&'()*( +, -,. )+/0*. 1)234-*
Journal of Materials Chemistry C
Page 2 of 8
DOI: 10.1039/C9TC03515J
A:;6<=>
?#).&!" @!2%
8(2:,21)-6( 4- *,'4+ *.).(C@OI[HbB A-+ 1).(24)'* Z4.A .43A.
1,'(60')2 8)6\4-3 6,0'+ :)=,02 .A( U$ (14**4,- 4- *,'4+P *4-6(
.A( .43A. 8)6\4-3 6)- 2(*.2)4- .A( 1,'(60')2 1(6A)-46)'
1,=(1(-. )-+ 14.43).( .A( 0-+(*42)>'( (-(239 ',** .A2,03A
-,-[2)+4).4=( 2(')K).4,- 6A)--('* 08,- ) 1(6A)-46)' :,26(C
^(6)0*( ,: .A( 4-.41).( 2(').4,-*A48 >(.Z((- .A( 1,'(60')2
8)6\4-3 )-+ ('(6.2,-46 *.206.02(P U$ 8(2:,21)-6( 6,0'+ >(
*43-4:46)-.'9 )::(6.(+ >9 .A( *0>*.4.0(-. 32,08*P ZA46A 6,0'+
1,+0').( .A( 1,'(60')2 ('(6.2,-46 *.206.02(C@O][HgB !A0*P .A2((
!&A +(24=).4=(* Z(2( ,>.)4-(+ >9 4-.2,+064-3 .Z, A)',3(-
).,1* ;RP #'P ^2< ., .A( -,-[U$ ;CA'< D ;R43C F<C ()''9P 08,-
.A( '4-\)3( ,: A)',3(- ).,1*P .A( ('(6.2,-46 *.206.02( ,: ;CA'
< D Z)* 6A)-3(+P 2(*0'.4-3 4- .A( .43A. 8)6\4-3 ,: .A(
A)',3(-[*0>*.4.0.(+ !&A +(24=).4=(* ;;CA'< D'A7P ;CA'< D'
A<" )-+ ;CA'< D'AE.< )66,18)-4(+ Z4.A .A( )88()2)-6( ,:
U$ (14**4,-*C !A)-\* ., .A(42 *418'( *.206.02(*P 4. 4*
6,-=(-4(-. ., (K8',2( .A( *.206.02([8)6\4-3[8(2:,21)-6(
2(').4,-*A48C V(2(4-P Z( Z,0'+ '4\( ., 82(*(-. .A(42 *9-.A(*(*P
*.206.02)' 6A)2)6.(24_).4,-P 8A,.,8A9*46)' 82,8(2.4(*P .A( U$
82,8(2.4(*P 629*.)' *.206.02(*P .A(,2(.46)' 6)'60').4,-* >)*(+ ,-
.A(42 *4-3'( 629*.)'*P )-+ 2(').(+ +4*60**4,-* ,- .A( *.206.02([
8)6\4-3[8(2:,21)-6( 2(').4,-*A48C
;CA'< D'A7 )-+ ;CA'< D'A<" 8,**(** 106A (-A)-6(+
4-.(21,'(60')2 4-.(2)6.4,-* ;R43C 7I<C !A(*( !&A +(24=).4=(* A)+
(K6(''(-. *,'0>4'4.9 4- 6,11,- ,23)-46 *,'=(-.*P *06A )*
.(.2)A9+2,:02)- ;!VR<P +46A',2,1(.A)-( ;D#U< )-+
6A',2,:,21C hf[f4* )>*,28.4,- *8(6.2) ,: ;CA'< DP ;CA'< D'
A7P ;CA'< D'A<" )-+ ;CA'< D'AE. Z(2( 1()*02(+ 4- !VR
*,'0.4,- ;R43C O)<C A'' ,: .A(1 8,**(**(+ .A( .Z, )>*,28.4,-
8()\* ;6(-.2(+ ). O]e )-+ Hdb -1 :,2 ;CA'< DP O]e )-+ Hbb
-1 :,2 ;CA'< D'A7P HGd )-+ HdH -1 :,2 ;CA'< D'A<"P HG]
)-+ HdH -1 :,2 ;CA'< D'AE.<P .A( >)-+* 4- .A( *A,2.(2
Z)=('(-3.A 2(34,- Z(2( )**,64).(+ Z4.A .A( iliY .2)-*4.4,-
)-+ .A( >)-+* 4- .A( ',-3(2 Z)=('(-3.A 2(34,-* Z(2(
)..24>0.(+ ., .A( 4-.2)1,'(60')2 6A)23( .2)-*:(2 ;"#!<C "-
6,18)24*,- Z4.A .A,*( ,: ;CA'< DP ;CA'< D'A<" )-+ ;CA'
< D'AE.P ;CA'< D'7 (KA4>4.(+
)
*'43A.'9 >'0([*A4:.(+
)>*,28.4,- >)-+* ;)>,0. FG -1<P 8,**4>'9 +0( ., .A( +4::(2(-.
