Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 165 (14) D731-D742 (2018)
D731
Direct Electrochemical Preparation of Nanostructured Silicon
Carbide and Its Nitridation Behavior
1
,2,z
1,2
1
3
D. Sri Maha Vishnu,
Jagadeesh Sure,
Hyun-Kyung Kim, Ji-Young Kim,
1
1,2,∗
R. Vasant Kumar, and Carsten Schwandt
1
Department of Materials Science and Metallurgy, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB3 0FS, United Kingdom
Department of Materials Science and Metallurgy, University of Nizwa, 616 Nizwa, Sultanate of Oman
Advanced Analysis Center, Korea Institute of Science and Technology, Seoul 02792, Korea
2
3
Silicon carbide was synthesized from mixtures of SiO2 and graphite by applying the concept of the FFC-Cambridge process and
several fundamental aspects of the synthesis route were investigated. Porous disks composed of powders of SiO2 and graphite in
molar ratios of 1:0.5, 1:1 and 1:1.5 were prepared by sintering in inert atmosphere and subjected to electro-deoxidation in molten
CaCl2 at 1173 K under a range of experimental conditions. Disks of molar ratio 1:1.5, reduced at an applied voltage of 2.8 V for
a duration of 6 h, yielded exclusively phase-pure SiC of nanowire morphology as the reaction product, while the other precursor
compositions provided significant amounts of calcium silicides. Voltages lower than 2.8 V gave mixtures of SiC with elemental
Si and graphite, and voltages higher than that gave CaSi alone. Shorter electro-deoxidation times led to incomplete reduction and
allowed for the identification of CaSiO3 as a transient phase. Based on the experimental results a multipath reaction mechanism is
proposed, consisting of the electrochemical reduction of SiO2 and CaSiO3 to Si and the subsequent in-situ carbonization of the Si
formed to SiC. The effect of N2 at high temperature on the electrochemically synthesized SiC was investigated and the formation of
nanowire Si2N2O was observed. Overall, the process presented is a facile single-step and low-temperature method for the synthesis
of SiC with possible commercial prospects.
©
Manuscript submitted August 20, 2018; revised manuscript received October 15, 2018. Published October 30, 2018.
Silicon carbide is an important non-oxide ceramic material because
of its desirable properties, such as high melting point, high hardness
the electrolyte. Many metal oxides and mixtures of metal oxides have
been electro-deoxidized in this way to form their parent metals and
alloys. The scope and the versatility of the FFC-Cambridge process
concerning the oxide precursors used and the metal products made
1
and strength, and excellent wear resistance and chemical inertness.
3
SiC has a relatively low density, of 3.21 g/cm , compared with other
1
9–11
refractory metal carbides, and it is a wide-bandgap semiconductor.
have been reviewed extensively.
Due to this superior blend of thermal, mechanical, chemical and elec-
trical properties, SiC finds diverse applications, as heating elements,
as components in automobile brakes and clutches, as ceramic plates
in bulletproof vests, as an abrasive, and in electronic devices. SiC is
also used as an additive in a variety of composite materials. A more
recent research focus has been on nanostructured SiC because of its
attractive applications in electrical and energy devices and as a support
The FFC-Cambridge process can be modified for the synthesis of
metal carbides, by employing a precursor material as the cathode that
comprises a mixture of metal oxide and carbon of suitable ratio. Under
such conditions, the metal released from its oxide under the influence
of the cathodic potential reacts in-situ with the carbon present in the
cathode to form the respective metal carbide. Various carbides have
12,13
14,13
15,13
16
been made like this, including TiC,
ZrC,
TaC, WC, and SiC.20 For the latter, the elec-
trolytic cell can be represented as follows.
HfC,
3 2
Cr C ,
2
17
18,13
13
19
material for catalysts.
Cr
7
C
3
,
NbC,
SiC is commercially synthesized by carbothermic reduction of
2
SiO at very high temperature. The commonly used method is the
Acheson process in which silica sand is reacted with petroleum coke
(
+) C |CaCl
2
| SiO
2
, C (−)
[1]
1
,3
at above 2773 K in a graphite electric resistance furnace. The
method is laborious and energy intensive and yields a bulky mate-
The metal carbides made by electro-deoxidation were typically in
the form of powders and consisted of particles in the nanometer range.
Zou et al. reported the preparation of SiC from SiO
molten CaCl using an yttria-stabilized zirconia solid oxide membrane
as the anode thereby avoiding a carbon anode. The same group also
reported the formation of SiC nanowires from SiO /C via a combined
1
rial with relatively low surface area and many impurities. SiC can
also be prepared by various alternative routes. Some of these are gas-
phase reactions at high temperature, for instance, the decomposition of
2
/C precursors in
2
organosilicon compounds such as methyltrichlorosilane (CH
3
SiCl
in the pres-
, and the reduction-carburization from Si powder and
3
)
21
4
2 4 4
in the presence of H , the reaction of SiCl and CCl
5
2
ence of H
CCl with Na as a reductant. Further methods are mechanical alloy-
2
22
solid-state reduction and dissolution-deposition mechanism and the
further processing of these wires into mesoporous structures for use
6
4
1
ing, liquid phase sintering, arc melting, and sol-gel precipitation.
However, all these methods have drawbacks in that they require
high energy input, multiple process steps and/or the presence of a
substrate.
23
in supercapacitors.
Despite the earlier reports there are still many uncertainties that
prevent the straightforward implementation of the FFC-Cambridge
process for the synthesis of SiC at a large scale and with controled mor-
phology. One aspect concerns the optimum precursor composition.
This is because it has been found in general that the carbon content of
the oxide/carbon precursor has to be higher than the quantity required
There is a growing demand for processes that allow the synthesis
of metal carbides, particularly SiC, at temperatures lower than those of
7
8
the conventional production method. The FFC-Cambridge process is
a promising approach in this regard. In this, a metal oxide or semimetal
oxide serves as the cathode in an electrolytic cell that furthermore
14,15,17,18
stoichiometrically due to loss of carbon during processing,
20
21
although Zhao et al. and Zou et al. have reported that SiC could
be made from SiO /C of molar ratio 1:1. Another issue concerns the
2
contains a molten salt electrolyte of typically CaCl and an anode
2
of typically carbon. The cell is then polarized such that the potential
of the cathode is negative enough to cause expulsion of oxides ions
into the electrolyte, but positive enough to preclude electrolysis of
electrochemical process parameters. This is because the main and the
side reactions are sensitive to the cathodic potential applied.
2
The intended cathodic reaction is the electro-deoxidation of SiO to
Si followed by the immediate in-situ reaction of the Si with the carbon
in the cathode to yield SiC. The reactions read as follows, with the
standard electrode potentials calculated from thermodynamic data,
∗
z
24