J. W. Johannes et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 25 (2015) 5743–5747
5745
a robust PARP enzyme for expression and crystallization.10,11 The
Table 2
Difluoro substitution on the benzylic linker improves rat CL
crystal structure of AZ9482 bound to TNKS1 is presented in
Figure 2. Similar to other PARP inhibitors,12,13 the phthalazinone
core mimics nicotinamide and binds in the same pocket as the
nicotinamide portion of the PARP enzyme cofactor NAD+. The
carbonyl and NH of the phthalazinone form hydrogen bonds with
the backbone of Gly1185. The cyano-pyridine moiety serves as
an adenine mimetic and binds between the two aromatic residues
His1201 and Phe1188. The nitrogen of the nitrile forms a hydrogen
bond with the backbone NH of Asp1198. Linking these two parts
together is a phenyl amide that interacts with the backbone NH
of Tyr1213 via the amide carbonyl.
O
NH
N
O
N
L
N
N
N
Compd*
L
Declustering Rat heps
Rat CL (mL/ Caco2 AB Papp
EC50 M)
(
l
(l
L/min 106) min kg)
(10ꢀ6 cm/s)
Intrigued by this compound’s ability to induce a multi-polar
spindle phenotype and inhibit the growth of cancer cells at low
nanomolar concentrations, we were eager to test the consequences
of this mechanism of action in vivo in a suitable xenograft model.
However, as outlined in Table 1, compound 1 has poor aqueous sol-
1
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
CH2
O
NH
S
CF2
CHCH3
CHOH
CHF
CHNH2
<0.018
9.18
9.33
0.311
0.573
0.027
0.115
0.140
0.057
134
39
31
208
109
109
43
192
39
83
21
13
12
97
25
122
86
5y
ubility (11 lM) and DMPK properties. When subjected to human
microsomal (hu mics) or rat hepatocycte (rat heps) incubations
(see Supporting Information Table S1), compound 1 is rapidly
metabolized resulting in very high intrinsic clearances (CLint). This
high intrinsic hepatic clearance is also reflected in vivo, where the
rat clearance (CL) following IV bolus was measured at 83 mL/
min kg. Moreover, the low solubility likely resulted in poor fraction
absorbed and high plasma clearance led to low bioavailability
(12%) following oral dosing in rat. With this data in hand, we
focused our medicinal chemistry efforts on improving the proper-
ties of our analogs with an ultimate goal to increase water solubil-
ity. Our designs also concentrated on mitigating the in vivo
clearance liability of the series while maintaining potency in the
centrosome declustering assay.
The amide linkage in compound 1 served as a handle for rapid
generation of analogs, wherein a large number of diverse piperazi-
nes were incorporated. From this set, we uncovered compound 2a,
a compound featuring a fused triazolopiperazine moiety which
showed greatly improved physicochemical properties compared
to initial hit 1 (Table 1). Compound 2a was 51 nM in the decluster-
30
0.2
*
Data for most cell potent, chirally pure enantiomer where applicable.
39% mass recovery.
y
intrinsic clearance of <2.2 l
L/min 106 cells. In spite of this, the
in vivo PK of compound 3a still showed poor clearance in rat
(CL = 97 mL/min kg).
Other metabolites produced in vivo in rat from 2a included
hydroxylation of the benzylic methylene linker between the
phthalazinone core and the phenyl ring. Following this observa-
tion, we designed and synthesized a series of compounds featuring
alterations and substituents at the benzylic methylene linker
(Table 2, position L in the structure). We chose to make these
alterations to 1, since many of the substituents would create a
stereogenic center at position L and the 3-cyano-2-piperazinyl-
pyridine moiety was commercially available, simplifying the
synthesis and chiral purification of these compounds. Changing
the CH2 linker to O or NH caused a large reduction in declustering
potency. Nevertheless, compounds 4 and 5 had improved rat heps,
and for compound 4, this manifested itself in a greatly improved
rat in vivo clearance of 21 mL/min kg, an almost 4-fold improve-
ment over 1. Encouraged by this, we prepared additional analogs
such as sulfur linked compound 6, which retained some decluster-
ing cell potency but showed no improvement rat hepatocytes or
in vivo clearance. Interestingly, CF2 linked compound 7 had greatly
improved in vivo clearance and still retained some declustering
cell potency.14 We also explored compounds that kept the carbon
linker while introducing a substituent such as CH3, OH, F, and
NH2 (compounds 8–11). In these cases, only one enantiomer was
appreciably active in the declustering cell assay. Of this set, only
compound 11 retained cell potency while showing an improve-
ment in both in vitro and in vivo PK. Examining 7 versus 11 with
the goal of optimizing this series to an orally bioavailable com-
pound, we chose to progress with compound 7, since it retained
permeability while compound 11 had very low permeability in a
Caco2 permeability assay.15,16
ing assay and also had an aqueous solubility of 984 lM. More
importantly, 2a had greatly reduced lipophilicity (calculated
reduction in ClogP) and correspondingly low CLint in rat heps.
Unexpectedly, this compound did not show a corresponding
improvement in rat CL in vivo; its measured rat clearance was very
high at 159 (mL/min kg). Interestingly, close analog 2b, which has
swapped nitrogen for carbon to create a fused imidazopiperazine,
was not potent in our declustering assay. We surmised that this
nitrogen in compound 2a serves as a hydrogen bond acceptor for
the backbone NH of Asp1198, taking the place of the nitrile moiety
in 1.
Having identified compound 2a, which featured improved
CLint and solubility, we sought to fix the poor in vivo clearance
of this series. Guided by the observation of oxidative metabolism
of 2a at the methylene groups alpha to the amide nitrogen
in vivo, we explored methyl group substitution at these positions
(Table 1). Methyl substitution at the pseudo-benzylic methylene
between the piperazine nitrogen and the triazole was not toler-
ated; compounds 3c and 3d lost cell potency significantly. Sur-
prisingly, addition of a methyl group at the opposite methylene
alpha to the amide nitrogen was tolerated, provided the com-
pound had (S) stereochemistry. (S)-methyl compound 3a had
improved declustering potency comparable to 1, while (R)-methyl
Combining the difluoro linker with the (S)-methyl fused
triazolopiperazine adenine mimetic led to compound 14a (Table 3)
which had improved cell potency (216 nM) relative to compound 7.
More importantly, this compound had a clearance of 33 mL/min kg
with an oral bioavailability of 43%, demonstrating that the
beneficial effects of the CF2 linker on PK carried over to the more
potent fused triazolopiperazine sub-series. Compound 14a also
had favorable solubility, and its overall potency, property and PK
profile served as the basis for the final phase of optimization.
compound 3b had an EC50 of >11 lM in the declustering assay.
Moreover, compound 3a was in a much better physicochemical
property space and DMPK space. Compound 3a had a measured
aqueous solubility of >1000
ubility of only 11 M. Most importantly, (S)-methyl compound 3a
was more stable in rat hepatocytes compared to 2a, with an
lM compared to 1, which had a sol-
l