Halogen-Substituted Dibenzothiophene Oxides
SCHEME 4. Model To Explain Solvent Dependence
on Quantum Yields Based on Competition between
Reaction with Solvent and DBT
Another mechanistic extreme that cannot be elimi-
nated is the photodissociation to an ion pair, presumably
DBT•+/O•-, followed by back-electron transfer that leads
to DBT and ground-state O(3P). This back-electron-
transfer pathway would naturally compete with simple
recombination and thus could also result in a low
quantum yield. If the ion pair is born in a singlet state,
then heavy atom substitution on the DBT moiety might
facilitate the back-electron-transfer pathway and raise
the quantum yield of O(3P) formation.
The three bromo-substituted compounds were inves-
tigated to determine empirically whether a higher quan-
tum yield could be obtained by moving the substituent
or adding a second one. From the practical perspective
of trying to use these compounds in independent studies
of oxygen atom chemistry, the differences are not espe-
cially significant, though adding a second bromine does
enhance reactivity.
olefins.16,35 As a result, the observed quantum yields are
higher in cyclohexane than acetonitrile.
The strong luminescence and lack of deoxygenation
from 2g can be rationalized in at least two ways. First,
the data are consistent with a case in which intersystem
crossing to the luminescent triplet is very efficient and
in which the photoreactivity of that state is very low. The
blue-shifted emission spectrum of 2g, relative to the other
emissive sulfoxides, suggests that the triplet energy may
be on par with or just below the S-O bond energy, but
the carbonyl group may perturb the nature of the state
more than the halogens. The lack of structure in the
spectrum suggests it is not a typical localized nπ* state
of aromatic ketones such as benzophenone, but assign-
ment beyond that is speculative. There is not a high
correlation between phosphorescence yields and reactiv-
ity in another prototypical reaction of sulfoxides, photo-
induced stereomutation, but the phosphorescence yields
for compounds whose racemization have also been stud-
ied are all lower than for 2g.36-38 A second rationalization,
also consistent with all the data, is that the introduction
of the acetyl substituent and its attendant electronic
influences directly perturbs the coupling between ISC
and deoxygenation.
An alternative heavy atom strategy, to be reported
separately, is the use of selenoxides instead of sulfoxides
in a DBTO-like molecule. In this case, the perturbation
to the system is inherently greater because of changes
in bond strength, bond lengths, aromaticity of the re-
duced compound, etc. However, the central location of the
heavy atom at the key atomic position involved in the
S-O (or Se-O) cleavage may turn out to be a more
dramatically successful strategy, in terms of producing
a high quantum yield O-atom donor.
The initial attractiveness of the higher quantum yield
for iodinated sulfoxide 2a is quickly quashed by the
complications involved with the dehalogenation reaction.
The fact that only it and its corresponding sulfide 1a
undergo the photodehalogenation reaction suggests that
this is an orthodox homolysis reaction, which is usually
assigned to triplet-state chemistry. (See, for example, refs
33 and 34.) The bond energy for aryl iodides is of the
order of 64 kcal mol-1 33,34 That is just a few kcal mol-1
.
higher than the energy of the spectroscopic triplet of 2a,
probably within reach at room temperature, given the
moderate quantum yield. The triplet energies of the DBT
derivatives is about 70 kcal mol-1 17
which is above the
,
energy required for C-I homolysis and presumably
contributes to the higher quantum yield for deiodination
of 1a.
On the other hand, arene-Br bond energies are near
70 kcal mol-1 33,34
With triplet energies of the order of 60
.
kcal mol-1, it is not surprising that 2b, 2d, and 2e do
not debrominate competitively with deoxygenation. On
the other hand, exhaustive photolysis might have led to
dehalogenation of the corresponding sulfides, given their
higher triplet energies.
The solvent dependence on the quantum yield observed
for 2b is consistent with our previous observations for
DBTO,16 though with values all somewhat larger than
for the parent. We interpret the solvent dependence in
terms of a model suggested in Scheme 4.
On scission, O(3P) is formed in the immediate vicinity
of DBT. As a result, the reactive intermediate may
immediately react with the sulfide to reoxidize it, diffuse
away from the sulfide before reacting with anything, or
react with solvent before escaping from the cage. To the
extent that one solvent reacts with O(3P) faster than
another one, the observed quantum yield will be higher.
Acetonitrile is not a particularly active substrate for
reactions with O(3P).35 More reactive molecules include
halide ions, and those with oxidizable sulfur atoms or
Conclusions
Halo-substituted dibenzothiophenes show a modest
improvement in the quantum yield for deoxygenation,
relative to the parent DBTO. The trend order of iodo >
bromo > chloro ∼ H allows assignment of this to a heavy
atom effect. This is consistent with a proposed mecha-
nism of unimolecular S-O scission in which bond stretch-
ing is coupled to intersystem crossing, presumably into
the T0 substate. From a quantitative point of view, the
effect is smaller than that which would be optimum for
(32) Liu, Y.-J.; Persson, P.; Lunnell, S. J. Phys. Chem. A 2004, 108,
2339-2345.
(33) Grimshaw, J.; de Silva, A. P. Chem. Soc. Rev. 1981, 10, 181-
203.
(34) Schutt, L.; Bunce, N. J. In CRC Handbook of Organic Photo-
chemistry and Photobiology, 2nd ed.; Horspool, W. M., Lenci, F., Eds.;
CRC Press: Boca Raton, 2004; pp 38-1-38-18.
(35) Bu¨cher, G.; Scaiano, J. C. J. Phys. Chem. 1994, 98, 12471-
12473.
(36) Lee, W.; Jenks, W. S. J. Org. Chem. 2001, 66, 474-480.
(37) Tsurutani, Y.; Yamashita, T.; Horie, K. Polymer J. 1998, 30,
11-16.
(38) Tsurutani, Y.; Machida, S.; Horie, K.; Kawashima, Y.; Nakano,
H.; Hirao, K. J. Photochem. Photobiol. A 1999, 122, 161-168.
J. Org. Chem, Vol. 69, No. 24, 2004 8181