P.P. Christov et al.
Bioorganic & Medicinal Chemistry Letters 41 (2021) 127974
these compounds produced only modest inhibition of LDHA activity in
cells, with none of the compounds demonstrating an IC50 for cellular
lactate production of less than 5 µM.
SAR for LDHA inhibition and cellular effects. Reinforcing a trend
observed in our earlier work, the cellular data did not track well with
biochemical inhibition of LDHA. For example, the morpholine analog
13a showed reasonable LDHA inhibition, but poor cellular activity,
perhaps as a result of the polar oxygen atom. Removing this polarity
(13b-f) generated mixed results in enzyme inhibition, but generally
improved cellular IC50 values by ~3–10 fold. The more elaborated spi-
rocyclic azetidine 13g and the aniline 13h displayed inhibition data
within the same range as the initial amines.
We hypothesized that, much like our previously reported com-
pounds, application of the contemporaneously discovered SAR
regarding pyrazole substutitions15 and phenyl sulfonamide fluorina-
tion16 would afford more potent analogs. Thus, we prepared compounds
bearing an alkyl substituent at the 5-position of the pyrazole, using
synthetic routes similar to those reported previously (Scheme 2)15,16
Elaboration of the acetophenones 7a and 7b to the desired ethers 8
proved easier than late-stage functionalization for most analogs. The
derivatized acetophenones were alkylated twice using the previously
described conditions15,16 to give the 1,3-diketones 10, which were
cyclized to the corresponding pyrazoles 11. As reported, the cyclization
produces a separable mixture of regioisomers; the desired isomer was
cleanly saponified to give the ether analogs 12 a-p.
We postulated that an amide bond would create a planar derivative
that might match more closely with the biphenyl and alkynes previously
reported, and thus have superior residence time and cellular activ-
ity.15,16 These analogs were synthesized from a bromide-bearing inter-
mediate 11 (R4 = Br). The amides were installed with either a coupling
of an isocyanate and subsequent hydrolysis and saponification (for
nitrogen-attached amides 13 a-j) or by a molybdenum-mediated car-
bonylative amidation and saponification (to give carbonyl-attached
amides 14 a-d). Ultimately, these analogs also failed to deliver a
noticeable boost to biochemical or cellular activity. Despite certain an-
alogs displaying potent LDHA inhibition, with IC50 values of less than
10 nM (14a, 14d), the amine and amide subseries as a whole was
somewhat inferior in the cellular lactate inhibition assay compared to
the ether subseries.
The activity data with these compounds (Table 2) was generally
improved relative to the compounds in Table 1, with some analogs
generating single digit nanomolar inhibition of the enzyme and sub-
micromolar inhibition of lactate production in MiaPaCa-2 cells. Com-
pounds without the sulfonamide ring fluorine tended toward lower
activity (e.g. 12i). The matched pair 12m vs. 12l demonstrates an
extreme example of this relationship. Interestingly, we found an
imperfect correlation between enzyme and cellular inhibition data. For
example, while the 5–20 nM inhibition data for analogs 12b-g demon-
strates again a wide tolerance for alkyl ether groups in LDH inhibition,
the accompanying lactate data varies in a different pattern. Analogs 12f
and 12g are the most potent of this set in the lactate assay, despite higher
enzyme IC50 values. We selected the benzyl substitution of 12g for
further elaboration (selected compounds shown). Fluoro substitution on
this benzyl (12h) was well tolerated, but replacement with a heterocycle
(12j) diminished activity. We also elected to explore removal of the
methylene with phenyl ethers 12k-p. While enzyme inhibition for this
phenyl ether subseries was generally weaker than with comparators
bearing alkyl substituents, several analogs still showed lactate inhibition
IC50 values near 1 µM.
As we have previously reported15,16, compounds in the pyrazole
chemotype tend to be potent inhibitors of both LDHA and LDHB. A
similar relationship was found in this work, with LDHB IC50 values
typically 2–4 fold better than those for LDHA (Table 4).
As a class, the ether compounds trend toward superior cellular po-
tency compared to amine-based compounds, not only in the MiaPaCa2
lactate production assay, but also in an A673 Ewing’s Sarcoma line
(Table 4). In general, the effects of the compounds on cellular prolifer-
ation showed a similar trend as the lactate production assay, with the
ether compounds demonstrating low micromolar cytotoxicity in the
MiaPaCa2 line. Notably, activity in A673 cells was typically superior to
1a or 1b for some of the ethers, with 12g, 12h, 12j, and 12p showing
submicromolar proliferation IC50 values.
We also evaluated aniline derivatives (13 a-j, Table 3). These analogs
were prepared either from acetophenones similar to 9 (Scheme 2), but
bearing the required amines, or from a later stage palladium-mediated
Buchwald-Hartwig style coupling reaction17 from the corresponding
bromides (11, R4 = Br) that were carried through the synthetic route
(Scheme 2) from the corresponding acetophenone. A selection of small
saturated cyclic analogs 13 a-f were evaluated, showing a rather narrow
We assessed selected compounds for their binding to LDHA by SPR.
Similar to previously reported compounds, some of the ether-based in-
hibitors (e.g. 12b, 12e, 12h, 12j, and 12p) with submicromolar inhi-
bition of lactate production in the MiaPaCa2 cells showed very tight
binding to LDHA and accompanying long residence times, whereas alkyl
amines, such as 13a, and the aniline 13h, characteristically displayed
faster dissociation kinetics, with inferior cellular data to match.
Table 2
Ether analogs (12) bearing the cyclopropylmethyl pyrazole substitution.
Cpd
R2/3
R4
LDHA IC50 (nM)a
MaPaCa2 Lactate IC50 (µM)b
12a
12b
12c
12d
12e
12f
F/H
F/F
F/F
F/F
F/F
H/F
H/F
F/F
F/H
F/F
F/H
H/H
F/F
F/F
F/F
F/F
-O-methyl
8
5.7
-O-(2,2-difluorocyclopropyl)methyl
-O-3-tetrahydrofuranylmethyl
-O-2-tetrahydrofuranylmethyl
-O-cyclopropyl
5
1.4
5
3.0
5
2.9
8
2.1
-O-cyclopentyl
13†
19
22
84
23
34
1060
27
41
71
26
0.71†
0.69
0.67†
3.3†
1.0
12g
12h
12i
-O-benzyl
-O-3-fluorobenzyl
-O-4-fluorobenzyl
12j
-O-(5-(trifluoromethyl)-2-furanyl)methyl
-O-phenyl
12k
12l
1.7
-O-3-fluorophenyl
19
12m
12n
12o
12p
-O-3-fluorophenyl
0.97
1.7
-O-4-fluorophenyl
-O-4-trifluoromethylphenyl
-O-4-methylphenyl
1.1
0.87†
a
IC50 values represent the half maximal (50%) inhibitory concentration as determined in the previously reported assay,15,16 reported as a mean of 3 determinations.
CV ≤ 0.2 unless otherwise noted by†.
b
IC50 values represent the half maximal (50%) inhibition of lactate production in the referenced cell line,15,16 reported as a mean of 3 determinations. CV ≤ 0.33
unless otherwise noted by†.
3