272
A.L.P. de Meireles et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 502 (2015) 271–275
renders HPAs higher catalytic activities than conventional acid cat-
alysts, such as mineral acids, zeolites and ion-exchange resins. HPAs
as catalysts cause less corrosion and environmental problems than
mineral acids and do not promote undesirable side reactions. Even
from homogeneous systems HPAs can be recovered and recycled
without neutralization because they are highly soluble in polar sol-
vents, on the one hand, and insoluble in non-polar solvents (e.g.,
polar solvent.
Previously, we have applied HPA catalysts in a variety of liquid-
phase reactions of terpenic compounds, such as isomerization
[28–32], hydration, etherification and esterification [33–35], and
cycloaddition [36]. Within our program on the valorization of nat-
ural ingredients of essential oils by catalytic transformations, we
report now the application of tungstophosphoric heteropoly acid
H3PW12O40 (HPW), the strongest HPA in the Keggin series, as a
homogeneous catalyst for the isomerization of nerolidol (1) and
farnesol (2) aiming to obtain ␣-bisabolol (3). To our knowledge, no
attempt to use HPA catalysts for these reactions has been made so
far. Moreover, none of the previous works, as far as we know, have
achieved such a high yield of ␣-bisabolol.
was predominantly formed under these conditions rather than the
desired ␣-bisabolol. The selectivity for ␣-bisabolol did not exceed
40%. At 50 ◦C, the results were even less encouraging in terms of
selectivity (Table 1, run 2). On the other hand, to run the reaction
nerolidol to ␣-bisabolol. The formation of farnesol in significant
amounts was detected at low conversions. Then, the concentra-
tion of farnesol decreased, whereas the selectivity of ␣-bisabolol
(Table 1, runs 4 and 5). In both runs, ␣-bisabolol was obtained in
good selectivities at 90% conversions (60–66%). However, attempts
to complete the conversion resulted in a drastic drop in ␣-bisabolol
selectivity (36% at 97% conversion; run 5, Table 1). Although, far-
nesol was detected in the reaction solutions in significant amounts
at early reaction stages (up to 30% of the converted nerolidol), final
reaction mixtures contained no even traces of farnesol. Thus, a vari-
ety of reversible transformations occur with nerolidol in acetone
high selectivity becomes really challenging.
Trying to inhibit the formation of dehydration products, i.e.,
bisabolenes, we performed the reaction in the presence of extra
water (Table 1, runs 6 and 7). However, the addition of only 1 eq. of
water significantly decelerated the reaction. Moreover, the 7-fold
molar excess of extra water completely suppressed the reactivity
of nerolidol. A further attempt to improve the selectivity for ␣-
reaction at 15 ◦C was not only much slower (expectedly) but also
much less selective toward the desired ␣-bisabolol (Table 1, run
8). The HPW recovered after the reaction by precipitation with
In summary, using the HPW catalyst, nerolidol can be converted
to ␣-bisabolol in 55–60% GC yields under optimized conditions.
This value is among the best results reported for this reaction so
far [11,15]. Owing to low catalyst loading, which is an important
advantage of the method along with mild reaction conditions, high
turnover numbers (TONs) can be achieved in the substrate conver-
sion (up to 450 per mol of HPW). It is very important that final
reaction mixtures contain virtually no farnesol (by GC analysis).
The problem is that farnesol, differently from ␣-bisabolol, has an
allergenic potential; therefore, its presence in cosmetic products
is highly undesirable from a dermatological standpoint [37]. The
purification of ␣-bisabolol by distillation is difficult because ␣-
bisabolol and one of the isomers of farnesol (cis, cis) have almost
thetic ␣-bisabolol for practical applications is usually performed
sequent distillative separation of farnesol esters from ␣-bisabolol
[37–39]. It should be mentioned that ␣-bisabolol synthesized in our
work is most probably racemic.
2. Experimental
All chemicals were purchased from commercial sources and
used as received, unless otherwise stated. Nerolidol (3,7,11-
trimethyl-1,6,10-dodecatrien-3-ol, mixture of isomers) and far-
nesol (3,7,11-trimethyl-2,6,10-dodecatrien-1-ol, mixture of iso-
mers) as well as H3PW12O40 hydrate were acquired from Aldrich.
The reactions were carried out in a 10 mL glass reactor equipped
with a magnetic stirrer and a condenser. In a typical run, the solu-
tion (5.0 mL) of the substrate (0.38–1.50 mmol, 0.075–0.3 M), HPW
(5–20 mg, 1.65–6.67 mol) and dodecane (0.5 mmol, 0.1 M, GC
internal standard) in the indicated solvent was intensively stirred
under air at a specified temperature (15–50 ◦C). The reaction rate
was not dependent on the intensity of stirring within the range
used. The reactions were followed by gas chromatography (GC)
using a Shimadzu 17 instrument fitted with a Carbowax 20 M cap-
illary column and a flame ionization detector. After an appropriate
reaction time, aliquots were taken and analyzed by GC. Conver-
sion and selectivity were determined by GC based on substrate
converted. The GC mass balance was based on the charged sub-
strate using dodecane as an internal standard. Some experiments
were run for several times to confirm reproducibility. Turnover fre-
quencies (TOF) were measured by GC at low conversions (up to
20–40%) by taking aliquots at short reaction times. The products
were identified by mass spectroscopy using a Shimadzu QP2010-
PLUS instrument operating at 70 eV by comparison with authentic
compounds.
3. Results and discussion
Farnesol was also used as the starting material for the synthe-
sis of ␣-bisabolol in our work (Table 2). ␣-Bisabolol was obtained
in 60–70% GC yields, the highest values reported for the syn-
thesis ␣-bisabolol from either nerolidol or farnesol as far as we
know. It is noteworthy that in the very beginning of the reaction,
most of farnesol rapidly isomerized to nerolidol, which was further
slowly consumed to give ␣-bisabolol along with small amounts
of bisabolenes. For example, in run 1 in Table 2, a 83% conver-
sion of farnesol occurred for 1 h, from which 67% was converted to
nerolidol, 25% to ␣-bisabolol and only 8% to bisabolenes. Then, the
relative amounts of ␣-bisabolol gradually increased at the expense
of nerolidol so that after 9 h a 72% selectivity for ␣-bisabolol was
obtained. It is important that the combined GC yield of ␣-bisabolol
and nerolidol was as high as 91%, with only small amounts of bis-
tions containing HPW are presented in Table 1. The reaction gave
␣-bisabolol with up to 66% selectivity along with small amounts of
farnesol, which usually disappeared by the end of the nerolidol con-
version (Scheme 1). The rest of the substrate was converted mainly
in bisabolenes, which formally are the products of the dehydration
oligomerization, as often happens with terpenic compounds under
acidic conditions.
The transformation of nerolidol in the presence of ca. 0.2 mol% of
HPW occurred smoothly at 40 ◦C resulting in a nearly complete con-
version for 4 h (Table 1, run 1). However, a mixture of bisabolenes