Organic Letters
Letter
̈
Scheme 1. Product Variation in Dotz Reaction
Figure 1. Indanone and indane core natural products.
were an inseparable mixture, indicating possible benzannulated
and furan products. After systematically varying the solvents,
alkyne concentration, and temperature, the optimum con-
ditions were found to be performing the reaction of 1b with
alkyne 5b (0.95 equiv) in benzene (calcd 0.032 M) at 55 °C.
With the optimized conditions in hand, the scope of this
Fischer carbene pentannulation reaction to 3-substituted 1-
indanones was next examined. As shown in Scheme 2, the
reaction of Fischer carbene 1b with carbonate-based alkynes
delivered the indanone products 6b−d as single diastereomers
in moderate to good yields (42−65%). Alkynes with acyloxy
group gave the indanones 6e−h in 22−61% yields. A dimer
alkyne (prepared from propargyl alcohol and 1,8-octanedi-
carboxylic acid) furnished the dimer indanone 6i in 36% yield.
The butyrolactone-based alkynes reacted with 1b to provide
the indanones 6j and 6a in 45 and 51% yields, respectively.
Similarly, the Fischer carbene 1a with an ortho-methoxy group
reacted with different alkynes to deliver the indanones 6k−p in
21−52% yields. The 4-methoxy-, 2,3-dimethoxy-, 2-methoxy-3-
benzyloxy-, 2-methoxy-4-TBSO-, and 2-benzyloxy-4-TBSO-
based Fischer carbenes reacted with different alkynes and gave
the indanones 6q−u, respectively, in 41−52% yields.
Interestingly, the dimeric biphenyl Fischer carbene8b reacted
with propargyl benzoate to give dimeric indanone 6v in 25%
yield. A reaction of Fischer carbene 1b on a 1.1 mmol scale
with alkyne 5h (1.046 mmol) resulted in indanone 6e in 46%
yield (Scheme 2). With alkynes having a stereocenter (and
being enantiopure), the indanones 6b−d, 6a, 6k, 6l, and 6p−u
were obtained as single enantiopure diastereomers, as inferred
by NMR data and the relative stereochemistry corroborated
from the X-ray structure of 6a. For racemic alkynes with a
stereocenter, the racemic indanones 6g, 6h, 6j, 6n, and 6o
were also obtained as single diastereomers, as analyzed from
the NMR data.
lactone in six steps.9 The former on reaction with Fischer
carbene 1b surprisingly furnished the cyclopentannulation
product 6a in 51% yield as a single diastereomer. The structure
was fully characterized by using spectroscopic methods and
unambiguously confirmed by single-crystal X-ray data. We
could not isolate any other product from the reaction mixture
because it showed a trail of spots on TLC, probably of the
competing inseparable minor benzannulated or furan com-
pounds for the remaining mass balance. Considering the
alkyne 5a to have a acyloxy group adjacent to the alkyne, we
considered that a carbonate group would also give a similar
reaction. Thus the reaction of Fischer carbene 1b with alkyne
5b also provided the indanone product 6b in 35% yield.
The indanone moiety has immense significance. First, it is
present in many natural products, for example, taiwaniaquinol
B (7a),10a−d dichroanal A (7b),10e jungianol (7c),10f
mutisianthol (7d),10g kinamycins A−J (7e),10h−j nakiterpiosin
(7f),10k,l veratramine (7g),10m and so on (Figure 1). Second,
the indanone derivatives are used in medicine and show
various bioactivities.11,12 Considering a few reports on the
Fischer carbene pentannulation reaction and the significance of
the indanone moiety in many natural products and bioactive
molecules, we considered exploring the scope and limitation of
this reaction.
We next examined the alkyne selectivity toward pentannu-
lation versus the benzannulation of Fischer carbene, as shown
in Scheme 3. Ethyl propiolate (8) reacted with Fischer carbene
1b to deliver the known naphthol 9 in 46% yield.13 No
pentannulation product could be isolated in this reaction from
the trail of other minor reaction products. Similarly, the
acyloxy alkyne 10 from homopropargyl alcohol reacted with 1b
to provide naphthol 11 in 55% yield. The acetonide-based
alkyne 5b′ reacted with 1b to give naphthol 12 in 51% yield.
As previously discussed, acetonide alkyne 2 reacted with
The reaction of Fisher carbene 1b with alkyne 5b as model
substrates was considered for optimization. (See Table S1 for
details.) The reaction of 1b with 5b (1.5 equiv) in benzene at
50 °C gave indanone 6b in 35% yield. An inseparable trail of
spots was observed on TLC for the reaction mixture. We could
isolate compound 6b as the major product, whereas others
B
Org. Lett. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX