1
20
W. Zhang et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 489 (2015) 117–122
double-bond in olefins and the contact between catalyst and sub-
strate. On one hand, the conversions depend on the position and
steric configuration of the double bond, as a result of steric effects
during the epoxidation. On the other hand, the conversions are
decreased by increasing the chain length or the cross-section of
the olefin (1-hexene > cyclohexene). Furthermore, as the length of
linear olefin increases, the mobility of alkene decreases, and there-
fore, the accessibility of active site will be difficult for 1-octane and
1
-dodecene.
The excellent heterogeneous catalysts should not only have high
catalytic activity and selectivity, but should also be structurally sta-
ble and thus be easily recovered for continuous usage. Compound
azo-CMP-1 can be simply recycled by filtration, which was sub-
sequently reused in successive runs. The recycled azo-CMP-1 still
exhibited a very high conversion of 97% and selectivity of >99%
when cyclohexene being used as substrate, thus indicating that
azo-CMP-1 was indeed a heterogeneous catalyst for cyclohexene
epoxidation. The average turnover frequency (TOF) in the first 12 h
was also listed in Table 1.
Fig. 5. TG/DTG curves for sample azo-CMP-1 (left) and azo-CMP-2 (right).
With the aim at excluding any possible contamination by homo-
geneous metal active sites responsible for observed catalyst activity
and selectivity, a hot filtration test in azo-CMP-1 have been per-
formed shown in Fig. 7. Accordingly, the oxidation was allowed
to proceed for 90 min before being split into two fractions, one
containing the suspended catalyst and the other being filtered to
remove any solid precipitate. The former solution was kept to react
with additional azo-CMP-1 catalyst. For the latter one, the cata-
lyst was separated and discarded form the reaction mixture. Then,
the supernatant was analyzed by GC test. Finally, the conversion of
first fraction did well with the result of solution containing cata-
lyst all through. And, the catalytic performance of latter oxidation
increased slightly. Altogether, this hot filtration test confirmed a
truly heterogeneous process.
Fig. 6. Plot of conversion versus time with different substrates and catalysts.
Some benchmarking of azo-CMP-1 has been carried out by com-
parison with well known and readily available catalysts. Table 2
contains the epoxidation of trans-stilbene studies in the previous
literature. Based on the performance of azo-CMP-1 and homoge-
nous catalysts toward the trans-stilbene epoxidation, azo-CMP-1
outperformed the 2D layered in epoxidation via its structural resis-
tance to formation of catalytically inactive species.
their nucleophilicity toward electrophilic oxygen of catalytic
intermediate-porphyrin-Mn(V) O [30].
The catalytic activity of cyclohexene showed a higher conver-
sion than cyclooctene. The steric hindrance should be attributed to
this result. The size of cyclohexene was smaller than cyclooctene.
Consequently, it was hard for cyclooctene to be accessible to
active sites. Moreover, we also viewed recent published works
about epoxidation of cyclohexene and cyclooctene by metal met-
alloporphyrinic framework catalyst, the results showed that the
conversion of cyclohexene was higher than that of cyclooctene
3.3. Catalytic behavior study
Although the successive catalytic runs (Table 1, entry 2) and
comparison with ever reported catalysts (Table 2) have evidenced
that CMP strategy could prevent the self-dimerization of porphyrin
centers by bimolecular interaction to form the M-O-O-M unit
[35,4], porphyrinic networks constructed via Yamamoto homo-
coupling reaction usually exhibit strong hydrophobicity with a
[
10,32]. Although the cyclohexene was usually considered
in the bibliography as more difficult to oxidized than cyclooctene,
the rigorous dimension of channel size within catalyst has become
the main factor that affects the conversion of substrate with simi-
lar structure. This observation highlighted that azo-CMP-1 offered
channels with accessible catalytic sites for the substrates, which
greatly facilitated their diffusion.
◦
water contact angle about 135 [36]. This property greatly increases
the diffusion resistance by restricting exposing catalytically active
sites to those reactants with hydrophilic properties. However, if
there was no hydrophobic properties, the by-product of TBHP-
tertiary butanol in epoxidation would coordinate with Mn sites.
Therefore, a moderate hydrophobic property should facilitate the
catalytic application. Interestingly, N N bond endowed the
porphyrinic polymers (azo-CMP-1 and azo-CMP-2) with a rare
amphipathic property (Fig. 8). Thus, we supposed that azo-CMPs
catalysts could provide a desirable micro-environment for selec-
tive oxidation, facilitating the spread of reactants and accordingly
enhancing the overall catalytic performance.
Although the graphene-like morphology of azo-CMP-1 could
interpret its superior catalytic activity to azo-CMP-2, the nature of
Mn sites in azo-CMPs has not been revealed. To identify this point,
XPS analysis can help to reveal the oxidant state of Mn sites of
molecules in azo-CMPs. As shown in Fig. 9, one may notice that the
To further confirm aforementioned claim, we compared the cat-
alytic activities of azo-CMP-1 with their molecular components of
MnCl and Mn-TNPP shown in Table 1. MnCl showed a lower cat-
2
2
alytic activity with conversions of 57%. In comparison, Mn-TNPP
did show quite moderate catalytic activity that could transform
8
6% of the cyclohexene into the cyclohexene oxide, but still were
not as efficient as heterogeneous azo-CMP-1 (100% conversion). In
order to understand the steric effect on catalytic efficiency, a range
of natural alkenes were selected to be oxidized in this catalytic
system, including linear alkenes, styrene and trans-stilbene. Over-
all, increasing the steric size of alkenes triggered lower catalytic
activity.
From the catalytic results, it was obvious that the conver-
sion of cyclic olefin was higher than the linear olefin. With this
regard, we began to address this from two points: the position of