Communication
signments were further confirmed by scalar coupling that each
of the NH signals exhibits to these well-resolved doublets (Fig-
ure S33b). The spatial proximity between the signal at
3
.73 ppm and the singlets at 6.67 ppm and 7.23 ppm enabled
us to identify two sets of correlations in 2D ROESY spectra (Fig-
ure S34b) and thus these signals correspond to the a-CHs of
N-methyl pyrrole rings. Here it is worth mentioning that there
are two different magnetically distinct phenyl groups with the
observation of multiplets in the range 7.13–7.19 ppm for one
phenyl ring and a set of signals in the range 7.32–7.52 ppm for
the other phenyl group, as observed in the free base form as
well. The CH groups of meso-phenyl substituents have been
assigned based on 2D COSY spectra (Figure S33c), ROESY spec-
tra (Figure S34) and EXSY spectra (Figure S35). Further confir-
mation of the individual signals came from HSQC spectra (Fig-
ure S36). The observations of heterocyclic a-CHs and b-CHs
resonating in the region as those of isolated pyrrole/heterocy-
cle clearly indicate absence of any sizable macrocyclic ring cur-
rent, and hence the protonated 11 can be gauged as nonaro-
matic.
Figure 3. X-ray crystal structure of free base 11 (a,b) and protonated 12
(a’,b’). Top view (a,a’) and side view (b,b’).
[15]
tures of isolated N-methyl pyrrole and bond lengths are practi-
cally unperturbed; that is, CbÀCb> CaÀCb (1.438 vs 1.369 )
for 11. For macrocycle 12, failure to obtain a good single crys-
tal suitable for X-ray diffraction in free base form forced us to
resort to geometry optimization based on DFT calculations.
In our next attempt, we tried to investigate the impact of
a,b linkages of N-methyl pyrrole rings into the macrocyclic
core upon the aromaticity in macrocycle 12. Even though mac-
rocycle 12 exhibits well-resolved spectra at RT in free base
form itself, but only upon lowering the temperature to 243 K
[
12]
With the B3LYP/6-31G* basis set, a minimum energy struc-
ture turned out to be a figure-eight structure (Supporting In-
formation, Figure S51). On the other hand, single crystals suita-
ble for X-ray diffraction were obtained by slow diffusion of cy-
clohexane into TFA/dichloromethane solution of 12. Macrocy-
cle 12 upon protonation turned out to have a flat geometry
(
Supporting Information, Figure S41), the NH signal was gener-
ated along with b-CH of N-methyl pyrrole. The spectral obser-
vation (Figure S43) indicates absence of ring current and thus
non-aromaticity in the free base form of the macrocycle. The
diprotonated 12 however shows drastic change in NMR spec-
tral pattern. The diprotonated 12 was obtained by adding
+
(Figure 3a’). The interesting features were observed in 12·2H ,
7
0 mL of 10% CF COOH/CDCl owing to the fact that stepwise
where four TFA molecules were involved in the flat geometry
3
3
+
addition of 10% CF COOH/CDCl led to precipitation and,
of 12·2H . Each half of the macrocycle contains one neutral
3
3
hence an excess amount was added in one step to get a clear
pyrrole NH and one protonated pyrrole NH. The TFA molecule
which is protonating the pyrrole, the carbonyl oxygen of this
TFA is involved in strong H-bonding with carboxyl group of
other TFA. The carbonyl oxygen of this second TFA molecule is
in turn involved in H-bonding with the free pyrrole NH (Sup-
porting Information, Figure S48). The short distance for O···O
was estimated to be 2.47 . These features suggest that while
the highly distorted structures of 11 and 12 lead to nonaroma-
solution in the NMR tube. Upon lowering the temperature to
+
2
43 K, well-resolved spectra were obtained for 12·2H (Fig-
ure S44). The inner NH proton resonated as a singlet at
1
1
5.45 ppm, whereas the two doublets at 9.7 ppm and
0.7 ppm have been assigned to the inner b-CH protons of in-
verted pyrrole ring. Similarly the singlet at 10.3 ppm has been
assigned to the inner b-CH protons of N-confused N-methyl
pyrrole ring. The outer NH proton of inverted pyrrole ring res-
onated at 4.3 ppm, the outer a-CH proton of N-confused N-
methyl pyrrole ring resonated at 6.4 ppm and the outer b-CH
protons of non-inverted pyrrole ring resonated at 5.9 ppm and
+
ticity, planar 12·2H induced by protonation allows its antiaro-
matic character.
+
In contrast to 12·2H , the energy-minimized structure for
+
11·2H obtained was a substantially bent shape (Supporting
6
.4 ppm (Figure S46). All of these assignments were confirmed
Information, Figure S50). The b–b linkages of N-methyl pyrrole
1
1
by using a H– H correlation spectroscopy (COSY) experiment
Figure S45). These observations clearly indicate the presence
would provide the steric restriction on a planar structure,
+
(
which results in the bent shape of 11·2H and accounts for its
of moderate paratropic ring current and hence antiaromaticity
nonaromaticity.
+
in 12.2H . The observed spectral patterns for free base and
protonated forms of macrocycles 12 are well-supported by cal-
culated NMR spectra (Figures S59,S60).
Such nonaromaticity and weak antiaromaticity of free-base
and protonated 11 and 12 were well-described by nucleus-in-
dependent chemical shifts (NICS) and anisotropy of induced
current density (AICD) calculations in their optimized struc-
The solid-state X-ray crystallographic analysis and structure
optimization calculation revealed the involved structural
changes of macrocycles 11 and 12 by protonation. For macro-
cycle 11, its crystal structure was strongly puckered (Figure 3a).
Here, the protruding N-methyl pyrrole rings preserve all fea-
[
13]
tures. In both 11 and 12, the NICS values at the center of
the macrocycle were calculated to be d=0.46 and À2.87 ppm,
respectively (Supporting Information, Figure S53, S55), and the
AICD plot (Figure S57a, S58a) showed the localized ring current
Chem. Eur. J. 2016, 22, 5504 – 5508
5506
ꢀ 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim