3454
M. Kaliner, T. Strassner / Tetrahedron Letters 57 (2016) 3453–3456
N
N
N
Na[BArF3,5],
DCM, rt, 24h
N
a: n = 0 (methyl)
b: n = 3 (butyl)
c: n = 5 (hexyl)
d: n = 10 (undecyl)
n
n
Hal
[BArF3,5
]
R
R
R = 2-CH3
n = 0,3,5,10 (4a-d)
1a d
( - )
R = 2-CH3
n = 0,3,5,10
5a d
4-OCH3 n = 0,3,5,10
(
- )
6a d
4-OCH3 n = 0,3,5,10
2,4,6-CH3 n = 0,3,5,10
(2a-d)
3a d
2,4,6-CH3 n = 0,3,5,10
(
- )
(
- )
Scheme 1. Synthesis of borate TAAILs by anion metathesis.
group at the cation. Even redox active [BArF3,5] ILs containing a
ferrocenyl alkyl ammonium cation were synthesized.47
influence of the anion on the melting points of the TAAILs. We used
different alkyl chain lengths (small, medium, and long) and three
different electron donating substituents (2-Me, 4-OMe, 2,4,6-Me
[Mes]) which have a different influence of the electron density of
the phenyl ring. The methyl and mesityl groups exhibit an +I effect
that donates electrons through the sigma bonds into the ring, while
mesityl also has an additional steric influence. The +M effect of the
We focus on imidazolium based ILs, so-called tunable aryl alkyl
ionic liquids (TAAILs) that feature a (substituted) phenyl ring
together with an alkyl chain on the other nitrogen atom of the
heterocycle.48–50 Through the aryl ring additional mesomeric and
steric effects change the properties of the ionic liquids. Variation
of the substituent at the phenyl ring leads to different melting
points using the same alkyl chain length and anion depending on
the mesomeric or inductive effects of the substituent. Generally,
electron donating substituents show lower melting points than
electron withdrawing substituents as previously reported.49 The
exchange of the anion also has an influence on the properties of
the TAAILs. Coordination of small anions (Br, I) leads to higher
melting points compared to the bigger anions ([BF4], [PF6]).48 Ionic
liquids with N,N-dialkyl imidazolium cations and [BArF3,5] anion
have been found to exhibit interesting properties. Therefore we
investigated the influence of the [BArF3,5] anion on different aryl
alkyl imidazolium cations by combining the large cations with
bulky weakly coordinating anions. In this Letter we report the syn-
methoxy group results in an electron donation through the p-sys-
tem. To visualize the electronic effects we calculated the electro-
static surface potential (ESP)54 of the substituted 1-aryl 3-butyl
imidazolium cations 4b, 5b, and 6b as shown in Figure 2. To com-
pare the ESP’s of the imidazolium cations with different sub-
stituents (2-Me, 4-OMe, Mes) we kept the chain length (C4H9)
constant. Cations carry a positive charge all over the molecule,
the ESP representations differentiate between a more positive
potential at the imidazolium core (blue) and a negative potential
at the end of the alkyl chain and/or at the functional groups
(red). Substituents in para position at the aryl ring, especially
OMe, show a more negative potential than the methyl group at
the ortho position.
theses and characterization of 1-aryl 3-alkyl imidazolium [BArF3,5
]
TAAILs with mesityl substituents 6a–d lead to higher melting
points due to the steric influence of the methyl groups at the phenyl
ring (Table 1). If there are two methyl groups in ortho position to
the imidazolium ring the planes of the phenyl ring and of the imi-
dazolium ring55 are orthogonal to each other as could be demon-
strated by quantum chemical calculations (Fig. 2). [BArF3,5] ILs
4a–5d with mono substituted 2-Me and 4-OMe show lower melt-
ing points than the sterically hindered mesityl [BArF3,5] ILs, cer-
tainly due to minor steric influences between the aryl ring and
the imidazolium core.
The melting points of the imidazolium halide salts with 2-Me
1a–d and 4-OMe 2a–d show a minimum for the medium sized
hexyl chain length whereas for the mesityl imidazolium halide
salts 3a–d the melting points decrease by increasing alkyl chain
length.
ILs. The acronym [PhRCnIm][BArF3,5] describes TAAILs 4a–6d where
PhR characterizes type and position of the substituent R at the phe-
nyl ring and Cn the length of the alkyl chain at the imidazolium
core (Im). The general structure is given in Figure 1.
Results and discussion
The imidazolium halide salts 1a–3d were synthesized from the
commercially available anilines using previously described reac-
tions.48 The aryl imidazoles were accessible via a ring closing reac-
tion using
a one-pot procedure with glyoxal, formaldehyde,
ammonium chloride, and the respective anilines, followed by a
nucleophilic substitution with an alkyl halide. The aryl imida-
zolium [BArF3,5] salts 4a–6d were synthesized by anion metathesis
with Na[BArF3,5] from the aryl imidazolium halide salts 1a–3d as
By exchanging the halide anion with [BArF3,5] the behavior of
the methyl imidazolium ILs 4a–d changed, leading to generally
lower melting points with increasing chain length as can also be
shown in Scheme 1. After addition of an equimolar amount of Na
51
[BArF3,5
]
to the solution of the halide salts 1a–3d in
dichloromethane the reaction mixture was stirred at room
temperature for 24 h. After removal of the sodium halide salt and
solvent, TAAILs 4a–6d were obtained in excellent yields between
88% and 99%.52 The synthesized TAAILs show no transformation
when exposed to air and can be washed with water. They are air
and water stable and do not need to be handled or stored in a
glovebox. The sodium tetrakis[3,5-bis(trifluoromethyl)phenyl]bo-
rate (Na[BArF3,5]) was synthesized through a modified route
according to Smith et al. using a Grignard reaction.53 Because of
the high and sometimes explosive reactivity of the Grignard reac-
tant the reaction should be handled with care. No problems with
the reaction could be observed following the instructions. The
azeotropic distillation was carried out with toluene instead of
benzene and provided the Na[BArF3,5] salt as a colorless solid.
We investigated the influence of the substituent at the aryl ring
and the alkyl chain length of the cations in comparison to the
Table 1
Melting points of 1-aryl 3-alkyl imidazolium [BArF3,5] ionic liquids 4a–6d and 1-aryl
3-alkyl-imidazolium halide salts 1a–3d
Anion
R
Me (C1)
Bu (C4)
Hex (C6)
Undec (C11)
[BArF3,5
]
2-Me
4-OMe
2,4,6-Me
71
83
102
70
44
86
41
68
70
À27d
À23d
À21d
47b
46b
60b
2-Me
4-OMe
2,4,6-Me
119a
127a
160a
61b
56a
90a
lb,c
Halide
la,c
68a
a
b
c
Imidazolium salts with iodide counterions.
Imidazolium salts with bromide counterions.
Ionic liquids are liquid (l) at room temperature.
d
Glass transition temperature upon cooling; all melting points are given in °C.