88
S. Butini et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 23 (2013) 85–89
site. The two phenyl rings at C3 (R1, Table 1) and C5 positions lean
forward the S1 and the S3 cavities, respectively, establishing
hydrophobic contacts with L30, I110 and W115 side chains. These
interactions may account for the micromolar inhibitory potency of
(S)-1a. In line with the experimentally determined IC50, a similar
docking outcome was obtained with the isomer (R)-1a. Consistent
with the binding pose of 1a, and in line with the IC50, the tethering
of the phenyl ring at C3 by one or two methylenes (1c and 1d) and
the introduction of an hydroxyethyl group (1e), resulted in a severe
clash with the S1 pocket wall (due to the BDZ scaffold rigidity), and
in a clash in the S20 pocket respectively. It must be noted that in
compounds 1b and 1f, neither the protonated nitrogen (1b) nor
the hydroxyl group (1f) lay close enough to any of the Asp residues
at the catalytic site for engaging productive interactions. Contras-
tingly, for 1g and 1h a more favorable spatial arrangement of the
HEA portion may account for the micromolar BACE-1 inhibition
potency. In line with the experimental IC50 values docking results
obtained with 1a suggested that the major flexibility of the seco-
analogues, would allow the molecules to better fit within BACE-1
active site. Accordingly, when the most active compound (S)-2c
was docked within the enzyme (Fig. 3a), H-bonding interactions
with the catalytic Asp residues were detected (Fig. 3b). Further-
more, the benzylamine group of (S)-2c occupies the S20 pocket,
establishing a T-shaped interaction with the Y198 side chain and
hydrophobic contacts with I226, T329, S35, and Y71. The o-disub-
a modified BACE cleavage sequence, NFEV and a K612V mutation
which prevents processing by
-secretase.19 The other assay em-
ploys SHSY5Y cells expressing APP NFEV and the wild-type
cleavage site. The compounds were tested to determine their IC50
against the generation of sAPPb (direct functional read out for
a
a-
BACE-1 activity). The determined IC50 values ranged from 2.6
to >22 M in HEK293 cells and from 1.2 M to >22 M in the
SHSY5Y cell line. In more detail, (S)-1g (IC50 >22 M in HEK293,
and IC50 >11 M in SHSY5Y) was in general less potent than the
lM
l
l
l
l
l
seco-compounds. Indeed (R)-2c and (S)-2d were found the most
interesting of the series showing IC50 values in both cell lines rang-
ing from 1.2 lM to 2.6 lM. Activities on cell based assays are in
line with the observed potencies on the isolated enzyme thus sug-
gesting that these scaffolds could be new hits for the development
BACE-1 inhibitors active on whole-cell assays.
In summary, we described a new series of BACE-1 inhibitors
based on a BDZ or a seco-BDZ structure. These compounds repre-
sent the first benzodiazepine compounds disclosed as BACE-1
inhibitors. As shown in Table 1, the seco-analogues proved to be
slightly more potent than BDZs and through docking studies we
have been able to clarify why the BDZ system opening led to an
improvement of the inhibitory potency. Nevertheless, optimization
of the inhibitors is necessary to obtain IC50s in the nanomolar
range and rational modifications of the BDZ scaffold will be guided
by the docking studies here presented. Taken together our molec-
ular modeling studies traced out the experimentally determined
SAR data, explained the higher potency of the seco-BDZs interme-
diates, and highlighted the optimization strategy which is cur-
rently ongoing in our laboratories.
stituted phenyl ring, lying under the flap region, establishes a p–p
stacking with Y71 side chain and hydrophobic contacts with F108
and I118. The phenone moiety of (S)-2c enters the S1 cavity, sur-
rounded by a L30 and I110, engaging a T-shaped interaction with
W115, while the R1 substituent (phenyl ring) plunges into the S3
pocket where no tight interactions are visible. The benzylcarba-
mate branch stretches out over the S3 pocket where an H-bond
is detected between T232 backbone NH and the carbamate car-
Acknowledgments
The Authors thank the European Research Centre for Drug Dis-
covery and Development (NatSynDrugs), MIUR Prin and Regione
Campania L.R. 05/02 grant for financial support. The Authors thank
Dr. Joseph P. Vacca at Merck-USA.
bonyl oxygen; R235 side chain establishes a cation-
p interaction
with the aromatic ring. The experimentally observed lack of stere-
oselectivity of interaction ((S)-2c vs (R)-2c, Table 1) was justified
by the superimposable binding poses obtained for both enantio-
mers. Also the seco-analogues (R)-2b, (R)- and (S)-2d share the
binding mode and enzyme inhibition potency in the low micromo-
lar range with compound 2c (as already observed in the BDZ ser-
ies). Our proposed binding mode could also explain the loss of
activity of compound (S)-2a, where the piperazine moiety at the
C3 faces the active site floor and gives a massive clash.
Supplementary data
Supplementary data associated with this article can be found, in
BACE-1 is a transmembrane protein anchored to the luminal
side of the intracellular compartment. Since some BACE-1 inhibi-
tors active in isolated enzyme-assays fail when tested in cellular
assays, we engaged the most interesting analogues of the series
((S)-1g, (S)-2c, (R)-2c, and (S)-2d) in functional cell-based assays.
One assay used HEK293 cells expressing APP construct containing
References and notes
1. Citron, M. Nat. Rev. Drug Discov. 2010, 9, 387.
2. McLean, C. A.; Cherny, R. A.; Fraser, F. W.; Fuller, S. J.; Smith, M. J.; Beyreuther,
K.; Bush, A. I.; Masters, C. L. Ann. Neurol. 1999, 46, 860.
3. Naslund, J.; Haroutunian, V.; Mohs, R.; Davis, K. L.; Davies, P.; Greengard, P.;
Buxbaum, J. D. JAMA 2000, 283, 1571.
4. Walsh, D. M.; Selkoe, D. J. J. Neurochem. 2007, 101, 1172.
5. Haass, C.; Hung, A. Y.; Schlossmacher, M. G.; Oltersdorf, T.; Teplow, D. B.;
Selkoe, D. J. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 1993, 695, 109.
6. Yan, R.; Bienkowski, M. J.; Shuck, M. E.; Miao, H.; Tory, M. C.; Pauley, A. M.;
Brashier, J. R.; Stratman, N. C.; Mathews, W. R.; Buhl, A. E.; Carter, D. B.;
Tomasselli, A. G.; Parodi, L. A.; Heinrikson, R. L.; Gurney, M. E. Nature 1999, 402,
533.
7. Vassar, R.; Bennett, B. D.; Babu-Khan, S.; Kahn, S.; Mendiaz, E. A.; Denis, P.;
Teplow, D. B.; Ross, S.; Amarante, P.; Loeloff, R.; Luo, Y.; Fisher, S.; Fuller, J.;
Edenson, S.; Lile, J.; Jarosinski, M. A.; Biere, A. L.; Curran, E.; Burgess, T.; Louis, J.
C.; Collins, F.; Treanor, J.; Rogers, G.; Citron, M. Science 1999, 286, 735.
8. Sadowski, M.; Wisniewski, T. Curr. Pharm. Des. 1943, 2007, 13.
9. De Strooper, B. Physiol. Rev. 2010, 90, 465.
10. Ghosh, A. K.; Brindisi, M.; Tang, J. J. Neurochem. 2012, 120, 71.
11. Sankaranarayanan, S.; Holahan, M. A.; Colussi, D.; Crouthamel, M. C.;
Devanarayan, V.; Ellis, J.; Espeseth, A.; Gates, A. T.; Graham, S. L.; Gregro, A.
R.; Hazuda, D.; Hochman, J. H.; Holloway, K.; Jin, L.; Kahana, J.; Lai, M. T.;
Lineberger, J.; McGaughey, G.; Moore, K. P.; Nantermet, P.; Pietrak, B.; Price, E.
A.; Rajapakse, H.; Stauffer, S.; Steinbeiser, M. A.; Seabrook, G.; Selnick, H. G.;
Shi, X. P.; Stanton, M. G.; Swestock, J.; Tugusheva, K.; Tyler, K. X.; Vacca, J. P.;
Wong, J.; Wu, G.; Xu, M.; Cook, J. J.; Simon, A. J. J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther. 2009,
328, 131.
Figure 3. Docked structure of (S)-2c into the BACE-1 (PDB code: 1W51), where a
portion of the binding site is visible as cornflower surface. (a) Detailed interaction
mode of (S)-2c with BACE-1 active site residues; (b) ligands carbon atoms are
displayed in golden, and key binding site residues as cyan sticks. H-Bonds are
shown as dark-blue dotted lines.