Journal of the American Chemical Society
Article
or FIPC-1. Thus, the competition experiment in this case
serves to distinguish saturable targets of FIPC-1 from apparent
“enrichment” (false positives) arising from a cellular response
to the xenobiotic peroxide molecule itself.
TXNDC5, and PDIA3. Knockdown of individual PDIs in the
absence of ferroptosis inducer had no effect on proliferation of
HT-1080 cells. However, P4HB knockdown sensitized cells
dramatically to RSL3 and erastin, but interestingly not to
FINO2 or 3 (Figure 4E and Figure S11A). If labeling by FIPC-
1 or 3 promoted PDI dysfunction in the ER, this might be
expected to induce the unfolded protein response (UPR). To
explore this possibility, we treated HT-1080 cells with
compound 3 or a positive control inducer of the UPR,
thapsigargin, and looked for induction of the UPR effector
ATF4. Indeed, compound 3, like thapsigargin, led to ATF4
UPR induction by 3 is due solely or even primarily to
interaction with PDIs cannot be discerned from these initial
experiments but is nevertheless consistent with an underex-
plored connection8 between ferroptosis and the UPR.
Since several inhibitors of P4HB have been described in the
literature, we next evaluated the effects of three such
compounds in HT-1080 cells, alone and in combination with
known ferroptosis inducers. Previously reported as PDI
inhibitors, both PACMA3143 and 35G844 (a 3-methyltoxo-
flavin) were indeed cytotoxic to HT-1080 cells, while the
compound LOC1445 was much less so (Figure 4F). To
determine whether these compounds promote ferroptotic cell
death specifically, we performed coincubations with death
suppressing compounds as before. Notably, PACMA31 toxicity
was mitigated or reversed by DFO and ferrostatin-1 but not
other death suppressors, consistent with a mechanism of
mediated cell death could not be rescued by any of the death
suppressors, suggesting a different mechanism of action
(Figure S13A). In fact, redox cycling toxoflavins, of which
35G8 is an example, are known to catalyze the conversion of
oxygen to hydrogen peroxide46 and interfere in enzymatic
assays broadly, but especially perniciously in the case of
cysteine/GSH dependent enzymes such as PDIs. The reported
mechanism of PACMA31 action is more specific, namely,
covalent binding to the catalytic cysteine in PDIs. That this
compound, or PDI inhibition in general, can trigger ferroptosis
has not to our knowledge been previously recognized. Because
knockdown of P4HB alone failed to induce ferroptosis, the
contribution of additional PDIs or other off-targets in the
action of PACMA31 appears likely. In fact, PACMA31 was
reported47 to also inhibit PDI family members PDIA6 and
PDIA3, both of which were among the protein targets
identified with FIPC-1. While acknowledging the potential
for cross-reactivity of PACMA31 even outside the PDI family,
we note that widely used GPX4 inhibitors such as ML210 and
RSL3 also possess cysteine reactive warheads and other
structural similarities with PACMA31. Thus, the possibility
that these well-established tool compounds may have addi-
tional targets cannot be formally excluded.
Having identified several members of a FIPC-1 iron-
dependent interactome, we next considered their known
biological activities and possible roles in ferroptosis. AKR1B1
encodes an aldose reductase, a member of the family that
converts glucose to sorbital during hyperglycemia but is also
capable of reducing toxic aldehyde byproducts of lipid
peroxidation, namely 4-hydroxy-trans-2-nonenal (4-HNE)
and its glutathione adducts, to the corresponding alcohols.35,36
Similarly, the carbonyl reductase encoded by CBR1 counts
among known substrates 4-HNE as well as prostaglandins and
the quinones tocopherolquinone (vitamin E) and ubiquinone-
1 (coenzyme Q1).37,38 Thus, a protective role for AKR1B1 and
CBR1 in the later stages of ferroptosis can be readily
envisioned. Of note is that AKR1C1, a close family member
to AKR1B1, was found previously to be upregulated in erastin-
resistant cells.8 The mitochondria localized PRDX3 is a
peroxidase that catalyzes the reduction of hydrogen peroxide,
limiting availability of this species for Fenton reaction and
hydroxy radical generation.39 Finally, four members of the
protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) family were identified in the
FIPC-1 iron-dependent interactome. The PDIs are multifunc-
tional endoplasmic reticulum (ER) enzymes that mediate
disulfide formation and protein folding.40
We performed knockdown of individual target genes in HT-
1080 cells using siRNA pools targeting the specific genes.
Despite achieving over 95% knockdown of mRNA levels, we
observed only moderate impairment of cell growth with
We also evaluated the effects of AKR1B1 inhibitors developed
for other clinic indication but found that none could alone
trigger ferroptotic cell death in HT-1080 cells (Figure S9C).
Given that 4-HNE should be elevated during GPX4 inhibition,
we looked for synergy between GPX4 inhibition and AKR1B1
or CBR1 knockdown (Figure S10). We found that knockdown
of CBR1, AKR1B1, or PRDX3 did not additionally sensitize
HT-1080 cells to RSL3 or indeed to any of the canonical
ferroptosis inducers studied, including 3 (Figure S10).
Paradoxically, knockdown of CBR1 or AKR1B1 protected
HT-1080 cells from erastin toxicity, an observation that might
be explained by a compensatory antioxidant response to the
KD of these genes, a possibility that merits further study.
The most robustly (∼19-fold) competed protein in the
FIPC-1 screen was the protein NT5DC2. Annotated as a
mitochondrial localized member of the haloacid dehalogenase
(HAD) superfamily,41 the functional activity and physiological
relevance of this protein remain uncharacterized. Intriguingly
then, siRNA knockdown of NT5DC2 significantly sensitized
HT-1080 cells to both RSL3 and erastin (Figure 4D and
Figure S10). In what is apparently the only previous report on
this protein, NT5DC2 was proposed to associate with and
stabilize Fyn (a proto-oncogene protein tyrosine kinase) to
promote tumor progression in glioma stem-like cells.42
Because the HAD superfamily primarily comprises phospha-
tases, further study of NT5DC2 function, its interaction with
Fyn kinase, and its larger role in the ferroptosis pathway is
warranted.
To further explore the potential utility of PACMA31 as a
ferroptosis inducer, we next asked whether the compound
exhibited synergy with canonical ferroptosis inducers erastin
and RSL3. Indeed, we found that noncytotoxic concentrations
of PACMA31 and erastin, when combined, produced a
profound killing effect in HT-1080 cells (Figure 4G). By
comparison, the combined effect of PACMA31 and RSL3 was
only additive in nature (Figure S13D). An inhibitor of cystine
import, erastin rapidly depletes the cell of an essential cofactor
(GSH) required for PDI function.48 In this way, the dramatic
synergy of system Xc− and PDI inhibition revealed herein can
Next we evaluated the effect of siRNA knockdown of four
members of the protein disulfide isomerase family identified in
the FIPC-1 interactome screen, namely PDIA6, P4HB,
F
J. Am. Chem. Soc. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX