Angewandte Chemie International Edition
10.1002/anie.201711429
COMMUNICATION
cancer types.[7b, 8] In addition, two allosteric inhibitors of p97,
This is in contrast to the published compound NMS-873 which
we confirmed is highly selective for p97 (Supporting Fig. 2).
MSC1094308 inhibition was reversible, as expected due to
[
9]
NMS-873 and UPCDC30245, have recently been reported
9]
(
Supporting Fig. 1).[5b,
Although both compounds are
structurally different, they target the same allosteric pocket in D2. absence of bioreactive groups in the compound and confirmed
For most other AAA ATPases, chemical inhibitors or structural
information on allosteric circuits are however not yet available.
with an initial treatment at 20 µM followed by a dilution series
that progressively relieved the inhibitory effect (Supporting Fig.
3).
Here, we report
a
chemical compound class that
allosterically inhibits both the type I ATPase VPS4 and the type
II ATPase p97, thereby demonstrating conserved allosteric
circuits in both types of AAA ATPases.
Enzyme kinetic studies for the AAA ATPases p97 and
VPS4B revealed that MSC1094308 did not affect the K or
M
cooperativity; however, Vmax was progressively reduced with
increasing inhibitor concentrations, indicating a non-competitive
inhibitory mechanism for both ATPases (Fig. 1D and Supporting
Table 1). This was corroborated by binding studies with
fluorescent ATP to p97, which was not affected by the presence
or absence of MSC1094308 (Supporting Fig. 4). Together with
our findings that MSC1094308 inhibition is reversible, these
experiments thus strongly suggest an allosteric inhibition of both
AAA ATPases.
We next performed structure-activity relationship (SAR)
studies, aiming to identify the impact of the different structural
units of MSC1094308.
A set of focused analogues was
synthesized and tested for p97 inhibition. The influence of the
bisfluorophenyl moiety was evaluated with derivatives 2 – 4 (Fig.
2
A and Table 1). While removal of the fluoride residues in 2 led
to an only three-fold decrease in activity (IC50 of 22.6 ± 5.6 µM),
further displacement of one (3) or both phenyl residues (4)
abolished their inhibitory potential. In contrast, modifications at
the tetrahydrocarbazole system were better tolerated (Fig. 2B
and Table 1). Removal of the fluoride residue (5) again had an
only weak effect (IC50 of 14.1 ± 3.8 µM). Deconstruction of the
ring system led to tetralin derivative 6 or cyclohexane derivative
7
that inhibited with IC50s of 25.2 ± 4.6 µM and 46.1 ± 6.1 µM,
respectively. Incorporation of a benzyl residue (8) instead of the
tetrahydrocarbazole moiety also resulted in derivatives with
remaining, nevertheless weak inhibitory potential (IC50 of 62.3 ±
7.2 µM). For VPS4B, a different picture was however obtained.
Here, the structural reductions leading to derivatives 2 – 8 had a
much lower impact on inhibition (Table 1). Indeed, all
Figure 2. Overview on synthesized chemical compounds for structure-activity-
relationship (SAR) studies. A) Chemical structures of fluoro-bisphenyl
analogues. B) Chemical structures of derivatives for probing the inhibitory
impact of the tetrahydrocarbazole moiety. C) Chemical synthesis of
MSC1094308 analogues. a) i) BnO(CH
2
)
3
PPh
, Pd/C, EtOH, rt, o/n, 46%; b) i) MsCl (2 eq.), NEt
h, ii) 1,4-dioxaspiro[4.5]decane-8-carboxamide (2 eq.), MeCN, 80 °C, rt,
2%; c) Ar-NHNH (2 eq.), TFA/DCM (1:3), 2 h, rt, 13-83%.
3
Br (1 eq.), KOtBu (1.1 eq.), THF,
‘tetrahydrocarbazole’ derivatives 5 – 8 were almost equipotent to
7
3
8
0 °C, 6 h, ii) H
2
3
(2.5 eq.), rt,
the parent inhibitor MSC1094308. Removal of residues on the
bisphenyl system were also much better tolerated, although
derivatives 3 and 4 no longer displayed a similar, classical
sigmoidal inhibition curve as observed for MSC1094308, thus
indicating that these compounds may exhibit an alternative
inhibition mode. Altogether, our SAR therefore indicates that the
fluorobisphenyl moiety is most important for effective inhibition
and that allosteric inhibitors for targeting both the type I ATPase
VPS4B and the type II ATPase p97 should feature the whole
bisfluorophenyl tetrahydrocarbazole scaffold. We therefore next
determined the impact of different substitutions at the
tetrahydrocarbzole moiety on p97 and VPS4B inhibition and
found that most substitutions were well tolerated (Fig. 2C and
Table 1). Intriguingly, we however also noticed a correlation
between p97 and VPS4B inhibition, i.e. more potent p97
inhibitors are also more potent VPS4B inhibitors and vice versa;
indeed, most tetrahydrocarbazole VPS4B inhibitors are about
2
Our studies started from the identification of MSC1094308 (1) in
a biochemical NADH-coupled high throughput screen for p97
ATPase inhibitors (Fig. 1B). We validated the inhibitory effect vs.
p97 by a malachite green assay and observed a sigmoidal dose-
activity relationship and an IC50 of 7.2 ± 1.1 µM, comparable to
the published activity of the frequently used p97 inhibitor DBeQ
8a]
(
Fig. 1C and Table 1).[
To deduce the specificity of
MSC1094308, we tested its inhibitory potential vs. two other
AAA ATPases (Fig. 1C and Table 1). For the type II AAA
ATPase NSF, we observed dose-dependent inhibition only at
higher concentrations, which prevented reliable determination of
an IC50. For the type I AAA ATPase VPS4B, ATPase activity was
determined in presence of an activating fragment of its substrate
CHMP1B.[10] MSC1094308 inhibited VPS4B about ten times
more potently than p97 with an IC50 of 0.71 ± 0.10 µM.
10-fold more potent than against p97, thereby indicating that the
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.