Angewandte
Communications
Chemie
To further investigate the acetyl elimination by AbyA5,
a modelling study was performed. Molecular docking was
conducted using the AbyA5 crystal structure with both (R)-3
and (S)-3. This yielded a series of closely related models of the
AbyA5–substrate complex, each of which positions the
substrate directly within the AbyA5 active site cleft and
locates the acetyl group in close proximity to Ser198 and
His312 (Figure 3). The side chain of 3 occupies a largely
hydrophobic portion on the right of the active site cleft. Given
the minimal number of contacts between AbyA5 and the
substrate in this region, it appears unlikely that chain length
and composition is a major determinant of substrate selec-
tivity. This is consistent with our in vitro assay data, which
demonstrate that the substrate analogue (R)-9, which lacks
the side chain functional group decoration of 3, is readily
acted upon by the enzyme. In contrast, appropriate position-
ing of the acetylated tetronate ring within the active site
appears to play a significant role in substrate binding. This is
achieved by a combination of shape and charge complemen-
tarity between the acetylated ring and the active site cavity,
supported by several hydrogen bonds. The point mutants
AbyA5_H321A and Ser198A showed no activity with (R)-9,
despite both proteins being well-folded monodisperse species
in solution (Supporting Information, Figure S5), implying
a critical role for these residues in substrate positioning and/or
catalysis within the active site. Molecular dynamics simula-
tions using docked poses of (R)-3 reveal a distance of
approximately 3.5 ꢀ between His312 and C15 of the sub-
strate, optimal for proton abstraction and consistent with the
His-dependent catalytic mechanism proposed previously for
QmnD4 (Supporting Information, Figure S6).[4a] The distance
between His312 and C15 for (S)-3 docked poses is greater
than 4.5 ꢀ, sufficient to preclude proton abstraction and
thereby negate catalysis (Figure 3). Together, these data offer
an explanation for the stereoselectivity of AbyA5 observed in
our in vitro enzyme assays.
The crystal structure of AbyA5 raises the intriguing
possibility that this protein scaffold could support both
acetate elimination and hydrolysis, though no (R)-9 hydro-
lytic product 8 was detected in our functional assays. To test
this hypothesis, the ability of AbyA5 to deacetylate p-
nitrophenolacetate (p-NPA) in vitro was monitored spectro-
photometrically.[13] AbyA5 was found to catalyze the hydro-
lytic deacetylation of p-NPA, with kcat = 44 Æ 2.4 minÀ1, Km =
78 Æ 9.2 mm, and kcat/Km = 0.62 Æ 0.31 minÀ1 mm (Supporting
Information, Figure S7). Molecular dynamics simulations of
AbyA5, in the absence of substrate, reveal the appropriate
positioning of the His-Ser-Asp triad, as defined by the
occupation of hydrogen bonds between these side chains,
for approximately 10% of the simulation duration, consistent
with the ability of the enzyme to catalyze ester bond cleavage
via a canonical acetyl esterase mechanism (Supporting
Information, Figure S8).[14] The infrequent adoption of this
catalytically competent state accounts for the comparatively
poor catalytic efficiency of AbyA5 for p-NPA as compared to
naturally evolved acetyl esterases, with an up to 60-fold lower
kcat/Km (Supporting Information, Table S2). Neither
AbyA5_H321A nor Ser198A showed any activity with p-
NPA. Docking studies confirmed that p-NPA can be readily
accommodated within the AbyA5 active site.
In summary, we report the structural and functional
characterization of the acetate lyase AbyA5, revealing the
molecular details of the acetate-elimination reaction cata-
lyzed by this enzyme, and in doing so, establish explicitly the
role of this enzyme in abyssomicin C biosynthesis. AbyA5 is
shown to possess an acetyl-esterase-like fold, within which
conserved catalytic machinery can be deployed to facilitate
either acetate elimination or ester hydrolysis, in a manner
dictated by substrate identity. Our studies establish the origins
of substrate selectivity in AbyA5, revealing absolute stereo-
selectivity for the (R)-tetronate, but relaxed selectivity for the
C3 chain. These findings hint at the potential general utility of
AbyA5 as an acetate-elimination biocatalyst. Although
evolutionarily selected to catalyze elimination, AbyA5 exhib-
its kinetic parameters for ester hydrolysis comparable to
naturally evolved acetyl esterases. Catalytic multifunctional-
ity is an inherent feature of many biocatalysts; however,
AbyA5 is unusual in its proficiency in performing a secondary
non-cognate reaction.[15] These studies also further expand the
breadth of transformations catalyzed by a/b-hydrolase fold
enzymes, highlighting the utility of this protein scaffold in
supporting a diverse array of biocatalytic reactions. Finally,
given the high degree of sequence identity between AbyA5
and acetate-eliminating enzymes from other spirotetronate/
spirotetramate pathways, we conclude that many of the key
findings reported herein will be directly applicable to acetate
lyases from other biosynthetic pathways.
Acknowledgements
This study was supported by BBSRC and EPSRC through the
BrisSynBio Synthetic Biology Research Centre (BB/
L01386X/1), PhD studentships awarded to N.R.L. (EPSRC,
EP/G036764/1 and GSK), M.J.B. (BBSRC, BB/D526037/1),
J.A.D. (EPSRC, EP/L015366/1), P.E.J.M. (BBSRC, BB/
J014516/1), and a BBSRC David Phillips Fellowship to
M.W.v.d.K (BB/M026280/1).
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Keywords: antibiotics · biocatalysis · enzyme structure ·
enzymology · polyketides
d) A. V. Zamaraev, G. S. Kopeina, E. A. Prokhorova, B. Zhivo-
4
ꢀ 2019 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2019, 58, 1 – 6
These are not the final page numbers!