154 Chem. Res. Toxicol., Vol. 10, No. 2, 1997
Shen et al.
primarily by nucleophilic addition of CySH to o-quinone
2, is a major precursor of many identified products.
However, yields of 2,5-bi-S-CyS-DA are low at any stage
of the oxidation reaction (2) owing to the great ease of
oxidation of this conjugate. The oxidation of 2,5-bi-S-
CyS-DA generates o-quinone 4 that can undergo in-
tramolecular cyclizations to o-quinone imines 7 and 8
(Scheme 2) (2). In order to account for formation of
DHBT-2 and DHBT-6 when 2,5-bi-S-CyS-DA is oxidized
even in the absence of free CySH, it is clear that 7 and
8 can chemically oxidize this cysteinyl conjugate by the
reaction pathways shown in Scheme 2 and discussed in
detail elsewhere (2). However, the present study estab-
lishes that oxidations of 2,5-bi-S-CyS-DA, DHBT-2, and
DHBT-6 also result in formation of the regioisomers 12
and 13, the latter always being the major product.
Accordingly, it can be concluded that intramolecular
cyclizations of both cysteinyl residues of 4, formed by
oxidation (2e, 2H+) of 2,5-bi-S-CyS-DA, leads to the
tricyclic o-diimine 11. Decarboxylation of 11 from C-2′
or C-9′, the preferred route, then leads to regioisomers
12 and 13, respectively (Scheme 2). Borohydride reduc-
tion of 12 and 13 to 14 and 15, respectively, provides a
valuable method to convert these sparingly soluble ben-
zothiazines into much more soluble dihydrobenzothiaz-
ines. Spectroscopic evidence, particularly on 15, permits
unequivocal structure assignment and hence the struc-
ture of 13. The bright yellow color that progressively
develops during oxidations of DA in the presence of CySH
can be traced primarily to BT-1, 12, and 13, i.e., products
derived 5-S-CyS-DA and from 2,5-bi-S-CyS-DA, DHBT-
2, and DHBT-6, respectively.
The upregulation of nigral γ-GT (10), irreversible loss
of GSH (18-20), and increased 5-S-CyS-DA/DA concen-
tration ratio (21) are all compatible with the hypothesis
that an elevated translocation of CySH into neuromela-
nin-pigmented SN neurons might occur in PD. The
observation that surviving dopaminergic cells are less
heavily pigmented in the Parkinsonian SN compared to
age-matched controls (15-17) would also be expected, by
analogy with the results of in vitro studies, as a conse-
quence of the diversion of the neuromelanin pathway by
CySH. The in vitro products of oxidation of DA in the
presence of free CySH include not only 5-S-CyS-DA but,
as a consequence of the fact that this conjugate is more
easily oxidized than the neurotransmitter (1, 2), many
additional cysteinyldopamines, DHBTs, BT-1, 12, and 13.
Whether a similarly complex mixture of metabolites is
formed in the cytoplasm of neuromelanin-pigmented SN
neurons in PD remains to be established. However, that
the initial step in formation of such metabolites occurs
in PD is supported by the increased 5-S-CyS-DA/DA ratio
in the SN (21) and the increased 5-S-CyS-DA/HVA ratio
in CSF (22). Furthermore, a number of lines of evidence
support the conclusion that 5-S-CyS-DA is formed as a
result of oxidation of cytoplasmic DA (21, 25, 26).
