MELATONIN IN FOOD-RESTRICTED AGING
B25
demonstrated nocturnal hypoglycamia in FR animals fed at
the end of the light phase, and low glucose availability to
the brain has been proposed as a cause of decline in melato-
nin secretion observed in a study (43) of fasting humans. An
automated feeding machine may enable nocturnal feeding
of the FR animals without exposing them to light.
In conclusion, the present study overcame the problem of
change in peak acrophase in animals of different ages and
diet regimens by measuring the total nocturnal excretion of
6-S-OH-MLT as an indicator of melatonin secretion. The
study also attempted to control for the complicating influ-
ence of disease. The similarity found between diet groups in
age change in 6-S-OH-MLT excretion through adulthood
may indicate that the age-retarding effects of the FR regi-
men are not modulated or reflected by youthful total noctur-
nal melatonin secretion, although higher tissue concentra-
tions of melatonin in the FR groups are suggested by the
marked group differences in the weight-indexed metabolite
excretion. Because many factors complicate the relationship
of weight-indexed metabolite to serum levels of melatonin,
direct sampling of serum melatonin is necessary to establish
the influence of FR on melatonin availability to tissues. The
difficulties of making the required regular sampling of
blood from small nocturnal mammals may preclude the use
of a rat model in such studies.
Various explanations may be given for the current find-
ings. Although a difference in 6-S-OH-MLT excretion due
to diet regimen was not found, a slowing of pineal aging
may have occurred in the FR animals, as postulated in the
following scenario. Melatonin may be secreted more rapidly
by more responsive or more efficient pinealocytes in the rel-
atively youthful FR animal, with the tissue concentrations
reaching an unusually high peak due to enhanced pineal
function and reduced tissue mass. There are indications that
the FR regimen may maintain youthful upregulating ability
in pinealocytes (9,44), although a Wistar rat study suggests
that an age-related decline in ability to synthesize melatonin
is a more likely cause of reduced secretion with age (45). If
the serum melatonin in the aging FR animals is exception-
ally high it may reach a threshold not attained with normal
aging and at which a negative feedback influence, less ac-
tive in the younger animal, is induced. Feedback control is
found in all other endocrine systems (46), and an inhibitory
effect of melatonin appears to be demonstrated in a study
(47) showing that certain tissues, which do not usually se-
crete melatonin, produce measurable amounts of the hor-
mone following pinealectomy. Alternatively, possible noc-
turnal hypoglycemia in the FR group as discussed above
may, without preventing certain age-retarding and life-
extending influences of the regimen, compromise mainte-
nance of the youthful pineal function that would otherwise
occur.
Correlations between disease and reduced melatonin lev-
els (18–20) may indicate that impaired health status in some
of the current AL group masks a higher level of metabolite
excretion usual in AL animals. A higher absolute, but not
weight-indexed, secretion of melatonin in normal AL rats
compared with those undergoing food restriction was found
in a short-term study (48) in which 3 weeks of 50% food re-
striction in male rats resulted in a decrease in pineal content
of melatonin but an increase in melatonin serum levels. In
this study also, low glucose levels may have impaired pineal
function in the food-restricted group.
Monitoring of blood glucose in studies of FR and melato-
nin and investigation of the suppressive effects of melatonin
on the pineal and other tissues are indicated. Future studies
could also explore further the effects of the FR regimen and
other temperature-lowering environmental influences on pi-
nealocyte function, particularly with regard to adrenergic
stimuli and the responsiveness of target cells to melatonin, as
discussed in an earlier paper (9). Important mammalian dif-
ferences pertinent to such studies include the reported lack of
a blood–brain barrier surrounding the pineal gland in the rat,
but not the human (49), and the differing adrenergic receptors
responsible for regulating pineal melatonin secretion (32).
Also, in some species, there is evidence that the melatonin
concentrations in the third ventricle are substantially higher
than in the plasma, raising the possibility of two physiologi-
cally significant compartments of melatonin (50).
Acknowledgments
We thank CERA, Concord Hospital, for the use of the animals and facil-
ities; Alison Ryan for care of the animals; Dr. Francis Seow for technical
advice and support; and Dr. Malcolm France of the Veterinary Pathology
Department, University of Sydney, for advice on rat pathology.
Address correspondence to Dr. Mary F. MacGibbon, MacKillop Cam-
pus, Australian Catholic University, P.O. Box 968, North Sydney, NSW,
Australia, 2059. E-mail: m.macgibbon@mackillop.acu.edu.au
References
1. Yie S-M, Liu G-Y, Johansson E, Brown C, Brown G. Age-associated
changes and sex differences in urinary 6-sulphatoxymelatonin circa-
dian rhythm in the rat. Life Sci. 1992;50:1235–1242.
2. Pang SF, Tsang CW, Hong GX, Yip PCY, Tang PL, Brown GM. Fluc-
tuation of blood melatonin concentrations with age: result of changes
in pineal melatonin secretion, body growth and aging. J Pineal Res.
1990;8:179–192.
3. Sack RL, Lewy AJ, Erb DL, Vollmer WM, Singer CM. Human mela-
tonin production decreases with age. J Pineal Res. 1986;3:379–388.
4. Sharma M, Palacios-Bois J, Schwartz G, et al. Circadian rhythms of
melatonin and cortisol and aging. Biol Psychiatry. 1989;25:305–319.
5. Zhdanova IV, Wurtman RJ, Balcioglu A, Kartashov AI, Lynch HJ.
Endogenous melatonin levels and the fate of exogenous melatonin:
age effects. J Gerontol Biol Sci. 1998;53A:B293–B298.
6. Wetterburg L, Bergiannaki JD, Paparrigopoulos T, et al. Normative
melatonin secretion: a multinational study. Psychoneuroendocrinol-
ogy. 1999;24:209–226.
7. Zeitzer J, Daniels JE, Duffy JF, et al. Do plasma melatonin concentra-
tions decline with age? Am J Med. 1999;107:422–436.
8. Arendt J, Wirz-Justice J, Kornemark M. Long-term studies on im-
muno-reactive human melatonin. Ann Clin Biochem. 1979;16:307–
312.
9. MacGibbon MF. Ageing as upregulation failure. Med Hypoth. 1996;
46:523–527.
10. Van Den Heuvel CJ, Kennaway DJ, Dawson D. Thermoregulatory and
soporific effects of very low dose melatonin injection. Am J Physiol.
1999;276(2Pt1):E249–E254.
11. Reiter RJ, Tan D-X, Poeggeler B, Chen Li-d, Menendez-Palaez A.
Melatonin, free radicals and cancer initiation. Adv Pineal Res. 1994;7:
211–228.
12. Guerrero JM, Reiter RJ. A brief survey of pineal gland-immune sys-
tem relationships. Endocrine Res. 1992;18:91–113.
13. Keenan KP, Smith PF, Soper KA. Effect of dietary (caloric) restriction
on aging, survival, pathology and toxicology. In: Mohr U, Dungworth
DL, Capen CC, eds. Pathobiology of the Aging Rat. Internat. Life Sci.
Inst. 1994;2:609–628.
14. Yu BP, Masoro EJ, McMahan CA. Nutritional influences on aging of