Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 2 of 11
heteroatoms attached to the central silicon, the silylarenes complexes of phenanthrolines bearing methyl groups in the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
produced from the functionalization of aryl and heteroaryl
C-H bonds with this reagent undergo a wide variety of
cross-coupling and functionalization reactions.8 The silyla-
tions catalyzed by a rhodium-bisphosphine complex we re-
ported functionalize arenes with high sterically-derived re-
gioselectivity. However, a series of functional groups, in-
cluding Lewis basic groups, such as nitriles, most basic het-
erocycles, and reducible groups, such as aryl iodides, aryl
bromides, aryl esters, and ketones, did not undergo silyla-
tion (Scheme 1b).12 In contrast, the silylations catalyzed by
an iridium complex of 2,4,7-trimethyl phenanthroline oc-
curred with exceptionally high functional-group tolerance.
Yet, reactions catalyzed by this system required long times
and required high temperatures to reach high conversion of
starting material. Furthermore, the reactions of electron-
neutral arenes occurred in only modest yields, and the reac-
tions of electron rich arenes formed little to no product
(Scheme 1c).13
2 and the 9 positions were more than five times faster than
those catalyzed by iridium complexes of the 2, 4, 7-substi-
tuted phenanthroline L2 previously reported for the silyla-
tion of C-H bonds.
Despite the high initial rate of the silylation catalyzed by
the combination of [Ir(COD)(OMe]2 and 2,9-Me2phen, the
overall yield of this reaction was reported to be lower than
that of the reaction catalyzed by complexes containing other
ligands.13 Indeed, when the reaction of benzene and silane
catalyzed by iridium and this ligand approached 5% conver-
sion, the rate began to decrease (Figure 1), and after 15%
conversion, the amount of silylbenzene produced by the re-
action conducted with 2-methyl ligand L2 is greater than
that produced by the catalyst containing 2,9-dimethyl lig-
ands L1 or L4. We hypothesized that inhibition of the cata-
lyst by the hydrogen produced by the reaction could cause
the observed decrease in rates during reactions catalyzed
by complexes ligated by L1 or L4.
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
Here, we describe a new iridium catalyst and conditions
for the silylation of arenes with hydrosilanes that together
lead to reactions of electron-rich arenes and much faster re-
actions of heteroarenes and electron-poor arenes, along
with experimental mechanistic studies that reveal the
origin of this high reactivity. This catalyst contains 2,9-di-
methylphenanthroline (2,9-Me2phen) as ligand. The high
activity of this catalyst is masked under standard conditions
by its susceptibility to inhibition by the hydrogen byprod-
uct. The high activity is evident from initial rates and be-
comes practical when the product inhibition is alleviated by
removing the hydrogen from the system. Cleavage of the
aryl C-H bond is reversible, and the higher rates, counterin-
tuitively, appear to result from a more thermodynamically
favorable oxidative addition of C-H bonds to the iridium
complex of this hindered ligand than to complexes of lig-
ands lacking substituents in the 2 and 9 positions. Applica-
tions to the synthesis of a series of intermediates to medici-
nally important compounds demonstrate the value of this
new system.
To determine whether hydrogen inhibited the silylation
reaction, we first measured the amount of silylbenzene
formed in the presence of [Ir(COD)(OMe]2 and L1 with
added dihydrogen. The rate at which silylbenzene is formed
is ten times slower under an atmosphere of hydrogen than
under an atmosphere of nitrogen (See SI). We examined
whether a series of hydrogen acceptors could prevent inhi-
bition by hydrogen formed in the course of the reaction. The
profile of the reaction of benzene and silane was the same
in the presence or absence of cyclohexene or tetrameth-
ylethylene as hydrogen acceptors (Figure 2). Consistent
with this observation, the 1H NMR spectrum of the crude re-
action catalyzed by iridium and 2,9-Me2phen with cyclohex-
ene as the hydrogen acceptor contained signals correspond-
ing to less than 0.05 equivalents of cyclohexane, even
though 16% of the starting material was converted to prod-
uct. This result shows that the rate of the reduction of cyclo-
hexene is much lower than the rate of the silylation of ben-
zene. The conversion of silane in the reaction conducted
with the strained alkene norbornene (nbe) was higher in
less time than that in reactions conducted with other hydro-
gen acceptors, but the silylation of the alkene C-H bond of
nbe to form vinylsilane was faster than silylation of the C-H
bond of benzene, and a low yield of silylarene was observed.
Thus, the complex formed by the combination of iridium
and 2,9-Me2phen and silane does not reduce unstrained in-
ternal alkenes with hydrogen at a rate that is commensurate
with the rate of the silylation of benzene, and this complex
leads to the silylation of the C-H bond of a strained alkene.
For this reason, a different approach to removing hydrogen
from the reaction was required to prevent the inhibition of
the catalysts by hydrogen.
Results and Discussion
1. Initial Rates and Reaction Development
To identify highly active catalysts for the silylation of aryl
C-H bonds, including those of electron-rich arenes, we first
measured the rates of the silylation of benzene in the pres-
ence of an iridium pre-catalyst and phenanthrolines pos-
sessing varied steric properties. The initial rate of the reac-
tion of HSiMe(OTMS)2 and benzene was determined by
measuring the amount of silyl-arene produced at 80 °C with
a 1:1.5 ratio of benzene to silane (Figure 1). The rates of re-
actions catalyzed by the combination of
1 mol %
To test further the effect of the hydrogen byproduct, the
reaction was run in a closed system, as is typically done for
reactions on small scale, as well as a system containing a
flow of nitrogen. The reaction of o-xylene and silane cata-
lyzed by [Ir(cod)(OMe)]2 and 2,9-Me2Phen in a closed vial
produced only the silylarene in only 18% yield. However,
the same reaction conducted in a vessel equipped with a ni-
trogen inlet and gas outlet formed silylarene 4 in 77% yield
within 20 h. It appears that the flow of nitrogen gas through
the system prevents catalyst inhibition by removing
[Ir(COD)(OMe]2 and 3 mol % of four phenanthroline ligands
(L1-L4, Figure 1) containing methyl substituents in differ-
ent quantities and positions were measured. The initial
rates of the reactions catalyzed by the combination of irid-
ium and a phenanthroline containing methyl groups in the
2 and the 9 positions (L1 and L4) are higher than those of
the reactions catalyzed by the combination of iridium and
phenanthroline ligands lacking one or both of the methyl
groups in the 2 and the 9 positions (L2 and L3) (Figure 1).
The silylation of aryl C-H bonds catalyzed by iridium-
ACS Paragon Plus Environment