Particularly in the cytoplasm of pigmented SN neurons,
in which DA is autoxidized to form neuromelanin (6, 7),
5-S-CyS-DA must almost certainly undergo further oxi-
dation. In the presence of free CySH such an in vivo
oxidation reaction would lead to the more complex
cysteinyl dopamines, DHBTs, BT-1, 12, and 13 that are
formed in the in vitro reaction. The results presented
in this and earlier reports (1, 2) indicate that 2,5-bi-S-
CyS-DA, DHBT-1, DHBT-2, DHBT-5, DHBT-6 (and other
DHBTs), 12, and 13 are toxic (lethal) when administered
into the ventricular system of mice and evoke a charac-
teristic neurobehavioral response. Interestingly, 13 (LD50
) 1.5 µg), the major product of oxidation of 2,5-bi-S-CyS-
DA (LD50 ) 37 µg), DHBT-2 (LD50 ) 70 µg), and DHBT-6
(LD50 ) 17 µg), is the most toxic compound discovered in
these investigations. Thus, it appears that as the oxida-
tion reactions of DA in the presence of CySH progress
through cysteinyldopamines and DHBTs to 13 increas-
ingly toxic putative metabolites are formed. These
observations raise the possibility that one or more of
these putative nigral metabolites might be endotoxins
that contribute to SN cell death in PD. However, there
is currently no evidence that any of these compounds are
dopaminergic neurotoxins or that they are formed in the
Parkinsonian brain. Nevertheless, all other factors being
equal, intraneuronal formation of 5-S-CyS-DA, other
cysteinyldopamines, DHBTs, BT-1, 12, and 13 would be
expected to be most extensive in those neurons that
sustain the highest basal levels of DA autoxidation, i.e.,
SN cells normally most heavily pigmented with neu-
romelanin. Thus, it may be significant that such neurons
appear to be preferentially vulnerable to degeneration
in PD (15-17).
In summary, three new compounds, BT-1, 12, and 13,
have been identified as products formed in the relatively
late stages of the in vitro oxidation of DA in the presence
of CySH. The immediate precursor of BT-1 is DHBT-1.
The immediate precursors of 12 and 13 are 2,5-bi-S-CyS-
DA, DHBT-2, and DHBT-6. The results presented and
hypothesis advanced in this paper are based on the
influence of CySH on the in vitro electrochemically driven
oxidation of DA, the toxicity of many resulting products,
and other known changes that are known to occur in the
Parkinsonian brain. While it is plausible to expect that
similar chemistry would accompany the autoxidation of
DA in pigmented dopaminergic SN cells as a result of
the hypothesized γ-GT-mediated translocation of CySH
into these neurons, this remains to be experimentally
verified. Furthermore, while a rather remarkable num-
ber of products formed from the electrochemical oxidation
of DA in the presence of CySH are relatively potent toxins
in mouse brains, particularly 13, it must be emphasized
that it is not yet known whether any of these putative
nigral metabolites evoke degeneration of SN neurons and
therefore might play a role in the pathogenesis of PD.
Ack n ow led gm en t. This work was supported by
Grant NS-29886 from the National Institutes of Health.
Refer en ces
(1) Zhang, F., and Dryhurst, G. (1994) Effects of L-cysteine on the
oxidation chemistry of dopamine: New reaction pathways of
potential relevance to idiopathic Parkinson’s Disease. J . Med.
Chem. 37, 1084-1098.
(2) Shen, X.-M., and Dryhurst, G. (1996) Further insights into the
influence of L-cysteine on the oxidation chemistry of dopamine:
Reaction pathways of potential relevance to Parkinson’s Disease.
Chem. Res. Toxicol. 9, 751-763.
(3) Zhang, F., and Dryhurst, G. (1995) Reactions of cysteine and
cysteine derivatives with dopamine-o-quinone and further in-
sights into the oxidation chemistry of 5-S-cysteinyldopamine:
Potential relevance to idiopathic Parkinson’s Disease. Bioorg.
Chem. 23, 193-216.
(4) Tse, D. C. S., McCreery, R. L., and Adams, R. N. (1976) Potential
oxidative pathways of brain catecholamines. J . Med. Chem. 19,
37-40.
(5) Zhang, F., and Dryhurst, G. (1993) Oxidation chemistry of
dopamine: Possible insights into the age-dependent loss of
dopaminergic nigrostriatal neurons. Bioorg. Chem. 21, 392-410.
(6) Graham, D. G. (1978) Oxidation pathways for catecholamines in
the genesis of neuromelanin and cytotoxic quinones. Mol. Phar-
macol. 14, 633-643.