CONVENTIONAL AND MICROWAVE-ASSISTED SPPS APPROACH
The application of MW irradiation in peptide chemistry has
been reported in several publications, most of which describe
case studies of successful syntheses of difficult peptide sequences
[6–8]. However, a definitive comparison of conventional RT and
MW-assisted-SPPS protocols must be performed on identical in-
struments. In fact, comparing conventional RT and MW-assisted
SPPS carried out on different instruments that apply protocols
that differ in the equivalent excess of reagents and their molar
ratios, stirring techniques and the nature and number of washing
steps, may be misleading. Moreover, the automated synthesizers
are generally developed to produce peptides without monitoring
of the progress of the synthesis. Therefore by-products caused by
side reactionssuchasaspartimide anddiketopiperazine formation,
incomplete couplings and deprotections may be detected only
after the final cleavage of the deprotected peptide from the resin.
In this study we compared the Fmoc/tBu RT-SPPS with the MW-
assisted synthesis of the 1–34 N-terminal fragment of PTHrP using
the same instrument (Liberty, CEM, Matthews, NC, USA), and
monitoring the progress of the synthesis by UPLC-ESI-MS of MW-
assisted mini-cleaved fragments of the growing peptide chain.
PTHrP is an autocrine, paracrine and intracrine regulator of
processes such as endochondrial bone formation and epithe-
lial–mesenchymal interactions during the development of mam-
mary glands. In analogy to PTH, most of the known biological
functions are exerted by the N-terminal PTHrP(1–34) fragment
that has 60% sequence similarity to PTH(1–34). The sequence of
PTHrP(1–34)NH2 is shown in Figure 1. In the past, this sequence
was the subject of numerous structure–activity–conformation
relationship studies [9,10]. Importantly, the presence of clusters
of arginine, of sterically hindered and hydrophobic amino acid
residues in the sequence represents a synthetic challenge that
was the subject of our comparative study reported herein.
The synthesis was initially carried out following the con-
ventional RT protocol using the Liberty automated peptide
synthesizer excluding MW irradiations. As modern automated
SPPS protocols allow the assembly of larger and increasingly
complex peptides, a precise control of the coupling reactions
is a crucial prerequisite in peptide synthesis. In fact monitoring
the progress of synthesis allows the detection of undesirable
products caused by side reactions, incomplete couplings or
deprotections. Although different methods have been developed
for monitoring of SPPS, we observed that the use of colorimetric
monitoring or continuous-flow UV absorbance of the reaction
column effluent was not informative enough to identify difficult
steps in the synthesis. Therefore, we decided to monitor the
progress of PTHrP(1–34)NH2 synthesis by UPLC-ESI-MS analyses
of small aliquots of cleaved peptide fragments obtained by
MW-assisted mini-cleavages. The application of MW-assisted
mini-cleavages of resin-bound peptides has been proposed as a
fast, reliable method to monitor SPPS [11]. After specific coupling
cycles, suspected to be difficult, we stopped the synthesizer and
withdrew a small aliquot for analysis by UPLC-ESI-MS. In particular,
we focused our attention on the PTHrP fragments related to the
19–28 sequence, characterized by clusters of Arg residues and
highly hydrophobic residues (see Reaction Scheme and Figure 1).
By UPLC-ESI-MS analyses of intermediate fragments of the
PTHrP(1–34)NH2 included in the 19–34 sequence we noticed the
presence of the desired peptide as well as of some by-products
(Table 1 and Figure 2). The fragmentation patterns of these by-
products in ESI-MS/MS allowed us to confirm the formation of dele-
tion sequences as reported in Supporting Information (Figure S1).
As the length of the resin-bound peptide increases, the related
UPLC-ESI-MS analyses become much more complex. We report
as an example the characterization of the 12–34 fragment
of PTHrP(1–34)NH2. The deconvoluted spectrum obtained for
the cleaved mixture of this sample resulted in several deletion
sequences (Figure 3). The fragments desLys13/Gln16-f(12–34) and
desLys13/Gln16,Leu27-f(12–34) were identified as two isobaric
peptide sequences lacking either Lys13 or Gln16 residues.
The UPLC-ESI-MS/MS analyses of the intermediate resin-bound
fragments obtained from the RT-SPPS of PTHrP(1–34)NH2 confirm
that it is a difficult sequence for SPPS. The desired peptide was
usually present as the major component in the cleavage mixture,
but it was accompanied by some deletion peptides mainly lacking
Arg, Leu and His residues. It is well known that Arg-containing
peptides are difficult to synthesize due to the sterically hindered
Pbf group as side-chain protection and the tendency to form
γ -lactam leading to low yield couplings [12].
With the above information in hand we sought to improve
the synthesis of this difficult sequence of PTHrP(1–34)NH2 by
employing MW-assisted SPPS using Liberty automated peptide
synthesizer with MW irradiations. To address the difficulties
observed during the incorporation of Arg and His residues
we applied the protocols reported in Table 2. Specifically, we
have decreased the power of MW irradiation and lowered the
temperature in order to avoid side reactions such as γ -lactam
formation for Arg and racemization for His [13].
Indeed, after semi-preparative purification the MW-assisted
SPPS of PTHrP(1–34)NH2 yielded 27 mg of >95% pure peptide,
whereas RT-SPPS gave only 18 mg of >95% of pure peptide. This
improvement is attributed to the higher purity of the crude cleaved
peptide mixture (Table 3 and Figure 4).
On the basis of the results of the analytical RP-HPLC of the crude
PTHrP(1–34)NH2, we conclude that the use of MW irradiations
in SPPS has enhanced the efficiency of crucial coupling cycles
improving the final yield and purity of crude peptide and speeding
up the remaining coupling cycles. This improvement can be
attributed to the prevention of peptide backbone aggregation
and acceleration of deprotection and coupling steps.
In summary, although the application of MW-assisted SPPS
to the synthesis of PTHrP(1–34)NH2 led only to a moderate
improvement in final yield (6.3% vs 4.4%), it allowed us to
obtain a crude product of higher quality (77% vs 35%) and in
a shorter time (20 h vs 34 h used for the RT and MW-assisted SPPS
strategies). Moreover, we demonstrated the usefulness of the
combination of an MW-assisted mini-cleavage protocol and the
UPLC-ESI-MS analysis for monitoring the quality of the reaction
step (see Supporting Information). Compared to the ninhydrin
colorimetric monitoring, our strategy is faster and the UPLC-ESI-
MS/MS analysis is more accurate and more informative. We think
that application of the strategy presented in this report will help
to improve many syntheses of difficult sequences.
Experimental Procedures
RT and MW-assisted SPPS of PTHrP(1–34)NH2
All Fmoc-protected amino acids and TBTU were purchased from
Iris Biotech. (Marktdrewitz, Germany). The following amino acid
side-chain-protecting groups were used: OtBu (Asp, Glu), tBu (Ser,
Thr), Pbf (Arg), Trt (Gln, His) and Boc (Lys). Rink-amide NovaSyn
TGR resin was purchased from Novabiochem (Laufelfingen,
Switzerland). ACN, DCM and diethyl ether from Sigma-Aldrich
c
J. Pept. Sci. 2011; 17: 708–714 Copyright ꢀ 2011 European Peptide Society and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/jpepsci