Organic Letters
Letter
Initially, the 2,2′-diester aziridine 1b, para-nitrobenzoic acid
2a, and N-Ts ynamide 3a were employed to explore the reaction
conditions (Table 1). The L3-PiPr3/Sc(III)/LiNTf2 catalyst,
To reduce the impact of the erosion of diester aziridine under
Lewis acidic conditions, the amount of 1b was increased to 1.5
equiv, and the amount of 4 Å molecular sieve, which can slow
down the hydrolysis of azomethine ylides, was increased from 50
to 130 mg, and thus the desired 4b was obtained in 51% yield
with 95% ee (entry 7). Moreover, the yield could be increased to
74% with the ee value reduced to 86% (entry 8) when N-
methanesulfonyl protecting diester aziridine 1d was used as the
substrate, probably because the N-methanesulfonyl protecting
group enhances the stability of the azomethine ylides formed in
situ from 2,2′-diester aziridines. It was surprising that a small
excessive amount of metal salt (L3-PiEt2Br/Ho(OTf)3 = 1/1.1)
could further increase the reactivity with maintained enantio-
selectivity (entry 9, 86% yield, 87% ee). Under the current
reaction conditions, the two-component [3 + 2] cycloaddition
product 5d could be isolated with ∼10% yield. However, when
2,2′-diester aziridine 1c and ynamide 3a were mixed under
optimized conditions, [3 + 2] cycloaddition occurred and
delivered the tetra-substituted 3-pyrroline 5c in 50% yield
without enantioselectivity (eq 1). In addition, we surveyed other
ligands. Superior Box and BINOL did not give any
enantioselectivity (entries 10−12).
a
Table 1. Optimization of the Reaction Conditions
b
c
entry
meal salt
ligand
solvent
yield (%)
ee (%)
1
2
3
4
5
6
Sc(OTf)3
La(OTf)3
Ho(OTf)3
Ho(OTf)3
Ho(OTf)3
Ho(OTf)3
Ho(OTf)3
Ho(OTf)3
Ho(OTf)3
Ho(OTf)3
Ho(OTf)3
Ho(OTf)3
L3-PiPr2
L3-PiPr2
L3-PiPr2
L3-PiEt2
L3-PiEt2Br
L3-PiEt2Br
L3-PiEt2Br
L3-PiEt2Br
L3-PiEt2Br
tBu-Box
toluene
toluene
toluene
toluene
toluene
CHCl3
CHCl3
CHCl3
CHCl3
CHCl3
CHCl3
CHCl3
trace
11
28
13
28
34
51
74
86
28
15
25
53
57
74
82
90
95
86
87
0
Next, we turned our attention to the substrate generality
under optimal reaction conditions. First, diester aziridines 1a−
1m were investigated. As shown in Scheme 2, 1a−1d with an N-
d
7
e
8
ef
,
9
a
ef
,
Scheme 2. Substrate Scope of 2,2′-Diester Aziridines
10
11
12
ef
,
iPr-Pybox
(S)-BINOL
0
0
ef
,
a
Unless otherwise noted, all reactions were carried out with ligand/
metal salt/LiNTf2 (1:1:1.5, 10 mol %), 1b (0.10 mmol), 2a (1.0
equiv), 3a (1.0 equiv), and 4 Å molecule sieve (50 mg) in solvent (1.0
b
mL) under a N2 atmosphere at 35 °C for 24 h. Isolated yield.
c
d
Determined by chiral HPLC analysis. 1b (1.5 equiv), 4 Å molecule
e
sieves (130 mg), and CHCl3 (2.0 mL) were used. 1d (1.5 equiv), 4 Å
molecule sieves (130 mg), and CHCl3 (2.0 mL) were used. Ligand/
f
metal salt 1:1.1.
which was efficient in the three-component reaction of ortho-
hydroxybenzyl alcohols with ynamides and carboxylic acid,6 is
inoperative in this reaction (entry 1). Next, various metal salts
were screened by complexing with L3-PiPr2 (entries 2 and 3).
The rare-earth metal complex of Ho(OTf)3 could provide the
desired product 4b in 28% yield with 57% ee (entry 3). The low
yield was caused by the hydrolysis of aziridine 1b and the
generation of the byproduct 3-pyrroline 5, which was produced
by the [3 + 2] cycloaddition of aziridine 1b and ynamide 3a
(Scheme 1, path i and eq 1). Then, an examination of the steric
a
All reactions were carried out with L3-PiEt2Br/Ho(OTf)3/LiNTf2
(1:1.1:1.5, 10 mol %), 1 (1.5 equiv), 2a (0.10 mmol), 3a (1.0 equiv),
and 4 Å molecule sieve (130 mg) in CHCl3 (2.0 mL) under a N2
atmosphere at 35 °C for 24 h.
hindrance of the ligands was conducted, and a significant
influence on the enantioselectivity was exhibited. L3-PiEt2 with a
decreased steric hindrance improved the ee value to 74%, but the
yield decreased (Table 1, entry 4). L3-PiEt2Br with a bromo
atom at the para position of phenyl ring further improved the ee
to 82% ee with the yield remaining low (entry 5). When the
reaction was carried out in CHCl3, the yield could be increased
to 34%, and the enantioselectivity increased to 90% ee (entry 6).
methylsulfonyl protecting group or N-phenylsulfonyl protecting
group could afford the corresponding products 4a−4d in
moderate yields with good ee values (53−86% yield, 87−94%
ee). 1d−1i bearing different substituent groups, such as Me−,
F−, Cl−, Br−, and phenyl−, on the para position of the Ar1 ring
could be transformed to the corresponding products 4d−4i in
moderate to good yields with good ee values (43−86% yield,
87−94% ee). When 2-naphthyl-substituted diester aziridine 1j
2955
Org. Lett. 2021, 23, 2954−2958