Bioorganic & Medicinal Chemistry Letters
Sulfur incorporation generally improves Ricin inhibition
in pterin-appended glycine-phenylalanine dipeptide mimics
Paul A. Wiget, Lawrence A. Manzano, Jeff M. Pruet, Grace Gao, Ryota Saito, Arthur F. Monzingo,
⇑
Karl R. Jasheway, Jon D. Robertus, Eric V. Anslyn
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of Texas at Austin, 1 University Station A1590, Austin, TX 78712, United States
a r t i c l e i n f o
a b s t r a c t
Article history:
Several 7-aminoamido-pterins were synthesized to evaluate the electronic and biochemical subtleties
Received 26 August 2013
Revised 3 October 2013
Accepted 7 October 2013
Available online 12 October 2013
observed in the ‘linker space’ when N-{N-(pterin-7-yl)carbonylglycyl}-
the active site of RTA. The gylcine–phenylalanine dipeptide analogs included both amides and thioam-
ides. Decarboxy gly-phe analog 2 showed a 6.4-fold decrease in potency (IC50 = 128 M), yet the analo-
gous thioamide recovered the lost activity and performed similarly to the parent inhibitor
(IC50 = 29 M). Thiourea 12 exhibited an IC50 nearly six times lower than the oxo analog 13. All inhibitors
showed the pterin head-group firmly bound in their X-ray structures yet the pendants were not fully
resolved suggesting that all pendants are not firmly bound in the RTA linker space. Calculated logP values
do not correlate to the increase in bioactivity suggesting other factors dominate.
Ó 2013 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
L-phenylalanine 1 was bound to
l
7
l
Keywords:
Pterin
Thioamide
Dipeptide mimic
Ricin inhibitors
RTA
SAR
As recently as April 2013 the biotoxin ricin has been employed
as a potential weapon against high-ranking government officials
including US Senator Roger Wickers and President Barack Obama.1
Ricin toxicity can occur from aerosol exposure in addition to a
due to the modification of the three dimensional space the mole-
cule occupies. These changes can be due to (amongst others) the
addition or reduction of steric bulk, conformational restrictions,
and/or hydrogen bonding preferences.6
wealth of other methods at doses below 1
l
g/kg body weight. Ricin
Highly specific interactions can be mapped and optimized with-
in classes of molecules by carefully controlling the modifications in
a drug candidate by keeping the overall sterics and degrees of free-
dom the same or highly similar. One way this has been achieved is
by amide bond translocation within drug candidates. Coppola et al.
found that reversing the order of the amide in one such substrate
could produce the dramatic effect of having no activity to 33% inhi-
has already seen use as a weapon, and due to the ease of castor oil
procurement and toxin extraction, the threat persists.2
The cytotoxin ricin is a prototypical type 2 ribosome inactivat-
ing protein found in castor beans.3 Ricin Toxin A (RTA), the A chain
of the cytotoxin Ricin, catalyzes adenosine depurination, and is an
optimal candidate for inhibitor Structure–Activity Relationship
(SAR) studies due to its ease of handling and known and reproduc-
ible crystal structure.4 Additionally, we have previously reported
numerous pterin-based RTA inhibitors as potential anti-Ricin
agents via structure-based design and virtual screening.5 The pter-
in heterocycle is not only consistent in showing activity with a
multitude of pendants attached, but also with rare exception deliv-
ers firmly resolved X-ray crystallographic data.
bition of their target protein at 10 lM. Translocation has also
shown varying effects on the stability of candidates in microsomes,
increasing t1/2, by a factor of 3.7
Conversion of amides to thioamides has been used frequently to
alter the native conformation of peptides by modifying the hydro-
gen bond strength and rotational barriers of the molecule or drug
candidate. Thioamides have been found to be compatibly stable
Structure–Activity Relationships (SAR) correlate the biological
response of a specific process to the varying of functional groups
of a biomolecule (i.e., protein mutation or modification), or to par-
ticipating substrates such as drug candidates, co-factors, etc. As
with proteins, subtle changes in drug candidate structure can dras-
tically change drug efficacy, uptake, binding affinity, toxicity, etc.
in such tertiary structures as b-sheets and a-helicies, even at
elevated temperatures. Their incorporation into organocatalysts
has seen improvements of selectivity factors (s) by an order of
magnitude.8 The geometry, determined by both spectroscopic9
and computational10 methods show shorter N–C(S) bond lengths,
longer C–S bond lengths, and higher amide rotational barriers,
suggesting a greater degree of N–C double bond character. In drug
candidates thioamide incorporation has produced dramatic
changes in KD, log p, and hydrolysis rate, thus changing biological
⇑
Corresponding author.
0960-894X/$ - see front matter Ó 2013 Published by Elsevier Ltd.