Organic Letters
Letter
a
Scheme 1. Scope of Hybrid Cinchona-Based Catalysts
Scheme 2. Asymmetric Epoxidation of α,β-Unsaturated
a
Ketones S1−S21 Using Catalyst C5
a
The ee values were determined by HPLC analysis using a chiral
column Kromasil OD-H or Chiralcel AD-H and OB-H.
compound C5 allows the desired epoxides to be obtained with
high yield (99%) and promising enantiomeric excess (71% ee).
Also, reactions with catalysts based on the other Cinchona
alkaloids give the desired products with excellent yield, but in
racemic form.
Subsequently, we started to optimize the reaction conditions
using C5 as the catalyst, and we noted that the ratio of hydrogen
peroxide and aqueous solution of NaOH strongly affected the
enantioselectivity. We postulate that the oxidant/base ratio
affects the rate of hydrogen peroxide decomposition and
formation of the reactive HOO− ion. Moreover, instead of
toluene we found that a mixture of Et2O/toluene (1:1) was the
best solvent for most of these reactions. Finally, we showed that
epoxidation of chalcone S1 under the newly found conditions
was very efficient and proceeded for 1 h with an excellent
enantiomeric excess (99% ee), using only 0.5 mol % of catalyst at
5 °C temperature. Lower catalyst loading resulted in decreased
yield and ee value. All details of the optimization process are
Under such optimal conditions we examined the reactivity and
selectivity of α,β-unsaturated ketones S1−S21 as shown in
Scheme 2.
All of the epoxides P1−P21 were obtained from the
corresponding substrates S1−S21 with both excellent yield
and excellent enantioselectivity. For substrates S1−S13, with
various electron-differentiating substituents on the carbonyl
group side, no significant changes in the extremely high
selectivities (95−99% ee) were observed. Due to lower solubility
of epoxides P6, P10, and P12 in the diethyl ether, reactions
should be carried out longer (up to 48 h). Slightly lower
enantiomeric excesses were noted for epoxidation of E-
chalcones with an electron-differentiating substituents in the
phenyl ring on the double bond side S14−S17. In those four
cases, achievement of complete conversion required the use of 1
mol % of the catalyst and the reactions were carried out in
toluene (P13−P16 marked green, Scheme 2), but we noted very
high yields and ee values (92−99%, 90−96% ee). With more
challenging substrates S18−S21 we performed the epoxidation
reactions with 3 mol % of the catalyst C5 and also in these cases
we choose toluene as an optimal solvent (P18−P21 marked
purple, Scheme 2). Epoxidation of S20 was conducted 72 h
a
The ee values were determined by HPLC analysis using a chiral
b
column Kromasil OD-H or Chiralcel AD and OB-H. The ee values
were determined by HPLC analysis using a chiral column Kromasil
OD-H or Chiralcel AD and OB-H. Reactions were carried out in
toluene, and 1 mol % of C5 was used.
c
leading to product with moderate yield 71% and high
enantiomeric excess 97% ee. It is worth mentioning the great
results obtained for (2E,4E)-1,5-diphenylpenta-2,4-dien-1-one
S18 (95% yield, 96% ee) and α,β-unsaturated ketone S21
containing aliphatic substituent (98% yield, 99% ee). In
addition, all epoxides, except P20, can be isolated from organic
layer using simple filtration by silica gel pad. Such results
indicate a fairly universal character of the developed method,
and to the best of our knowledge it is a first example of successful
epoxidation such substrates using organocatalysts.
The obtained results may indicate a competitive π-stacking
effect originating from the phenyl system on the double bond
side, which may adversely affect the formation of the
diastereomeric complex with the catalyst C5. In order to explain
such high selectivity, we obtained monocrystals of C5 by slowly
evaporation of its saturated solution in wet acetone. Next, we
performed a successful single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis of
revealed its distinctive three-dimensional structure (Figure 1).
Let us consider one of the catalyst molecules as it occurs in a
single crystal. The C5 molecule has an aromatic ring stacked in
the direction determined by the amide function. Importantly,
the arrangement of the phenyl group in the amide arm is nearly
perpendicular, this conformational information creating an
attractive chiral reaction cavity around the amide function. This
B
Org. Lett. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX