2338
R. Xu et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 21 (2011) 2335–2340
Table 3
Constrained analogsa
H2N
N
R
N
N
N
R
Akt1 IC50
M)
PKA IC50
PKA/Akt
(fold)
pPRAS40 IC50
(
l
(l
M)
(lM)
O
S
O
O
O
23a
23b
23c
0.009
3.9
430
>40
250
0.69
N
HO
HO
HO
O
Figure 3. X-ray structure of 5 bound to Akt1 (PDB code: 3QKM).18
S
0.25
>10
13b
N
PKA inhibition while having modest effects on Akt potency.12 For
example, both 3b and 4 are capable of forming a pair of hydrogen
bonds with the backbone structure of Ala230 and Glu228 (Akt1),
while the quinazoline and pyrimidine cores in 5 and 6 can only
act as hydrogen bond acceptors. Clearly, loss of the H-bond donor
interaction from the core affects potency at PKA more than Akt1. In
addition, as we noted in previous studies,15,16 there are several key
differences between the active site residues of Akt1 and PKA that
could be exploited to influence the selectivity of various inhibitors.
In particular, the substitutions of Akt1-Ala230 to PKA-Val, Akt1-
Thr211 to PKA-Val, Akt1-Met281 to PKA-Leu gives rise to a nar-
rower cavity in PKA. The narrower cavity of PKA, relative to Akt1
was found to be less forgiving of larger substituents, leading to in-
creased selectivity. This seems to be borne out in the pyrimidine
series, where the larger cyclopropyl substitution of compound 6
leads to 280-fold selectivity relative to PKA. Interestingly, although
the amino pyrimidine compound ( )-11 can also interact with the
hinge via a pair of hydrogen bonds, it retained 180-fold selectivity
against PKA, again illustrating the effects of increasing size as a
means of improving the selectivity profile. It is worthwhile to note
that selectivity against p70S6K, another closely related protein ki-
nase in the AGC family, generally parallels the PKA selectivity. For
example, compounds 3a, 3b, 3c, 4 and 5 were about 3-, 25-, 43-,
4- and 230-fold selective against p70S6K, respectively.
O
S
0.019
4.7
2.4
N
a
Values are means of at least three experiments unless otherwise stated.
Values are means of two experiments.
b
propyl linker and ethoxy ethyl side chain of 3 via a pyrrolidine
ring.19 Among the three compounds examined, 23a had the best
potency, comparable to 11. The corresponding (R)-alcohol 23b
was found to be 28-fold less potent than 23a. A modest difference
in potency was observed between the two stereoisomers of the pyr-
rolidine ring, with the (R)-isomer slightly preferred (23a vs 23c).
Further SAR of the sulfonamide region attempted to replace the
sulfonamide group with an amide, carbamate, urea or benzyl
amine. All modifications led to substantial losses in potency (data
not shown). Interestingly, removal of the ethoxy ethyl side chain in
(R)-11 retained Akt1 activity (Table 4, compound 27a, Akt1
IC50 = 4 nM and pPRAS40 IC50 = 0.90 lM), and maintained excellent
The X-ray structure of 5 in complex with Akt1 has been deter-
mined (Fig. 3) and revealed that the (R)-enantiomer of the 2,7-
diazaspiro[4.5]decane linker binds preferentially.18 The crystal
structure also confirmed that the quinazoline nitrogen acts as a
hydrogen bond acceptor in binding to the backbone NH of
Ala230 (N–N distance 2.82 Å). The piperidine nitrogen and the hy-
droxyl group form bifurcated interaction with Asp292, while the
2,6-dimethyl phenyl ring occupies a lipophilic pocket underneath
the glycine-rich loop.
selectivity against PKA (850-fold). To better understand the hydro-
phobic interactions of the benzene ring with the lipophilic pocket
under the nucleotide binding loop, we prepared a series of sulfon-
amide analogs (27b–i). The 2-methyl compound 27b had compara-
ble potency to 27a, while the 2-F compound 27c was about 20-fold
less potent. Increasing the size of the ortho-substituent recovered
Akt1 activity (27d and 27e). Fluorine substitution at the para posi-
tion (27f) was tolerated, while substitution with a larger methyl
group resulted in 40-fold drop in activity (27g). Potency also de-
creased sharply by replacing the 2-methyl benzene group with a
4-methyl-3-pyridyl moiety (27h), which is consistent with the
highly lipophilic nature of the binding pocket. We also evaluated
replacement of the phenyl group with five-membered heterocy-
cles. The isoxazole analog 27i was found to be the most potent
compound in this group, with an Akt1 enzyme IC50 of 3 nM, cell po-
Encouraged by the selectivity and potency of ( )-11, we pre-
pared the active (R)-enantiomer. Consistent with the SAR in the spi-
rochromane series,12 (R)-11 was about 2-fold more potent than the
racemate (Akt1 IC50 = 6 nM and pPRAS40 IC50 = 0.38 lM). This
compound also exhibited good selectivity against PKA, with a
PKA/Akt1 ratio of 180-fold. Although compound (R)-11 exhibited
acceptable potency, we were concerned about the impact of high
molecular weight (ca. 587), high C log P (4.2) and large number of
rotatable bonds (14 total) on ADME. In order to improve the
drug-like properties of compound (R)-11, conformationally re-
stricted analogs 23a–c were prepared (Table 3). These were de-
signed to restrain the rotation of sp3–sp3 bonds by connecting the
tency of 0.49 lM, and greater than 600-fold selectivity against PKA.
In summary, we have described the syntheses and biological
activities of several novel and potent bicyclic spiro sulfonamide
Akt inhibitors. We have successfully improved the selectivity
against PKA of previously published spirochromanes.12 Future
studies will probe other aspects of these compounds to evaluate