Angewandte
Communications
Chemie
classical strong metal-support interaction (SMSI) induced by
high temperature reduction could alter the HDO selectivity,
but is unlikely in our case since none of the catalysts went
through the high temperature reduction necessary to induce
the SMSI. We hypothesized that the TiO2 film consisting
mainly of small pores (Pd@TiO2-WI) discouraged “flat-lying”
adsorption of the reactant molecules, while favoring
“upright” adsorption. To support this hypothesis, we inves-
tigated the hydrogenation of two probe molecules, styrene
and 1-hexene, over the catalysts. The planar structure of
styrene is expected to occupy a larger collection of contiguous
Pd atoms at the catalyst surface, with a similar “footprint” to
flat-lying benzyl alcohol and furfuryl alcohol, while the non-
aromatic 1-hexene would occupy fewer sites on the surface
due to the absence of an aromatic substituent.
Figure 5. Mass spectra from a pulse of benzyl alcohol over Pd/TiO2
that was precovered by D2: a) ions for toluene, b) ions for benzene;
conditions: temperature: 1908C, pressure: 1 atm; mole fraction of the
pulse: YD2 =20%, Ybenzyl alcohol =0.03%; gas flow rates: 140 mLminÀ1
.
The relative rates of the hydrogenation probe reactions
are plotted in Figure 4. Pd@TiO2-WI exhibited a much lower
activity for hydrogenation of styrene, while the other
encapsulated and supported Pd materials showed comparable
activity for this reaction. In contrast, all the Pd catalysts
showed similar activities for hydrogenation of 1-hexene.
These results suggest a significant restriction for styrene
adsorption and hydrogenation on Pd@TiO2-WI, supporting
the hypothesis that suppression of the flat-lying adsorption of
the reactant molecules contributes to the high HDO selec-
tivity in the case of Pd@TiO2-WI, as depicted in Figure 1b.
To further verify how reactants bind to the surface and the
resultant product from different binding orientations, we
performed isotopic studies using D2 instead of H2 for HDO of
benzyl alcohol. Figure 5b shows that H/D exchange occurred
for all six aromatic H atoms of benzene, which verified
benzene formation was likely through a “flat-lying” adsorbate
configuration, which enables facile exchange of aromatic H
with surface D. To the contrary, aromatic H/D exchange was
not observed for toluene (Figure 5a), suggesting its formation
occurred through a more “upright” adsorption, which only
enabled the H/D exchange on the methyl group. No aromatic
H/D exchange was observed for Pd@TiO2-WI, with toluene
being the only product (Figure S10), evidencing the restric-
tion of “flat-lying” adsorption on Pd@TiO2-WI. We also
conducted the isotopic study for hydrogenation of styrene
(Figure S11), which showed that the H/D exchange occurred
for all aromatic H atoms, suggesting its adsorption pattern is
also “flat-lying”. The similar restriction for both benzene and
ethylbenzene formation from benzyl alcohol and styrene,
respectively, strongly suggests that the Pd@TiO2-WI
restrained “flat-lying” adsorption of aromatic reactants
thereby improving HDO selectivity. We propose two possible
mechanisms for the apparent restriction of flat-lying adsorp-
tion. First, the confined pores of TiO2 films on Pd@TiO2-WI
may provide a more crowded surface to disrupt contiguous
arrays of active sites (“ensembles”) necessary for flat-lying
adsorption. It should be noted that the detailed connection
between bulk pore size and the structure of available sites
around the interface is not clear; the results reported here
suggest that the surface crowding on Pd@TiO2-WI may be
more severe than would be expected based on the average
(bulk) pore size. Alternatively, chemical interactions between
TiOx and Pd may contribute to the selectivity boost for
Pd@TiO2-WI, for example via more extensive electronic
perturbation of Pd sites within more highly confined pores.
To investigate the generality of this approach, the Pd
catalysts were used for HDO of furfural and m-cresol to
produce 2-methyl furan and toluene, respectively. For these
reactions, noble metals suffer poor reaction specificity despite
their high activity/stability; alloys and base metals have been
considered as substitutes.[36–38] As with the model reactants,
we observed high HDO selectivity using the Pd@TiO2-WI
(Figure 6). Figure S12 shows that the improved selectivity was
due to faster HDO rates and suppression of decarbonylation
and ring hydrogenation. It may be interesting to use a similar
encapsulation approach to enhance properties of more
inherently selective alloy and base metal catalysts.
Figure 4. Relative TOF of hydrogenation of olefins with different sizes
(styrene and 1-hexene) versus catalytic conversion of benzyl alcohol.
Reaction conditions are shown in Experimental Procedures in the
Supporting Information. The relative TOF for Pd/TiO2 was normalized
to 1 for both reactions using scaling factors. The same scaling factors
were used for all other Pd catalysts to ensure quantitative comparison
among them.
In conclusion, we showed that the HDO selectivity of
aromatic alcohols/aldehydes and phenolics can be signifi-
cantly enhanced by encapsulating Pd NPs with porous TiO2,
while maintaining high catalytic activity. While all the
4
ꢀ 2017 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2017, 56, 1 – 6
These are not the final page numbers!