series.
Indeed, when benzyl amine 3 was switched for N-(2,3-dichloro-
benzyl)cyclopropanamine, a six-fold increase in intrinsic renin po-
tency was observed (i.e., 23 vs 15). However in the absence of a
suitable tail designed to anchor the inhibitor into the renin s3
sub-pocket, compound 23 was also highly shifted by human plas-
ma. Although the plasma shift observed could be slightly decreased
when either 3-methoxypropyl (i.e., 24) or 2-methoxyethyl (i.e., 25)
tail was re-introduced at the meta-position, neither compound
exhibited sufficient renin plasma potency to warrant further profil-
ing. On the other hand, a major potency breakthrough was realized
when we abandoned the benzene ring (i.e., 7 ꢀ 15, 23 ꢀ 25) for an
indole scaffold (i.e., 26 ꢀ 54). Indeed, with only a halogen substitu-
ent at the 4-position of an otherwise unfunctionalized indole ring
(i.e., 26 ꢀ 28), sub-nanomolar renin inhibitors were obtained.
Although it was not possible to differentiate between these ana-
logues on the basis of their respective plasma renin IC50, the 4-flu-
oro derivative 26 appeared to possess the best, albeit still
unacceptable, off-target profile of the three. When compound 26
was docked into the renin active site in silico, molecular modeling
revealed that the renin s3 sub-pocket can be accessed from both
the 1- and 7-positions of the indole ring. Consequently, a 3-meth-
oxylpropyl tail was installed at either of these two positions to as-
sess whether more improvements in potency could be achieved.
While compounds 29 and 30 were both more potent than their
un-alkylated precursor 26 in the enzyme assay, these renin inhib-
itors were however more plasma shifted. Furthermore, these mod-
ifications failed to improve the off-target profile. From 29, the
addition of a second alkyl chain capped by methoxide (i.e., 31),
cyanide (i.e., 32), sulfone (i.e., 33), morpholine (i.e., 34) or imidaz-
ole (35) also failed to deliver any tangible improvement over 26. In
contrast, the replacement of 3-methoxypropane in 29 by an N-
methoxyacetamide (i.e., 36) did lead to a six-fold decrease in bind-
ing affinity to the hERG channel. We have also evaluated the im-
pact of capping compound 26’s indole NH with either a benzyl
(i.e., 45 ꢀ 50) or a heteroaryl methyl (i.e., 38 ꢀ 44, 51 ꢀ 54) resi-
due. Compounds capped with a five-membered heterocycle such
as 1,3-oxazole (i.e., 38) and 3-methyl-1,2,4-oxadiazole (i.e., 41),
or a 6-membered heterocycle such as 4-methyl-3-pyridine (i.e.,
54), were found to be sub-nanomolar renin inhibitors even in the
presence of human plasma. However, further addition of methyl
groups to 5-membered heterocycles proved to be deleterious for
prove the off-target profile to
a more manageable level.
Unfortunately, this was accompanied by a drop in plasma renin po-
tency and more importantly, compound 58 was no longer orally
bioavailable in rats. Consequently, this series was put on hold.
In summary, by committing the necessary resources to the
development of synthetic sequences that were most amenable
for late stage structural diversification, we were able to make a ra-
pid ‘no go’ decision on this series of renin inhibitors. Although
compounds suitable for further development could not be identi-
fied, several members of this series were found to exhibit dose-
independent oral bioavailability in rats. Their use to elucidate the
role of efflux transporters on the poor oral bioavailability shared
by early generation renin inhibitors at low dose will be presented
in a future manuscript.
References and notes
2. Zaman, M. A.; Oparil, S.; Calhoun, D. A. Nat. Rev. Drug Discovery 2002, 1, 621.
3. Hollenberg, N. K. Nat. Rev. Nephrology 2010, 6, 49.
4. Chen, A.; Campeau, L.-C.; Cauchon, E.; Chefson, A.; Ducharme, Y.; Dubé, D.;
Falgueyret, J.-P.; Fournier, P.-A.; Gagné, S.; Grimm, E.; Han, Y.; Houle, R.; Huang,
J.-Q,; Lacombe, P.; Laliberté, S.; Lévesque, J.-F.; Liu, S.; MacDonald, D.; Mackay,
B.; McKay, D.; Percival, M. D.; Regan, C.; Regan, H.; St-Jacques, R.; Stump, G.;
ˇ
5. Corminboeuf, O.; Bezençon, O.; Remen, L.; Grisotomi, C.; Richard-Bildstein, S.;
Bur, D.; Prade, L.; Strickner, P.; Hess, P.; Fischli, W.; Steiner, B.; Treiber, A.;
Vaughn, C. Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 2010, 20, 6291.
6. Chen, A.; Bayly, C.; Bezençon, O.; Richard-Bildstein, S.; Dubé, D.; Dubé, L.;
Gagné, S.; Gallant, M.; Gaudreault, M.; Grimm, E.; Houle, R.; Lacombe, P.;
Laliberté, S.; Lévesque, J. F.; Liu, S.; MacDonald, D.; Mackay, B.; Martin, D.;
ˇ
McKay, D.; Powell, D.; Remen, L.; Soisson, S.; Toulmond, S. Bioorg. Med. Chem.
Lett. 2010, 20, 2204.
7. Nigam, S. C.; Mann, A.; Taddei, M.; Wermuth, C.-G. Synth. Commun. 1989, 19,
3139.
8. Buffer assay: Human recombinant renin (Proteos) at 100 pM was incubated in
the presence or absence of renin inhibitors and 6
DNP-Lys–His–Pro–Phe–His–Leu–Val–Ile–His- -Amp
l
M of Q-FRET substrate 9
in 50 mM MOPS,
D,L
100 mM NaCl, pH 7.4, 0.002% Tween. The reactions take place in a Costar 384
well black plate at 37 °C for 3 h. Fluorescence was measured at times 0 and 3 h
in a SpectraMax Gemini EM reader with excitation and emission filters at 328
and 388 nm, respectively. Plasma assay: Frozen human EDTA-plasma was
rapidly thawed in warm water and centrifuged at 2900 g for 15 min at 40 °C.
The supernatant was collected and recombinant human renin (Proteos) added
at 1 nm nominal concentration. The plasma was transferred to Costar black 384
well plates, renin inhibitors added and the mixture pre-incubated at 37 °C for
10 min. The renin Q-FRET substrate QXL520-Lys–His–Pro–Phe–His–Leu–Val–Ile–
His–Lys-(5-FAM) (Proteos), diluted in 3 M Tris/200 mM EDTA, pH 7.2 was added
to the plasma with final concentrations of 342 mM Tris, 23 mM EDTA and
6.8 lM substrate. The plate was incubated at 37 °C for 1 h and the plate read in
a SpectraMax Gemini EM reader with excitation and emission filters at 490 and
520 nm, respectively, at time 0 and 1 h.