Angewandte
Chemie
Table 1: Results of Diels–Alder reactions catalyzed by copper LmrR_X complexes
Two residues in the pocket of LmrR_M89C_1,
(Scheme 1).[a]
that is, Val15 and Asp100, were selected for a limited
mutagenesis study because these residues are most
likely situated in close proximity to the CuII com-
plex. This selection was based on an X-ray structure
of LmrR with a manually docked phenanthroline
Entry Catalyst
Product Conversion endo:exo ee (endo)
[%]
[%]
1
2
LmrR_N19C_1_CuII
4a
4a
4a
4b
4c
4a
4a
24Æ3
93Æ4
98Æ1
56Æ9
97Æ1
55Æ8
89Æ4
38Æ4
14Æ2
30Æ5
23Æ1
29Æ8
20Æ5
full
92:8
95:5
53Æ5 (+)
97Æ1 (+)
95Æ1 (+)
93Æ1 (+)
<5
66Æ2 (À)
97Æ1 (+)
40Æ2 (+)
21Æ3 (+)
<5
LmrR_M89C_1_CuII
LmrR_M89C_1_CuII
LmrR_M89C_1_CuII
LmrR_M89C_1_CuII
LmrR_M89C_2_CuII
LmrR_M89C_V15A_1_CuII
3[b]
4
90:10
96:4
(Figure S6).
The
LmrR_M89C_V15A
and
LmrR_M89C_D100E mutants were prepared using
standard QuickChange mutagenesis methods and
the corresponding conjugates with ligand 1 were
prepared and characterized as described above. The
V15A mutation did not have an influence on the
enantioselectivity of the catalyzed Diels–Alder
reaction (entry 7, Table 1). In contrast, with the
structurally conservative D100E mutation a signifi-
cantly decreased conversion and ee value was
obtained (entry 8 and 9, Table 1) suggesting that
the catalyzed reactions are sensitive to the structure
of the microenvironment of the pore of the LmrR
scaffold.
5
6
7
8
n.a.[c]
63:37[d]
96:4
LmrR_M89C_D100E_1_CuII 4a
LmrR_M89C_D100E_1_CuII 4b
88:12
84:14
90:10
88:12
90:10
93:7
9
10
11[e]
12[f]
13
14
LmrR_M89C_CuII
LmrR_9_CuII
4a
4a
13Æ4 (+)
28Æ7 (+)
0
LmrR_Phenanthroline_CuII 4a
Phenanthroline_CuII
Phenanthroline_CuII
4a
4c
95:5
0
[a] Typical conditions: 90% Cu(H2O)6(NO3)2 (3 mol%; 30 mm) loading with respect
to LmrR_X in 20 mm MOPS buffer (pH 7.0), 150 mm NaCl, for 3 days at 48C.
Conversions and ee values are an average of two independent experiments, both
carried out in duplicate. [b] Reaction carried out at room temperature. [c] exo peak
could not be observed. [d] ee exo 90Æ2%. [e] Compound 9 was added 2:1 with
respect to LmrR (wild-type). [f] Copper phenanthroline was added 2:1 with respect
to LmrR (wild-type).
The tolerance towards variation in the structure
of the substrate was investigated using the a,b-
unsaturated 2-acyl pyridine substrates 3b and 3c.
When R = m-methoxyphenyl (3b) the same trend
was observed as with azachalcone (3a): excellent
Table 1). Performing the reaction at room temperature only
caused a small decrease in ee value (entry 3, Table 1).
The higher conversions obtained with the artificial
metalloenzyme compared to CuII-phenanthroline alone indi-
cate that the reaction is accelerated by the protein scaffold.
Indeed, following the consumption of 3a by UV/Vis spec-
troscopy showed that the reaction catalyzed by the artificial
metalloenzyme is significantly faster than the reaction
catalyzed by CuII phenanthroline alone (Figure S7). Addition
of a fresh aliquot of reagents after the reaction was complete
showed that LmrR_M89C_2 was still active, albeit slightly less
than before, indicating a small degree of inactivation over
time (Figure S7b).
Interestingly, LmrR_M89C_2, which contains a conju-
gated 2,2’-bipyridine instead of a phenanthroline ligand, gave
rise to 66% ee of the opposite, that is, the (À) enantiomer of
the endo isomer of the Diels–Alder product 4a (entry 6,
Table 1). Hence, by judicious choice of the CuII binding
ligand, both enantiomers of the Diels–Alder product can be
accessed. Furthermore, with this artificial metalloenzyme
significant amounts of the exo product were obtained also
(endo/exo 63:37), with the exo product having 90% ee. No
significant enantioselectivity was found in the control reac-
tion performed with LmrR M89C having a free cysteine
(without ligand 1 or 2, entry 10, Table 1). Additionally, low
enantioselectivities and conversions were found with wild-
type LmrR supplemented with an analogue of 1, that is, the
propionamide derivative of 1,10-phenantroline-5-amine (9),
and CuII phenanthroline (entry 12 and 13, Table 1). This result
demonstrates that the covalent linkage of the ligand to the
protein scaffold is required for selective catalysis. Using an
excess of Cu(H2O)6(NO3)2 with respect to LmrR_M89C_1
(ratio 2:1 CuII/monomer LmrR_M89C_1) resulted in precip-
itation of the protein.
ee values with LmrR_M89C_1 and a significantly lower
ee values with the D100E mutant (entries 4 and 9, Table 1).
Using 3c, which contains a methyl group at the b-position, full
conversion was achieved but the Diels–Alder product was
obtained without any significant ee value. The data obtained
with this limited set of substrates suggests some substrate
selectivity of artificial metalloenzyme, but more research is
required to understand its structural origin.
The results show that the protein scaffold is not only
a source of chirality for the reaction, but that it also causes an
acceleration of the reaction rate, that is, the reaction is protein
accelerated. Moreover, there appears to be a correlation
between the rate and the enantioselectivity of the reaction,
that is, the most enantioselective enzymes also gave rise to the
highest conversions. Furthermore, both the conversion and
ee values depend on the nature of the ligand, the position at
which the ligand is anchored to the protein scaffold, and is
also sensitive to mutation in the hydrophobic pocket. This
demonstrates that the catalysis is dependent on the structure
of the microenvironment around the catalytic CuII ion and
these combined data strongly suggest that the reaction indeed
takes place in the newly created active site in the hydrophobic
pocket at the LmrR dimer interface. At present, the effect of
the individual changes on the catalysis is difficult to ration-
alize, since LmrR shows some plasticity.[10] For this reason we
are currently performing a detailed structural study of the
LmrR-based artificial metalloenzyme.
In conclusion, we have presented a novel strategy towards
the creation of an artificial metalloenzyme, which involves
grafting a new active site onto the dimer interface of the
protein LmrR by conjugation of a bidentate ligand capable of
binding CuII ions. The dimer interface provides the chiral
microenvironment for the catalyzed reaction. The artificial
metalloenzyme is capable of catalyzing Diels–Alder reaction
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2012, 51, 1 – 5
ꢀ 2012 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
3
These are not the final page numbers!