Organic Process Research & Development
Communication
While it is widely accepted that triazenes offer improved
thermal and shock sensitivity compared with the corresponding
diazonium salts, we have been unable to find any systematic
studies of structure−stability relationship (SSR) trends between
these two species. Herein we report a preliminary study toward
establishing such structure−stability relationships. Our project
design features the preparation of a set of tetrafluoroborate
diazonium salts bearing electron-rich, electron-poor and ortho,
meta, and para substituents, together with the corresponding
triazenes. In the triazene series, the secondary amine component
could also impact the stability of these materials, so a range of
secondary amines was designed, encompassing examples that
are cyclic (with different ring sizes), acyclic, and of different
symmetries. A few reports have measured decomposition
energies and decomposition temperatures of triazenes but
have not compared them directly to those of the corresponding
diazonium salts in a systematic manner. Lippert et al. showed
that the decomposition temperature of triazenes decreases with
the electron-withdrawing capacity of the substituents on the
aromatic ring, whereas the steric properties of the amine do not
must decrease in order to maintain the sample and the reference
at the same temperature. In the DSC data shown here and in the
negative peaks (increased heat flow to the sample) while
exothermic processes appear as positive peaks (decreased heat
flow to the sample). In the present work, significant exothermic
events are assigned as compound degradation.30,42 For some of
the samples studied, the DSC data exhibit overlapping peaks
because of the occurrence of different thermal events, which
complicates the extraction of peak onset temperatures. For this
reason, our analysis of exothermic peaks assigned as
decomposition is focused on the initial decomposition temper-
ature rather than the onset temperature (see Figure 2). It is
have a strong influence.30 Dobele et al. used triazenes for the
̈
formation of aryl fluorides via the Wallach reaction and
measured DSC data for one of their triazene precursors to
demonstrate the high stability of triazenes.31 Although the
stability of triazenes compared with their diazonium salts is
mentioned in most publications, no direct comparison of their
relative stabilities has been established.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
■
The designed compounds were synthesized using known
methods. The diazonium salts (2a to 8a) were prepared on a
small scale in batch by first treating the corresponding anilines
with boron trifluoride diethyl etherate followed by addition of
isoamyl nitrite. Diazonium salt 1a, derived from anthranilic acid,
was not prepared because it is known to be a contact
explosive.32−38 The triazene compound series was prepared
using a telescoped continuous flow process optimized to
generate and consume the diazonium salt in situ while avoiding
precipitation of the intermediate diazonium salt (see Figure
3).39−41
Figure 2. DSC data for the anthranilic acid derived triazene 1b,
annotated to show the analysis and interpretation of different thermal
events.
important to note that, for a given sample, the initial
decomposition temperature will vary depending on the heating
rate used in the DSC measurement. However, as the DSC data
for all of the samples studied here were recorded at the same
heating rate (20 °C min−1), differences in the initial
decomposition temperatures of different samples provide a
reliable qualitative indication of their relative thermal stabilities.
Our 13C NMR data for the triazene series suggest that these
molecules undergo restricted rotation, as previously reported for
such materials (i.e., variable-temperature 13C NMR experiments
demonstrate temperature-dependent coalescence behav-
ior).30,43−50 There is inconsistency in the manner in which
this issue is reported in the literaturein some cases, the
observation of fewer 13C environments than expected is not even
addressed, while other cases simply note that the NMR data are
inconsistent with the proposed structure (with reference to the
restricted rotation phenomenon). To address this issue more
rigorously, the present paper reports 13C NMR data at three
different temperatures for each triazene studied (see the
temperature-dependent 13C NMR data can be used to calculate
the rotational energy barrier in the case of triazene 8b.
The degradation temperature of each compound was assessed
using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). DSC is a
thermoanalytical technique in which a sample and a reference
(typically an empty sample holder) are heated or cooled at a
constant rate. The mode of operation differs for different types
of DSC instrument (e.g., power-compensated DSC or heat-flux
DSC), but the basic principle is that the instrument attempts to
maintain the sample and reference at the same temperature
throughout the heating/cooling process by varying the amounts
of heat that the instrument exchanges with the sample and with
the reference or by allowing heat exchange to occur between the
sample and the reference. As the present work is focused on
studying sample degradation at high temperature, the DSC
experiments involved heating the sample (and reference) from
20 °C to a temperature in the range of 160−250 °C at a rate of 20
°C min−1. If an endothermic or exothermic process occurs in the
sample, the amount of energy required to heat the sample differs
from the amount of energy required to heat the reference. For
example, during an endothermic process in the sample (e.g.,
melting), the energy supplied to the sample must increase in
order to maintain the sample and reference at the same
temperature; conversely, during an exothermic process in the
sample (e.g., decomposition), the energy supplied to the sample
The initial decomposition temperatures derived from the
DSC measurements are presented in Figure 3 (with further
B
Org. Process Res. Dev. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX