M.G. Ricardo et al.
Bioorganic Chemistry 113 (2021) 104987
conformations. Many more diamines with more or less rigidity, length,
and functionality (e.g., heterocyclic, polyether, fluorescent, etc.) are
commercially available and can be used to span the scope of this variant
of double Ugi multicomponent stapling.
the diamine/diisocyanide combination, always using the i → i + 7
linking strategy. We proved that both the type of bifunctional combi-
nation and the nature and flexibility of the linker influence the resulting
helicity, or the absence of any structured conformation. Although 20%
TFE had to be used as co-solvent in the CD spectra measurements – a
solvent known to favor the helical content – it was proven that the
double Ugi stapling is responsible for the stabilization of helical struc-
tures in several peptide-internal linker combinations, since the acyclic
peptides show a typical random coil pattern under the same conditions,
as do some tethered ones. Thus, the peptide diacid/diisocyanide com-
bination – in these examples – was unable to fix a helical conformation
in 10-mer peptides cross-linked at i, i + 7 residues, but the same com-
By considering Ugi-reactive functional groups naturally present in
amino acid side chains, we envisioned other additional variants of the
double Ugi macrocyclization approach that involve amino groups of
peptides. Hence, we devised the implementation of a variant that has
never been employed in multicomponent peptide stapling, that is, the
diamine/diisocyanide combination with a peptide diamine. Scheme 3
shows the implementation of this variant using a liner 10-mer peptide
featuring the same sequence of peptides 1 and 7 but with ornithine (Orn)
instead of Glu or Asp at positions 2 and 9. We realized that by using Orn
and not the proteinogenic Lys, we could access the same macrocyclic
ring sizes in the new stapled peptides 12, 13 and 14 than for those
peptides already shown in scheme 1, of course also using the same dii-
socyanides. Therefore, direct comparision is possible, to see if this new
diamine/diisocyanide combination would render a different result than
the inverse diacid/diisocyanide one, which did not provide helical
peptides for the 10-mer sequence. Cyclic peptides 12, 13, and 14 were
produced in reasonably good overall yield via a macrocyclization pro-
tocol previously optimized. This required the preformation of the dii-
mine by reaction of 11 with paraformaldehyde, followed by the slow
parallel addition of this diimine solution and the diisocyanide to a stir-
red solution of acetic acid.
bination did lead to very high
+ 11 residues. Unfortunately, a precise prediction, which components
will give an -helix, a 310-, polyproline- or other helix for varied peptide
α-helicity in a 14-mer peptide linked at i, i
α
sequences and i → i + n distances is yet impossible, but the ease and
variability of Ugi-stapling allows rapid experimental selection of the best
linker for a chosen purpose. While in this basic study very simple
monofunctional components were employed, i.e., methyl amine, acetic
acid, cyclohexyl and benzyl isocyanides, this multicomponent stapling
approach also has the capacity to incorporate more complex, function-
alized appendages for a variety of purposes, including fluorescent labels,
lipids, PEGs, and cationic or anionic groups, as shown by us before in
other contexts[11]. The only requirement is to have the primary amines,
carboxylic acids and isocyanides properly functionalized, for which
commercially available reactants provide numerous alternatives. In
principle, also different aldehydes or ketones can be use, but the
preferred use of paraformaldehyde is due to the poor stereoselectivity of
the Ugi reaction in non-symmetric oxo components. This is also the
reason for not using Ugi stapling combinations with dialdehyde linkers,
as they would lead to the formation of diastereomeric cyclic peptides of
difficult characterization and – depending on the purpose – perhaps poor
applicability. Nevertheless, the three easy combinations of bifunctional
components explored in this work already offer countless opportunities
for stabilizing helical peptides via variation of 2 of the 3 linker compo-
nents and the nature and positions of the amino acids to be tethered. We
are convinced that many biomedical applications can profit from the
exploitation of this powerful concomitant stapling/functionalization
technology.
In all the macrocyclization combinations included here, a key step is
the formation of the imine by condensation of the amine – either a Lys/
Orn side chain or an added component – with formaldehyde. Whereas
such imines should typically participate in the Ugi reactions, previous
reports describe the reaction of Arg and Tyr side chains with
formaldehyde-derived imines [36,37]. Since all peptide sequences used
in our examples incorporate Arg, it is expected the formation of by-
products derived from the reaction of the Arg guanidinium group and
the imine. Analysis of HPLC traces of crude products conveys that such
side reactions might take place (see the Supporting Information), but the
Ugi-stapled peptides are the major products of this procedure.
Comparison of the CD spectra of the unconstrained peptide 11 with
the three cyclic ones 12, 13, and 14 reveals that this variant of double
Ugi stapling can also lead to helical structures. As shown in scheme 3B,
there are differences in the CD spectra of the stapled peptides, indicating
that – in this case – the dissimilar linkers have influence on the resulting
conformations. Thus, while the macrocyclization with m-xylylene-dii-
socyanide led to unstructured peptide 12 (CD spectrum similar to the
acyclic precursor 11), the CD spectrum of peptide 14 suggests the sta-
bilization of a 310-helix after the stapling with the p-xylylene linker. In
contrast, the Ugi stapling with the 1,4-diisocyanobutane-having a
4. Experimental section
4.1. General
All starting materials were purchased from commercial sources and
used without further purification. 1H NMR and 13C NMR spectra were
recorded on a Varian Mercury 400 spectrometer at 399.94 MHz and
100.57 MHz, respectively. Chemical shifts (δ) are reported in ppm
relative to the TMS (1H NMR) and to the solvent signal (13C NMR). High
resolution mass spectra were obtained in an Orbitrap Elite mass spec-
trometer (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Germany) equipped with an ESI
electrospray ion source (positive spray voltage 4.5 kV, negative spray
voltage 3.5 kV, capillary temperature 275 ◦C, source heater temperature
250 ◦C, FTMS resolution 30000). A TripleToF 6600–1 mass spectrometer
(Sciex) was also used for high-resolution mass spectrometry, equipped
with an ESI-DuoSpray-Ion-Source and controlled by Analyst 1.7.1 TF
software (Sciex). The ESI source operation parameters were as follows:
ion spray voltage: 5,500 V, nebulizing gas: 60p.s.i., source temperature:
deeper minimum at 222 nm seems to favor some α-helicity in peptide
13, corroborating once more that small changes in both the shape and
flexibility of the linker – even using the same stapling combination –
determine the type of helicity or the absence of a structured confor-
mation. It is worth-noticing that not only the macrocycle ring size is
important in this type of double Ugi stapling (see that peptides 2, 3 and 4
have the same ring size than 14, 12 and 13, respectively), but the
presence of endo- or exo-cyclic amides and substituents is also relevant
as they can ultimately define the conformation of the Ugi-derived in-
ternal linker. This is especially evident for tertiary amides as they usu-
ally occur as a mixture of s-cis and s-trans rotamers, either of which can
impose dissimilar constraints and thus affect the secondary structure.
◦
450 C, drying gas: 70p.s.i., curtain gas: 35p.s.i. Data acquisition was
3. Conclusions
performed in the MS1-ToF mode, scanned from 100 to 1500 Da with an
accumulation time of 50 ms. Analytical RP-HPLC analysis was per-
formed on an Agilent 1100 system with a reverse-phase C18 column
We have provided novel insights into the effect of different combi-
nations of the double Ugi stapling on the secondary structure of the
resulting cyclic peptides. A generic 10-mer peptide sequence was chosen
to implement three different variants of this multicomponent macro-
cyclization. These are the diacid/diisocyanide, the diacid/diamine and
(4.6 × 150 mm, 5 μm) and a PDA detector. A linear gradient from 5% to
100% of solvent B in solvent A over 20 min at a flow rate of 0.8 mL
minꢀ 1 was used. Preparative RP-HPLC was performed on a Knauer 1001
system with UV detector K-2501. Separation was achieved using a C18
5