146
JENSEN ET AL.
2. Hassager C, Christiansen C 1989 Influence of soft tissue body
composition on bone mass and metabolism. Bone 10:415–
419.
3. Harris SS, Dawson Hughes B 1996 Weight, body composition,
and bone density in postmenopausal women. Calcif Tissue Int
59:428–432.
4. Haarbo J, Godtfredsen A, Hassager C, Christiansen C 1991
Validation of body composition by dual energy X-ray absorp-
tiometry (DEXA). Clin Physiol 11:331–341.
5. Hansen M, Hassager C, Overgaard K, Marslew U, Riis B,
Christiansen C 1990 Dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry: A
precise method of measuring bone mineral density in the
lumbar spine. J Nucl Med 31:1156–1162.
6. Charles P, Richard W, Mitchell B, Sartoris D 1990 Accuracy
of dual-energy radiographic absorptiometry of the lumbar
spine: Cadaver study. Radiology 176:171–173.
7. Hangartner TN, Johnston CC 1990 Influence of fat on bone
measurements with dual-energy absorptiometry. Bone Miner
9:71–81.
months. It is not surprising that any effect that initiates a
change in bone needs this time for the full effect to show,
and the bone changes measured initially may be reflections
of the increased number of reabsorption lacunae caused by
bone remodeling. An extrapolation of this would be that the
weight at 6 months would predict the bone status at 12
months, and thus any regained weight would result in re-
gained bone at that time. We have no measurements at 12
months to support this, but a previous study of TBBM
included 9-month measurements, and we found that weight
regain resulted in a corresponding regain of TBBM.(8) The
delay between weight loss and its corresponding bone loss
is a strong argument against the explanation that the ob-
served bone changes should be systematical measurement
errors, caused by alterations in the soft tissues.
The most convincing effect of the calcium substitution
was in the lumbar spine. The loss of TBBM on the other
hand, was significant also in the treatment group, but the
tendency to a lesser bone loss, when extra calcium was
given, was the same in all regions measured, and some
factors may have tended to underestimate the between
group differences. Primarily, the result of the randomization
was known to the participants. This may have accomplished
self-treatment in the placebo group, which would level out
some of the difference, and uncontrolled confounders such
as tobacco smoking and exercise could increase variation
and make differences harder to show. The estimated SE on
the TBBM being 75 g demands the difference between
groups to be at least 147 g in order to be statistically
significant. A larger study or a more substantial weight loss
may more clearly show a difference in all regions. Overes-
timation of the TBBM and of the BMC in the lumbar spine
in the treatment group, because unabsorbed calcium in the
gut occasionally may overlay bone pixels, cannot explain
the preservation of bone in the treatment group. Only 1 g of
calcium was given daily, and in our opinion only a small
fraction of this is likely to be mistaken as bone, because
only calcium in bone pixels is measured as such. This line
of argument is supported by the fact that the preservation of
bone also lasts through the final 3 months, when no calcium
was given.
8. Jensen LB, Quaade F, Sørensen OH 1994 Bone loss accom-
panying voluntary weight loss in obese humans. J Bone Miner
Res 9:459–463.
9. Mazess R, Barden H, Bisek J, Hanson J 1990 Dual-energy
x-ray absorptiometry for total-body and regional bone-mineral
and soft-tissue composition. Am J Clin Nutr 51:1106–1112.
10. Slosman DO, Casez J-P, Pichard C, Rochat T, Fery F, Rizzoli
R, Bonjour J-P, Morabi A, Donath A 1992 Assesment of
whole-body composition with dual-energy x-ray absorptiom-
etry. Radiology 185:593–598.
11. Compston J, Laskey M, Croucher P, Coxon A, Kreitzman S
1992 Effect of diet-induced weight loss on total body bone
mass. Clin Sci 82:429–432.
12. Ricci TA, Chowdhury HA, Heymsfield SB, Stahl T, Pierson
RN Jr, Shapses SA 1998 Calcium supplementation suppresses
bone turnover during weight reduction in postmenopausal
women. J Bone Miner Res 13:1045–1050.
13. Andersen T, McNair P, Hyldstrup L, Fogh-Andersen N,
Nielsen T, Astrup A, Transbøl I 1988 Secondary hyperpara-
thyroidism of morbid obesity regresses during weight reduc-
tion. Metabolism 37:425–428.
14. Atkinson R, Dahms W, Bray G, Schwartz A 1978 Parathyroid
hormone levels in obesity. Miner Electrolyte Metab 1:315–
320.
15. Buckley LM, Leib ES, Cartularo RN, Vacek PM, Cooper SM
1996 Calcium and vitamin D3 supplementation prevents bone
loss in the spine secondary to low-dose corticosteroids in
patients with rheumatoid arthritis. Ann Intern Med 125:961–
968.
It has been suggested that bone loss in weight losers is an
unwanted effect of very low calorie diets, and that it can be
avoided by using regimes with a higher energy content.(28)
Our regime was more liberal with a prescribed energy
intake up to 4.2 MJ and moderate weight losses, and we still
found significant losses in TBBM and lumbar BMC in the
absence of calcium substitution. We conclude that a bone
loss is an inevitable result of weight loss and that it is not
avoided by a higher calorie regimen as long as weight is
lost. It can be diminished by additional dietary calcium. In
dieting subjects, the usual recommended calcium intake is
insufficient and a calcium supplement is advisable.
16. Hey H, Petersen H, Andersen T, Quaade F 1987 Formula diet
plus free additional food choice up to 1000 Kcal (4.2 MJ)
compared with an isoenergetic conventional diet in the treat-
ment of obesity. A randomised clinical trial. Clin Nutr 6:195–
199.
17. Spector E, LeBlanc A, Shackelford L 1995 Hologic QDR 2000
whole-body scans: A comparison of three combinations of
scan modes and analysis software. Osteoporos Int 5:440–445.
18. Laskey MA, Flaxman M, Barber RW, Trafford S, Hayball MP,
Lyttle KD, Crisp AJ, Compston JE 1991 Comparative perfor-
mance in vitro and in vivo of Lunar DPX and Hologic QDR-
1000 dual energy X-ray absorptiometers. Br J Radiol 64:1023–
1029.
19. Kollerup G, Thamsborg G, Bhatia H, Sørensen OH 1992
Quantitation of urinary hydroxypyridinium cross-links from
collagen by high-performance liquid chromatography. Scand
J Clin Lab Invest 52:657–662.
20. Frost HM 1987 Bone “mass” and the “mechanostat”: A pro-
posal. Anat Rec 219:1–9.
REFERENCES
1. Lindsay R 1980 Prevention of spinal osteoporosis in oopho- 21. Frost HM, Ferretti JL, Jee WS 1998 Perspectives: Some roles
rectomised women. Lancet 2:1151–1154. of mechanical usage, muscle strength, and the mechanostat in