('(6.2,- Z4.A+2)Z4-3 82,8(2.4(* ,: A)',3(- ).,1*C !A( 14-,2
+4::(2(-6(* 4- .A(42 )>*,28.4,- *8(6.2) 4-+46).(+ .A( +4::(2(-.
('(6.2,-46 *.206.02(* 6)0*(+ >9 .A( 4-.2,+06.4,- ,: A)',3(-
).,1*C !A( :'0,2(*6(-6( (14**4,- >(A)=4,2* ,: !&A +(24=).4=(*
4- *,'0.4,- Z(2( )'*, 4-=(*.43).(+ ;R43C O)<P Z4.A .A( 2(*0'.*
'4*.(+ 4- R43 FC ;CA'< D )-+ ;CA'< D'A7 (KA4>4.(+ *414')2
(14**4,- 8()\* ). )>,0. beG -1 4- !VR *,'0.4,-C R,2 ;CA'< D'
A<" )-+ ;CA'< D'AE.P 14-,2 >'0([*A4:.(+ (14**4,- >)-+* Z(2(
,>*(2=(+ ;bdI )-+ bde -1P 2(*8(6.4=('9<C A'' ,: .A(1 *A,Z(+
>'0( (14**4,-* 4- !VR *,'0.4,-P 8)2.4)''9 )..24>0.(+ ., .A(
.Z4*.(+ 6,-:,21).4,-C !A( 2(*0'.* +(1,-*.2).(+ .A). .A(
14-,2 +4::(2(-6( ,: .A(42 ('(6.2,-46 *.206.02( 6,0'+ -,.
*0>*.)-.4)''9 )::(6. .A(42 (14**4,-* 4- !VR *,'0.4,-C U,2(,=(2P
.A( &$ '4:(.41( ;S< )-+ )>*,'0.( :'0,2(*6(-6( M0)-.01 94('+*
;TR< 4- !VR *,'0.4,- ;6,-6(-.2).4,-n FG mU< Z(2( )'*,
2(6,2+(+ ;R4302( O> )-+ !)>'( F<C ;CA'< DP ;CA'< D'A7 )-+
;CA'< D'A<" (KA4>4.(+ A43A(2 )>*,'0.( :'0,2(*6(-6( M0)-.01
94('+* ,: O]CGgP HFCOI )-+ OICb] aP )-+ ',-3(2 '4:(.41(* ,:
OC]eP HCGg )-+ OCdG -*P 2(*8(6.4=('9 ;R43C O><P ZA4'( ;CA'< D'
AE. 82(*(-.(+ ',Z(2 )>*,'0.( :'0,2(*6(-6( M0)-.01 94('+ ,:
]CeO a )-+ *A,2.(2 '4:(.41( ,: FCOb -*C !A(42 8A,.,* 0-+(2 .A(
4''014-).4,- ,: ) Hgd -1 hf ')18 6'()2'9 *A,Z(+ .A(42
+4::(2(-. :'0,2(*6(-6( 4-.(-*4.9 0-+(2 .A( *)1( 6,-+4.4,-*C
S( 6,0'+ ()*4'9 :4-+ .A). !&A[#VE[O^2 82(*(-.(+ Z()\(2
:'0,2(*6(-6( '014-(*6(-. 4-.(-*4.9 4- 6,18)24*,- Z4.A .A(
,.A(2 !&A +(24=).4=(*P Z('' 6,22(*8,-+4-3 ., .A(42 +4::(2(-.
