D. T. Richter et al. / Tetrahedron Letters 54 (2013) 4610–4612
4611
3
5
R1
R2
R1
R2
N
H
X
N
X
X
N
N
H
N
R1
R1
R1
Δ
Base
N
R2
N
1
N
R2
Cl
N
N
R2
Cl
N
Cl
4
R= H, F, Cl, Br, Me, OMe
2a-f
R1
R2
CF3
N
H
CF3
Cl
CF3
N
N
N
R1
R1
Cl
N
N
Base
N
R2
N
7
Cl
N
6
Cl
R2
8
1:1 Mixture
Figure 1. 2,4-Diaminopyrimidine synthesis.
(LA) appeared to be the only viable solution. Initially, protic acids
(HCl or Acetic acid) were employed, both as an additive and by pre-
paring amine salts. However, due to the diminished solubility of
these salts the reactions were slow or did not occur at all. Upon
the addition of base, the reaction would proceed but only give
the same 1:1 mixture of isomers observed previously. This result
led us to investigate Lewis acids, which also have the potential to
coordinate with the nitrogens of the pyrimidine. If coordination oc-
curs to the pyrimidine it was believed to favor substitution at the
less sterically hindered C-2 position.
While these results were quite exciting there were a few ani-
lines that did not show any changes in selectivity. Most notably,
p-methoxyaniline gave an 8:1 ratio while o-methoxyaniline gave
only a 1:1 ratio (Table 2). In this case it was believed that the o-
methoxy aniline was involved in a chelating effect with the LA such
that coordination to the pyrimidine was not occurring. Upon addi-
tion of 2 equiv of LA the selectivity increased from 1:1 to 9:1.
A similar result was obtained for 4-dimethylaminoaniline which
went from 1:1 to 11:1 (Table 2). As a result anilines with any sub-
stitution capable of complexing with the zinc or forming a chelate
as in the o-methoxy case can be added selectively with additional
equivalents of LA.
These positive results suggested that the effect could carry over
to more nucleophilic alkyl amines which also did not show any in-
creased selectivity with 1 equiv of LA. Because of the increased
nucleophilicity of these amines the initial attempts with 1 equiv
of ZnCl2 were unsuccessful. With 2 equiv of LA, the complex
formed crashes out of solution immediately. However, the reaction
takes 24 h to reach completion compared to the typical 2–4 h seen
with anilines while the selectivity increased to only 5:1 (Table 2).
Yet, this moderate selectivity is quite useful since these analogs
can be isolated via crystallization.
Initially it was believed that the Lewis acid was complexing
with the pyrimidine and thus directing the chemistry to the less
hindered site, however attempts at isolating a pyrimidine/LA com-
plex were unsuccessful and no discernable effects could be seen in
the Fluorine NMR when ZnCl2 was present. Since precipitate
formed when the two reagents were combined, it was believed
that the Lewis acid was instead coordinating with the amine. Since
zinc is capable of coordinating with two coordinating nitrogens it
was expected that this selectivity would be seen with fewer than
1 equiv of Lewis acid, and that is indeed the case. Increased selec-
tivity was observed with as little as 0.25 equiv of ZnCl2 although
optimal results were obtained when sufficient LA was present to
moderate the reaction.
With the conditions optimized, it was of interest to see if ZnCl2
could be used to alter the selectivity of additions to other dichloro-
pyrimidines. The results from a small set of pyrimidines showed
that 5-H and 5-Me were both shifted from approximately 9:1 to
nearly 1:1, 5-Cl experienced no change (see Table 1). This repre-
sents an encouraging breakthrough in the chemistry of these sys-
tems, as the two isomers formed are easily separable by normal
phase chromatography. Other LA may be able to shift the product
distribution even more significantly to the typically unfavored
isomers.
For this initial study, 6 was combined with 1.1 equiv of a com-
mercially available Lewis acid prior to addition of 4-methylaniline
(1.0 equiv) followed by the triethylamine base (1.1 equiv). The
crude reaction mixtures from this screen were analyzed by HPLC
to determine the isomeric ratio of 7 to 8. Using the original reaction
conditions (THF, RT, 1 equiv Et3N), a screen of 18 readily available
Lewis acids was employed (ZnCl2, Zn(OAc)2, BF3–Et2O, Mg(OTf)2,
MgCl2, MgBr2, CuCl, CuCl2, SnCl2, SnCl4, LiCl, LiOAc, AgNO3, AgOTf,
TiCl4, EtAlCl2, DIP-Cl, BCl3, 1.1 equiv). Initial results offered some
small improvements, in particular zinc salts were most effective
followed by CuCl2 and AgOTf. ZnCl2 exhibited the best improve-
ment of selectivity with a 4:1 ratio of 7 to 8. A more detailed inves-
tigation involving ZnCl2 as an additive and some minor
optimization of reaction conditions provided a 10-fold increase in
selectivity from the initial 1:1 ratio seen with no Lewis Acid
(Table 2). By switching to a solvent mixture of DCE/t-BuOH and
allowing the Lewis acid to complex with the amine and pyrimidine
before the addition of the base (which eliminated the need for
cooling reactions to 0 °C) >10:1 selectivity could be obtained. Com-
parison of this data with the isomeric ratio of the substitution reac-
tion run in the absence of an additive, provided evidence
suggesting that the addition of zinc chloride enhanced the selectiv-
ity ratio of 7:8 in favor of the less polar isomer 7. Additionally,
these simple changes applied to a wide variety of substituted ani-
lines, including those with electron withdrawing (EWG) and
donating groups (EDG), demonstrated that the selectivity in some
cases could be increased up to 17:1 (Table 2).
Table 1
Percent isomer ratios for selected pyrimidines reacted with 4-methylaniline
Pyrimidine
X
4-Isomer
2-Isomer
2a
2c
2e
6
H
CH3
Cl
95 (49)
95 (58)
100 (100)
40 (5)
5 (51)
<5 (28)
0 (0)
The addition of Lewis acids, most notably ZnCl2, to amine sub-
stitution reactions on 2,4-dichloro-5-trifluoromethylpyrimidine
CF3
60 (95)
⁄
Results in parenthesis are with ZnCl2.