2
J.G. Varnes et al. / Bioorganic & Medicinal Chemistry Letters xxx (2018) xxx–xxx
quinuclidine isomers of 2b similar to 3 have been reported,14 3 also
had the potential advantage of having a single chiral center. We
were optimistic that this might increase synthetic tractability
and facilitate exploration of our hypothesis.
While the potency and solubility (typically high for the compounds
described herein) of 4 were acceptable, both lipophilicity, as mea-
sured by clogP, and stability on incubation with human liver
microsomes were higher than desired. Reasoning that reductions
to the former might also attenuate the latter, we sought to reduce
clogP (<4) in a variety of ways. This included a) heteroaromatic and
substituent changes to the benzamide aromatic ring, b) conversion
of the unsubstituted phenyl moiety into various heterocycles, and
c) ring contraction of the isoquinuclidine itself.
As shown in Table 1, a comparison of 2b and 3 in a glycine
uptake inhibition assay9 revealed slightly more than a ten-fold
decrease in potency. While this did not confirm our hypothesis,
we were gratified that such a change still afforded a compound
with appreciable in vitro activity. Even more interesting, enan-
tiomer 4 did demonstrate activity comparable to 2b. This was sur-
prising, because the chirality of the benzylic position of 4 (R
enantiomer) is opposite that of the same position in 2b (S,S). Sus-
pecting an error in stereochemical assignment, we validated the
chirality of both 3 and 4 by vibrational circular dichroism (VCD)
and X-ray crystallography (discussed below). A molecular overlay
(recreated in MOE)15 reinforced the concept that similar potencies
between 2b and 4 were not unreasonable as there is good overlap
of benzamide, aryl, and heterocyclic regions (Fig. 1).
In the course of elucidating benzamide SAR to attenuate
lipophilicity, simple heterocyclic replacements (Not shown: 1-
methyl-imidazol-4-yl, thiazol-4-yl; GlyT1 uptake IC50 > 20 lM) of
the aryl ring were insufficient to retain potency. For benzamides
themselves, potency was found to directly depend on the nature
and number of ortho substituents. Specifically, linear free energy
relationship analysis (LFER) identified both the ortho substituent
parameter (Es; inverse correlation)17 and hydrophobic nature (
p
Hammett constant; positive correlation) of the benzamide ortho-
substituents to be good predictors of glycine uptake inhibition.
Where such information was not available, a torsion angle analysis
could be used to roughly bin compounds according to potency
(Fig. 2). In other words, hydrophobic ortho-substituents that per-
turbed the planarity of amide-aryl conjugation generally were
more active at inhibiting glycine uptake.
We were interested in modifying 4 to be a probe suitable for
evaluation in a murine MK801 locomotor activity (LMA) assay.16
Table 1
Initial assessment of isoquinuclidine enantiomers.
Armed with this knowledge, we looked at ways to reduce the
clogP of 4 through nitrogen incorporation while still maintaining
potency via installation of ortho substituents such as chloro,
methyl, bromo, and thiomethyl (Table 2). In general, pyridine ana-
logs were less active (6 vs 7; 9 vs 10; 14 vs 15) than their simple
phenyl counterparts, with 3-pyridyl amides evoking the most dra-
matic potency reductions (10 & 13). The most active compounds,
however, were those containing chloro, methyl, or thiomethyl
ortho substituents (6–9), and, in particular, 4-pyridyl analog 7 rein-
forced the concept that clogP could be reduced in select cases with
only a slight decrease in uptake efficiency.
2b (S,S)
3 (S)
4 (R)
Uptake IC50 (nM)a
Sol (mM)b
clogP
3
41
6
124
5.1
2.9
34
>500
5.4
2.7
34
>482
5.4
2.7
34
logDc
PSA (Å2)
hu CLint
(l
L/min/mg)d
223
103
109
Glycine uptake inhibition assay.9
Equilibrium solubility (pH 7.4).10
a
b
c
Empirically determined partitioning ratio: octanol/water (pH 7.4).
Rate of clearance as measured in human liver microsomes.
d
Despite reductions in lipophilicity, we saw no improvement in
predicted human clearance (6 vs 7; 14 vs 15) for pyridine matched
pairs, and all compounds contained a low to moderate efflux liabil-
ity. Improvements in metabolic stability were only observed in a
very small number of benzamide modifications that involved
introduction of polar ortho substituents such as for 16 and 17
(hu CLint <4 lL/min/mg). While very potent, both compounds car-
ried additional liabilities such as concerns around potentially
mutagenic anilines (16) or excessively high efflux (17).
Fig. 2. Benzamide aryl-carbonyl (red arrow) torsion angle analysis color coded
according to GlyT1 uptake IC50 potency. Green: <100 nM; yellow: 100 nM to 1
lM;
red: >1
l
M. Aryl rings with hydrophobic ortho-substituents (R1 & R2) that hindered
free rotation were generally predisposed to be more potent at inhibiting glycine
uptake, with the preferred conformation trending towards one in which the
aromatic ring is perpendicular to the plane of the amide itself.
Fig. 1. Overlay of 2b (blue) with 4 (magenta) using MOE (Chemical Computing
Group) software.15