)>*,'0.( :'0,2(*6(-6( M0)-.01 94('+* 4- !VR *,'0.4,-C
A++4.4,-)''9P 2)+4).4=( ;U2< )-+ -,-[2)+4).4=( 2).(* ;U-2< 4- !VR
Z(2( 6)'60').(+ )-+ 82(*(-.(+ 4- !)>'( FP 6,-:4214-3 .A(
:'0,2(*6(-6( 82,8(2.4(* ,: .A(*( !&A +(24=).4=(*C A'' ,: .A(1
8,**(** *414')2 2)+4).4=( 2).(* ;GCI]oFG] 7[F :,2 ;CA'< DP
FCGOoFG] 7[F :,2 ;CA'< D'A7P FCF]oFG] 7[F :,2 ;CA'< D'A<"P
GCeoFG] 7[F :,2 ;CA'< D'AE.<P ZA46A *A,0'+ >( 1)4-'9
)..24>0.(+ ., .A( 2(').4=('9 A43A :'0,2(*6(-6( (::464(-69 4-
+4'0.( !VR *,'0.4,-C V,Z(=(2P .A( -,-2)+4).4=( +(6)9 2).( ,:
!&A[#VE[O^2 4* eCHgoFG] 7[FP 106A A43A(2 .A)- .A). ,: ,.A(2
!&A +(24=).4=(* ;OCdFoFG] 7[F :,2 ;CA'< DP OCOdoFG] 7[F :,2
:%()"+( !&- -,(5)((,#&
!A(*( .A2(( 1,'(60'(* Z)* +(*43-(+ )-+ *9-.A(*4_(+
)66,2+4-3 ., .A( 2,0.( +(846.(+ 4- 76A(1( 7FC A'' ,: .A(1
Z(2( 82(8)2(+ >9 h''1)-- 2()6.4,- )-+ *0>*(M0(-. f4'*1(4(2[
V))6\ 2()6.4,-C 74'46) 3(' 6A2,1).,32)8A9 Z)* 0*(+ ., 8024:9
.A( .)23(. 1,'(60'(*P )-+ .A(42 6A(146)' *.206.02(* Z(2(
6,-:421(+ >9 FV )-+ FH# `U *8(6.2) ;R43C 7F[7]<C D7# ,: .A,*(
!&A[>)*(+ 1,'(60'(* Z(2( )'*, 6,-+06.(+P ;CA'< D'A7 )-+
;CA'< D'A<" *A,Z(+ ,>=4,0* (K,.A(2146 8()\*P 4-+46).4-3
K!"
HI;I+4 )B4&'J3+&2 4J-C3')
:/A;<=>LM&*83+&2
)<
><
/0 4J-C3')
:/A;<=>;?ALM&*83+&2
:/A;<=>;?<*LM&*83+&2
:/A;<=>;?@'LM&*83+&2
:/A;<=>
K!
:/A;<=>;?A
:/A;<=>;?<*
:/A;<=>;?@'
K!?
K!K
K!!
!!
"!!
D)E-*-2F3G 62(9
<'543)*
#!!
$!!
!
K!
?!
!
"!
#!
:+(- 6249
:/A;<=>;?A C'543)*
:/A;<=>;?A F'+2.+2F *+FG3*5
:/A;<=>;?A F'+2.+2F G-)E+*5
K7!
!7O
!7$
!7"
!7?
!7!
6<
)4;J'-J)'-.
P'&82. G-)E+*5
Q0
+<
#
K#
?#
? R.-F
#
"#
N!
"N!
#N!
$N!
D)E-*-2F3G 62(9
7,$8 A )< hfl=4* )>*,28.4,- ;2(+ '4-(< )-+ &$ ;>'0( '4-(< *8(6.2)
,: !&A[#VEP !&A[#VE[ORP !&A[#VE[O#' )-+ !&A[#VE[O^2
;#,-6(-.2).4,-? FG mU< 4- !VRC >< %14**4,- +(6)9 ,: !&A[#VEP
!&A[#VE[ORP !&A[#VE[O#' )-+ !&A[#VE[O^2 ;#,-6(-.2).4,-?
FG mU< 4- !VRC 6< &$ *8(6.2) ,: !&A[#VE[OR >(:,2( )-+ ):.(2
324-+4-3 4- *,'4+ *.).( )-+ U$ *8(6.2) ,: !&A[#VE[ORC +< .A(
T D 8)..(2-* ,: !&A[#VE[ORC
;CA'< D'A7P OC]O
FG] 7[F :,2 ;CA'< D'A<"<C !A4* 4-+46).(+
.A). .A( (-(239 ',** .A2,03A -,-2)+4.4=( +(6)9 82,6(**(* 4*
!)>'( F E8.46)' 82,8(2.4(* ,: ;CA'< D )-+ ;CA'< D'AF ;Tn RP #'P ^2<
A j Q! R 5&CP OGFOP BBP F[H
!A4* /,02-)' 4* k !A( ,9)' 7,64(.9 ,: #A(14*.29 OGKK
&'()*( +, -,. )+/0*. 1)234-*