1970
M. Franzini et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 23 (2013) 1967–1973
mutant vs. wild type IC50 ratio suffered significant erosion. This
observation supported the assumption that hydrophobic, aromatic
functionality in a specific orientation was necessary for optimal
inhibition of the G2019S mutant kinase. When tested in a 40-kinase
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
S
CF3
N
S
CF3
S
S
panel at 1 lM, 37 (solubility = 12 lM) showed the same excellent
selectivity for LRRK2 as seen for 1. Methyl ester 38 was found to
be about fivefold less potent than the corresponding amide, 37.
The configuration of the stereocenter in 38 does not seem to be rel-
evant, in that enantiomers 39 and 40 were virtually equipotent. Sim-
ple homologation of the alkyl substituent, as in 41, also did not
change the IC50 significantly. However, further branching into an
isopropyl group (as in 42) depressed potency. Incorporation of a
46
47
µ
µ
M
LRRK2wt IC50
=
>4
M
LRRK2wt IC50
=
>100
µ
µ
M
LRRK2GS IC50= 2.068
Av. solubility 3
M
LRRK2GS IC50= >4
Av. solubility 2
µ
µ
M
M
CO2Et
N
N
quaternary
a-carbon (43) strongly reduced activity, and virtually
N
N
N
erased any wt vs. mutant selectivity. Isosteres of the carboxylate
functionality, such as oxadiazole 44 and pyrazole 45, proved only
marginally beneficial. The average kinetic solubility of C-6 alkylthio
analogs was significantly improved for some ester derivatives
N
N
CO2Et
S
N
S
CF3
S
48
49
LRRK2wt IC50
LRRK2GS IC50= >100
µ
µ
LRRK2wt IC50
=
>100
M
M
µ
>100 M
=
(99
isosteres (88
(12 M for 37).
l
M for 39, as a representative example) and for heterocyclic
µ
M
LRRK2GS IC50= >100
µ
lM for 44), but remained low for primary amides
µ
Av. solubility 13 M
Av. solubility 31
M
l
Figure 4. C-7 and C-8 substituted analogs.
With the intent to probe the available space surrounding C-7 and
C-8, 7- and 8- methyl substituted derivatives of 3 (46 and 47, respec-
tively) were prepared and found to be virtually inactive, so were
analogs 48 and 49 (Fig. 4), an indication of the possible tight packing
in the binding pocket around this region. Further evidence for a con-
strained binding pocket came from the observed inactivity of a ser-
ies of analogs in which the thioether was replaced. Modeling
suggests that the dihedral angle around the thioether should be
close to 90°. Analogs incorporating O, as in 50, N, as in 51, or C, as
in 52 and 53, should have a wider dihedral angle and all were sub-
stantially less active (Table 5).
Oxidative metabolism soon emerged as a major liability with the
large majority of all the compounds in the sulfide series. Incubation
of 1 in NADPH-supplemented rat liver microsomes at 37 °C for
30 min completely consumed the parent molecule resulting in the
putative sulfoxide 54 and sulfone 55 metabolites. However, this oxi-
dation pathway was less extensive in human liver microsomes. The
latter compounds were independently synthesized, tested, and
found to be very weak inhibitors (Fig. 5). They were also significantly
more resistant to degradation in the microsomal stability assays.
The replacement of the arylthio moiety with carbon-based and
small heterocyclic bioisosteric groups is the focus of current syn-
thetic efforts.
angle between the C-3 heteroaryl group and the [1,2,4]triazolo[4,3-
b]pyridazine core. Indeed, although G2019S IC50 values for parent
compound 1 and meta-substituted derivatives 18 and 19 are very
close to the corresponding values for 14 (within standard deviation),
ortho-substitution on the phenyl ring, such as that seen in 17, in-
duced a 10- to 20-fold decrease in potency. Similarly, 3-bromo-2-
thienyl derivative 13 showed a six- to eightfold decrease in potency
as compared to 3. Conversely, minor substitutions at the para posi-
tion on the phenyl ring, such as the fluorine in 20, come with a three-
fold decrease in potency, suggesting a tight space within the enzyme
pocket surrounding the phenyl ring on C-3. The presence of a hydro-
gen bond acceptor at the para position was not favorable either, as
shown by a further decrease in potency with compound 16 (to be
compared with 14 and 15).
Small cycloalkyl groups at C3, such as the cyclopropane ring in
21 or the cyclopentane in 22, are detrimental to potency (Table 2).
Modest expansion to a THP ring, as in 23, further reduces potency
by a factor of 3 to 4. The presence of a H-bond donor, as in piper-
idine analog 24, completely erased kinase inhibition; the same ef-
fect was observed upon introduction of a one-carbon linker
between the core and the thienyl ring (25).
In regard to a cellular assay, inhibition of LRRK2 kinase is known
to decrease autophosphorylation at S935. This measurement can be
utilized to assess LRRK2 kinase activity in cells.15 Our cellular assay
employed HEK293 cells stably transfected with LRRK2 (G2019S).
Concerning the substitution pattern on the thioaryl group linked
to C-6, the meta position of the trifluoromethyl substituent seemed
highly preferred (compare 26 and 27 with 1, Table 3). Most rewar-
dingly, the combination of a C-3 thiazole and a C-2 3-halo-
phenylthioether afforded compounds in this series (28, 29) with
single digit nanomolar potency against mutant LRRK2 while main-
taining selectivity vs. wild type LRRK2. This gain in potency was
not preserved in the meta-fluoro analog 30, an indication that steric
bulk and polarizability of the substituent in this position might be
relevant factors to maintaining potency. Electron-donating and
withdrawing groups, as in 31 and 33, respectively, or bulkier groups,
as in 32, seemed well tolerated. Introduction of heteroatoms in the
arylthio ring, to give for instance pyrimidine derivative 35, only
marginally affected potency. Exclusion of ring substituents, as in
34 or 36, reduced potency especially against the mutant, thus eras-
ing the selectivity gained in most other cases, an intriguing finding
in our SAR.
Several compounds exhibited better than 1 lM potency and we ob-
served some correlation with in vitro biochemical results, although
with a 100-fold discrepancy possibly due to poor permeability (Ta-
ble 6).
Synthesis
Based on several experimental findings that emerged during
our synthetic efforts, intermediate 59 behaves more like an acyl
chloride than as an aryl halide due to the high electron deficiency
of the fused heterocycle. Displacement by good nucleophiles, such
thiophenates and thiolates, typically occur under mild conditions
in the presence of inorganic weak bases (rt–80 °C) to give the tar-
get sulfides in generally good yield.
As a representative example, synthesis of compound 21 from
pyridazine 56 is shown in Scheme 1. The preparation of C-3 (het-
ero)aryl derivatives (such as 3) can take advantage of an expedi-
tious one-pot cyclocondensation of 3,6-dichloropyridazine 61
As with HTS hit 2, and in contrast to the observed trend with sub-
stitution on the left-hand side of the molecule, the aryl group linked
to C-6 via the sulfide can be replaced by a polar aliphatic chain, fea-
turing an ester or a primary amide (Table 4). In this series, primary
amide 37 was of comparable potency to aryl analog 3 although the