Organic Letters
Letter
a
Scheme 1. Previous Reports
Table 1. Optimization of Reaction Conditions
b
entry
solvent (2 mL)
additive (1 equiv)
yield (%)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
DCE
EtOAc
DME
TFE
THF
CH3CN
toluene
MeOH
TFE
TFE
TFE
TFE
TFE
TFE
TFE
TFE
TFE
TFE
TFE
TFE
AcOH
AcOH
AcOH
AcOH
AcOH
AcOH
AcOH
AcOH
AcOH
AcOH
AcOH
none
AcOH
AcOH
AcOH
AcOH
ClCH2COOH
AdCOOH
PivOH
NaOAc
40
20
22
68
18
18
12
18
55
76
68
47
27
c
directing groups under redox neutral conditions for the
construction of carbocyclic rings.10 We reported the synthesis
of 1-naphthols using sulfoxonium ylide as a directing group
with 4-hydroxy-2-alkynoate as a coupling partner.11 In light of
the literature precedence10 and our work,11 we envisioned a
C−H activation of sulfoxonium ylide followed by the insertion
of olefin, which may lead to (4 + 1) annulation to form C3-
substituted indanone derivatives (Scheme 1c). Because
sulfoxonium ylide acts as a traceless directing group as well
as internal oxidant, the reaction does not need an external
metal oxidant, and the byproduct obtained is DMSO, which
can be easily separated. With this hypothesis, we carried out a
reaction of sulfoxonium ylide 1a (0.2 mmol) with ethyl
acrylate 2a (0.3 mmol) in the presence of [Cp*RhCl2]2 (5 mol
%), AgSbF6 (20 mol %), and AcOH (1 equiv) in DCE (2 mL)
at 80 °C for 16 h in an argon atmosphere. To our delight, we
observed the formation of indanone derivative 3aa in 40%
yield (Table 1, entry 1).
With this initial lead, we began the optimization of the
reaction conditions by solvent screening. TFE proved to be a
better solvent, furnishing the product 3aa in 68% yield (entries
2−8). Temperature screening studies (entries 9−11) revealed
that 100 °C (entry 10) is an optimal temperature for the
reaction to obtain the product 3aa in 76% yield. The yield of
the product decreased in the absence of additive AcOH and
activator AgSbF6 (entries 12 and 13). Among the activators
screened (entries 14 and 15), AgBF4 is better suited for the
reaction, furnishing the product 3aa in 83% yield(entry 15).
The reaction carried out in an air atmosphere resulted in
decreasing the yield of 3aa to 70% (entry 16). Screening of
other acid and base additives did not increase the yield of 3aa
(entries 17−20). Further attempts to improve the yield
resulted in the decomposition of the starting material 1a.
Further investigation for exploring the scope of the reaction
was carried out using the optimal conditions, as in entry 15.
Next, we examined the scope of the reaction with different
sulfoxonium ylide derivatives (Scheme 2). Unsubstituted aryl
sulfoxonium ylides and alkyl substitution at various positions
underwent a smooth reaction under optimal conditions,
furnishing the corresponding indanone derivatives 3aa−da in
77−84% yield. An electron-donating methoxy group at various
positions did not influence the reaction, and the reaction
provided the corresponding annulated products 3ea−ga in
68−92% yield. Sulfoxonium ylide with a weak electron-
withdrawing halogen substitution on the aryl ring afforded
the products 3ha−ia in 67−69% yield. However, the dihalide-
substituted aryl sulfoxonium ylide afforded the corresponding
annulated product 3ja in 30% yield. The substitution of strong
d
e
f
g
72
83 (80)
70
h
63
67
57
60
a
Reaction conditions: 1a (0.2 mmol) and ethyl acrylate 2a (0.3
mmol), [Cp*RhCl2]2 (5 mol %), AgSbF6, entries 1−12; AgBF4,
entries 15−20 (20 mol %), additive (1 equiv), in solvent (2 mL) at 80
b
°C for 16 h under an argon atmosphere. 1H NMR yield calculated
using trimethoxybenzene as an internal standard; yield in parentheses
c
d
is the isolated yield. Reaction at 60 °C. Reaction at 100 °C.
e
f
g
Reaction at 120 °C. Reaction in the absence of AgSbF6. AgNTf2
h
used as activator. Reaction in an air atmosphere.
electron-withdrawing groups such as nitro and cyano groups
on the para position of aryl sulfoxonium ylide also afforded low
yields of the products 3ka and 3la (39 and 34%, respectively).
The reaction condition was tolerant to furan and thiophene-
derived sulfoxonium ylides, furnishing products 3ma, 3na, and
3oa in 87, 40, and 54% yield, respectively.
Next, we extended the scope of the reaction with a variety of
acrylate, acrylamide, and styrene derivatives (Scheme 3).
Methyl and n-butyl acrylates reacted well with sulfoxonium
ylide 1a to furnish products 4aa and 4ab in 75 and 76% yield,
respectively. Trichloroethyl and ethoxyethyl acrylates under-
went a smooth reaction, resulting in the formation of products
4ac and 4ad in 58 and 72% yield. The reactions with phenyl,
naphthyl, and benzyl acrylates also proceeded well, providing
the products 4ae, 4af, and 4ag in 59, 55, and 69% yield,
respectively. N,N-Dimethyl- and piperidine-derived acryla-
mides are also compatible under reaction conditions, furnish-
ing the products 4ah and 4ai in 43 and 45% yield, respectively.
Unactivated olefins such as styrene derivatives were also
subjected to the optimal reaction conditions. The electron-
withdrawing acetoxy-group-substituted styrene derivative fur-
nished the corresponding product 4aj in 66% yield. The
electron-donating methyl group offered product 4ak in 29%
yield.
The synthetic utility of the reaction has been demonstrated
by performing a gram-scale reaction between 1a and 2a to
obtain 3aa in 80% yield (Scheme 4a). Furthermore, the base-
B
Org. Lett. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX