M. M. Van der Walt et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 22 (2012) 7367–7370
7369
Table 1
Table 2
The IC50 values for the inhibition of recombinant human MAO-A and –B by
The IC50 values for the inhibition of recombinant human MAO-A and –B by
sulfanylphthalonitriles 6a–l
sulfanylbenzonitriles 7a–j
2
R
4
CN
CN
R
4
1
1
CN
R
IC50
(
l
M)a
R
IC50
MAO-B
(l
M)a
MAO-A
MAO-B
SIb
SIc,d
MAO-A
SIb
SIc,d
6a –S–(CH2)-C6H5
6b –S–(CH2)-(4-Cl-C6H4)
6c –S–(CH2)-(4-Br-C6H4)
6d –S–(CH2)-(4-F-C6H4)
6e –S–(CH2)-(4-OCH3-C6H4)
6f –S–C6H5
6g –S–(4-Cl-C6H4)
6h –S–(4-Br-C6H4)
6i –S–(CH2)2-C6H5
6j –S–C6H11
9.02 0.896 0.167 0.016 54
0.623 0.053 0.014 0.004 45
218 23.9 0.025 0.003 8720 5334
2.10 0.218 0.034 0.006 62 38
129 78.1 0.067 0.021 1925 1178
3.58 0.592 2.13 0.067 1.7
11.1 1.17 0.114 0.002 97
19.0 8.27 0.079 0.017 240 147.1
7.19 1.35 0.124 0.009 58
5.96 0.382 0.223 0.039 27
2.78 0.936 0.887 0.072 3.1
1.45 0.203 0.242 0.035 6.0
33
27
7a
7b
7c
7d
7e
7f
7g
7h
7i
–S–(CH2)-C6H5
42.4 3.10
20.3 6.62
129 18.5
54.7 22.8
5.59 0.744
36.9 1.02
18.2 2.17
8.52 0.869
54.3 11.9
9.87 3.03
1.58 0.327
0.531 0.114
0.484 0.052
0.449 0.128
0.861 0.165
11.2 0.584
4.28 2.09
0.637 0.162
1.81 0.130
4.77 0.383
27
38
16
23
163
75
4.0
2.0
2.6
8.2
18
– S–(CH2)-(4-Cl-C6H4)
– S–(CH2)-(4-Br-C6H4)
– S–(CH2)-(4-F-C6H4)
–S–(CH2)-(4-OCH3-C6H4)
–S–C6H5
267
122
6.5
3.3
4.3
13
1.0
59.6
–S–(4-Cl-C6H4)
– S–(4-Br-C6H4)
–S–(CH2)2-C6H5
–S–C6H11
35.5
16.3
1.9
30
2.1
7j
1.3
6k –S–C5H9
6l –S–(CH2)2-CH(CH3)2
a
All values are expressed as the mean SD of triplicate determinations.
The selectivity index is the selectivity for the MAO-B isoform and is given as the
3.7
b
a
All values are expressed as the mean SD of triplicate determinations.
The selectivity index is the selectivity for the MAO-B isoform and is given as the
ratio of [IC50(MAO-A)]/[IC50(MAO-B)].
b
c
The selectivity index is the selectivity for the MAO-B isoform and is given as the
ratio of [IC50 (MAO-A)]/[IC50(MAO-B)].
ratio of Ki(MAO-A)/Ki(MAO-B).
c
d
The selectivity index is the selectivity for the MAO-B isoform and is given as the
The Ki values were calculated from the experimental IC50 values according to
ratio of Ki (MAO-A)/Ki(MAO-B).
The Ki values were calculated from the experimental IC50 values according to
the equation by Cheng and Prusoff: Ki = IC50/(1 + [S]/Km). For human MAO-A,
the equation by Cheng and Prusoff: Ki = IC50/(1 + [S]/Km). For human MAO-A,
d
[S] = 45
l
M and Km (kynuramine) = 16.1
lM, while for human MAO-B, [S] = 30 lM
and Km (kynuramine) = 22.7
l
M.17,23
[S] = 45
and Km (kynuramine) = 22.7
l
M and Km (kynuramine) = 16.1
lM, while for human MAO-B, [S] = 30 lM
l
M.17,23
are more favourable for MAO-B inhibition compared to
sulfanylbenzonitriles.
The results given in Tables 1 and 2 show that the sulfanylpht-
halonitriles and sulfanylbenzonitriles also are inhibitors of MAO-
A. In all instances, these compounds are, however, selective for
MAO-B with SI values ranging from 1.7–8720. Only one compound,
ring further enhanced MAO-B inhibition potency with compounds
6b–e exhibiting IC50 values of 0.014–0.067 M. In fact, 6b proved
to be the most potent MAO-B inhibitor of the present series. In con-
trast to the effect of the benzylsulfanyl moiety, phenylsulfanyl sub-
stitution on the phthalonitrile moiety, to yield 6f (IC50 = 2.13 lM),
l
resulted in only moderate MAO-B inhibition. Interestingly, halogen
substitution on the phenyl ring of 6f improved MAO-B inhibition
6b (IC50 = 0.623
range for the inhibition of MAO-A. Based on IC50 values of 0.623–
218 M, it may therefore be concluded that sulfanylphthalonitriles
lM), exhibited an IC50 value in the submicromolar
with 6g–h exhibiting IC50 values of 0.079–0.114
lM. Substitution
l
on the phthalonitrile moiety with (2-phenylethyl)sulfanyl, cyclo-
hexylsulfanyl, cyclopentylsulfanyl and (3-methylbutyl)sulfanyl
side chains also resulted in potent MAO-B inhibition. These homo-
and sulfanylbenzonitriles are in general weak to moderate inhibi-
tors of MAO-A. It is noteworthy that two compounds, 6c and 6e,
exhibited SI values in excess of 1000. These compounds, particu-
larly 6c (SI = 8720), may therefore be considered as highly selective
for MAO-B. Compounds 6c and 6e are also highly potent MAO-B
inhibitors. As mentioned, selective and potent MAO-B inhibitors
represent good candidates for antiparkinsonian therapy.
It has been reported that phthalonitriles act as reversible MAO-
B inhibitors.13 To verify that the sulfanylphthalonitrile class of
compounds also interacts reversibly with MAO-B, the reversibility
of MAO-B inhibition by 6c was examined. For this purpose 6c, at
concentrations of 10 Â IC50 and 100 Â IC50, was preincubated with
MAO-B for 30 min and the extent of enzyme recovery after dilution
of the enzyme–inhibitor complex was measured.22 The results
show that, after dilution of the enzyme-inhibitor complexes to
concentrations of 6c equal to 0.1 Â IC50 and 1 Â IC50, the MAO-B
catalytic activities are recovered to levels of approximately 76%
and 48%, respectively, of the control value (Fig. 4). This recovery
of MAO-B activity is consistent with a reversible interaction be-
tween 6c and MAO-B. For comparison, MAO-B was treated in a
similar manner with the irreversible inhibitor, (R)-deprenyl, at a
concentration of 10 Â IC50. After 100-fold dilution, MAO-B activity
was, however, not recovered (0.8% of control).
logues (6i–l) displayed IC50 values of 0.124–0.887
worthy that the (2-phenylethyl)sulfanyl substituted homologue
6i (IC50 = 0.124 M) is slightly more potent than the benzylsulfanyl
lM. It is note-
l
substituted phthalonitrile 6a. This suggests that extension of the
benzylsulfanyl side chain result in slightly improved MAO-B inhi-
bition. Reduction of the length of the benzylsulfanyl side chain of
6a to yield 6f, however, markedly lowers MAO-B inhibition
potency.
The MAO inhibitory properties of the sulfanylbenzonitriles are
given in Table 2. The results show that, although several com-
pounds exhibit IC50 values in the submicromolar range, the sul-
fanylbenzonitriles exhibited lower binding affinities for MAO-B
than the corresponding sulfanylphthalonitrile homologues. The
MAO-B inhibitor potencies of the sulfanylbenzonitriles ranged
from 0.449–11.2 lM with the most potent inhibitor being com-
pound 7d. As observed for the sulfanylphthalonitriles, substitution
(Cl, Br, F and OCH3) on the benzylsulfanyl ring enhanced MAO-B
inhibition potency compared to the unsubstituted homologue 7a
(IC50 = 1.58
e, possessed IC50 values of 0.449–0.861
stitution on the phenyl ring of 7f (IC50 = 11.2
inhibition with 7g–h exhibiting IC50 values of 0.637–4.28
l
M). These substituted homologues, compounds 7b–
M. Similarly, halogen sub-
M) improved MAO-B
M.
l
l
In conclusion, the present study shows that the sulfanylpht-
halonitrile and to a lesser extent the sulfanylbenzonitrile classes
of compounds are in general highly potent inhibitors of MAO-B.
A particularly promising compound among those examined is the
para bromo substituted derivative of 4-(benzylsulfanyl)phthalonit-
rile, compound 6c. This compound displays potent MAO-B
l
Among the sulfanylbenzonitriles, phenylsulfanyl substitution (to
yield 7f) resulted in the weakest MAO-B inhibition. This result is
similar to that obtained with the sulfanylphthalonitriles. Based
on these results it may be concluded that sulfanylphthalonitriles