ACS Medicinal Chemistry Letters
Letter
a
Scheme 1. Synthesis of Oxapenems
a
Reagents: (a) EtOH, NaSMe, 0−25 °C, 60−70%; (b) DMF, TBDMSCl, DABCO, 80−90%; (c) RCHO, LDA, THF, −78 °C, 40−50%; (d) Ac2O,
TEA, DMAP, 80−90%; (e) TBAF/AcOH, THF, 60−80%; (f) Cs2CO3/ACN, 50−70%; (g) LHMDS/THF, 60−70%; (h) NCS, silica, DCM, 30−
t
40%; (i) BuOK/tBuOH, THF, 20−30%; (j) TPP, Pd(PPh3)4/DCM, sodium-2-ethyl hexanoate, 40−50%.
diastereomers. Protection of the hydroxyl group (→ 5) was
followed by desilylation (→ 6) and alkylation to give 7.
Acylation of the acetate in 7 with pivaloyl chloride gave access
to intermediate 8. Conversion of the methyl thioether into a
chloride (9) set the stage for a base-mediated cyclization with
concomitant elimination of the acetoxy group to form the C6-
alkylidene (10). It should be noted that the last step removed
two chiral centers, resulting in a significant reduction of
complexity as the mixture no longer consisted of eight
diastereomers but was instead a single racemate. The synthesis
was completed by deallylation to give target compound 11 as
the sodium salt. The yields for each step were generally
moderate to good. A slightly lower yield was observed for the
key aldol condensation (3 → 4) as well as for the last two steps.
The lower yields for the last two steps presumably result from
the susceptibility of alkylidene penems to hydrolysis.
We next evaluated the inhibitory activities of the oxapenems
against representative serine β-lactamases from class A, C, and
D and compared them with those of the marketed β-lactamase
inhibitor clavulanic acid (12, Table 1). β-Lactamase inhibitory
activities were evaluated following 5 min preincubation in an
enzymatic turnover assay utilizing the colorimetric substrate
nitrocefin. The racemic 2-furan E-alkylidene 13, first reported
by Wild et al.,12 was significantly more potent than
enantiomerically pure clavulanic acid, particularly against class
C and D enzymes. In fact, 13 showed single digit to double
digit nanomolar IC50s against all class A, C, and D β-lactamases
tested. The observed inhibitory activity for 13 is among the best
reported to date for any β-lactamase inhibitor. To assess the
role of the alkylidene substituent, compound 14, lacking the
alkylidene, was synthesized. It was evident by comparing 13
and 14 that the conjugated double bond at the C6 position of
the oxapenem scaffold is essential to obtain broad-spectrum
activity, particularly against class A enzymes. However, the
desalkylidene compound 14 remained surprisingly potent
against class C enzymes (and to a slightly lesser extent against
class D enzymes).
compounds 15E and 16E were significantly more potent
inhibitors than their corresponding Z isomers. Table 1 also
showed that replacement of the 2-furan (13) with a phenyl
group (15) resulted in increased potency against class C
enzymes, but reduced activity against the class A carbapene-
mase KPC-2. While compound 16E, containing a 3-furan
group, was more potent against KPC-2 than the compound
with the phenyl substituent (15E), its activity was less than that
of the 2-furan (13), particularly against class C enzymes.
Finally, we examined the effect of introduction of
substituents on the aromatic ring by making the o-, m-, and
p-methoxyphenyl alkylidenes (17−19). As can be seen from
Table 1, substitution at each of these 3 positions was tolerated,
with the resulting compounds displaying similar or slightly
improved potency compared to unsubstituted phenyl 15E.
During the course of this preliminary SAR evaluation, we
realized that further optimization of activity would be a fruitless
endeavor if we did not first address the severe stability issues
observed for this initial set of compounds. The stability of the
compounds in Table 1 was too low to allow evaluation in more
advanced models, such as cellular activity assays (inhibition of
bacterial growth) or determination of physicochemical proper-
ties. Surprisingly, we found that even under strictly anhydrous
conditions, the compounds in Table 1 suffered from rapid
degradation. Analysis of the reaction mixtures revealed that the
degradation pathways for anhydrous and aqueous degradation
differed, raising the interesting possibility that this class of
compounds suffered from photolytic instability in addition to
hydrolytic instability.
Indeed, under carefully controlled conditions, we were able
to separate the two distinct degradation pathways (Scheme 2).
Thus, HPLC−MS−MS analysis of the degradation mixture in
aqueous buffer with exclusion of light suggested that hydrolytic
degradation proceeded through opening of the β-lactam with
concomitant decarboxylation (D1). An additional minor peak
with an identical mass and mass-spec fragmentation pattern but
shorter retention time was also detected, suggesting formation
of an isomer of D1 (D2). However, analysis of an anhydrous
DMSO solution of 13 subjected to ambient lighting suggested
formation of three major degradants from two separate
Having confirmed the essentiality of the alkylidene
substituent for broad spectrum coverage, we examined the
role of the alkylidene geometry. As shown in Table 1,
916
dx.doi.org/10.1021/ml5001855 | ACS Med. Chem. Lett. 2014, 5, 915−920