Macromolecules
Article
Figure 1. Polycarbonate materials development via bis-MPA-based monomers: state-of-the-art versus new routes from this work. (A) Material
development using automated synthetic platforms, (B) comparison of synthetic efforts for cyclic guanidine-functionalized carbonate. See refs 7, 28
and Figure S1A for information on previous routes to 3c. (C) New routes from this work to cyclic carbonate monomers using acid-promoted
carbonate formation. Abbreviations: ROP = ring-opening polymerization, CDI = carbonyldiimidazole, and EDC·HCl = N-ethyl-N′-(3-
dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide hydrochloride.
(Figure S1C).24 Although this approach was effective in
accessing a broad variety of functional carbonate monomers,
the transesterification step provided 50−90% yields, required
extended reaction times, and necessitated chromatographic
purification, which can be inconvenient at a larger scale.24,29
To improve on this process, Malkoch and co-workers
developed an alternative process using N,N′-carbonyldiimida-
zole (CDI) to generate an isolable imidazole ester intermediate
that is converted to the carbonate monomer in separate
esterification−cyclization step (Figure S1D).23 Although
demonstrated successfully on a multigram scales, the yields
varied between 23 and 43% and required purification by
chromatography.
Dimethyl carbonate has also been investigated as a reagent
for carbonate formation from diols.26 In the case of a bis-MPA
ester diol, however, an extended reaction time was required
and the product was contaminated with substantial amounts of
a linear bis-carbonate byproduct (Figure S1F). Carbon dioxide
has been reported as a reagent capable of synthesizing cyclic
carbonates of different ring sizes (Figure S1G). However, the
yields were modest (21−80%) and produced significant
amounts of oligomeric side products.30,31 To overcome the
limitations of these previous methodologies, we report two
complementary strategies for accessing a broad scope of bis-
MPA carbonate monomers in a two-step synthetic sequence.
alkyl (or benzyl/allyl) halide, which favors Route A. In other
cases, the functional group precursor is available as alcohol
and, therefore, Route B is better suited (Figure 1C).
The critical step in both routes is the cyclization of the 1,3-
diol to the carbonate and hinges on the successful employment
of CDI as the carbonyl source. CDI was chosen for its ease of
handling, low cost, and diminished toxicity compared to
triphosgene or ethyl chloroformate. Furthermore, CDI exhibits
improved reactivity compared to dimethyl- or diphenylcar-
bonate, which typically requires higher temperatures and
prolonged reaction times.3,26 The phenolic carbonate alter-
natives also necessitate the removal of super-stochiometric
amounts of a phenol byproduct, significantly complicating the
purification procedures. In contrast, the imidazole byproducts
from CDI are easily removed via acidic aqueous extraction.
Previous reports of the CDI facilitated cyclization 1,3-diols
required lengthy reaction times, undesirable chlorinated
solvents, and portion-wise addition of the reagent.20,32 Here,
we felt an improved protocol for CDI cyclizations could be
achieved through a judicious choice of reaction conditions and
a careful analysis of the reaction intermediates.
We began our investigation of the identified two-step
synthetic routes to carbonate monomers with Route A. The
first-step of alkylation in Route A of the bis-MPA carboxylic
acid has been performed using hydroxide (KOH), carbonate
(K2CO3 or Cs2CO3), and organic bases.4,33−35 The common
use of dimethyl formamide (DMF) in these procedures
complicates the workup and purification of the bis-MPA
ester diol product due to its high-boiling point and miscibility
in aqueous and organic solvents. To avoid DMF, we found that
the combination of triethylamine (Et3N) or N,N-diisopropy-
lethylamine (DIEA) in acetonitrile facilitated the alkylation
with a variety of alkyl halides, cleanly affording the bis-MPA
ester diols after an aqueous workup or following crystallization
RESULTS
■
We identified two potential synthetic strategies to access bis-
MPA carbonate monomers: Route A, alkylation (or Fischer
esterification) of the bis-MPA carboxylic acid to afford I,
followed by cyclization to the carbonate (Figure 1C), and
Route B, selective cyclization of bis-MPA to the corresponding
carbonate carboxylic acid II (Figure 1C), followed by N-ethyl-
N′-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide hydrochloride
(EDC·HCl) facilitating the esterification to afford the
monomer. The preference of route is dictated by the
availability of the appropriate precursors. In some cases, the
functional group precursor is commercially available as the
Moving on to the second synthetic step of Route A, we
examined a series of cyclization conditions using CDI with the
bis-MPA benzyl ester (S1a; Figure S2, Supporting Informa-
1768
Macromolecules 2021, 54, 1767−1774