Organic Letters
Letter
(other than a vinyl group at the C4 position of isoxazole ring),
a reaction of 4-methyl-3,5-diphenyl isoxazole was carried out
under standard conditions and resulted exclusively in the
cleaved product 5q (Scheme 3), which suggested that only
suitable substituents at the C4 position of isoxazole ring
facilitate the cyclization. This reaction condition was also
compatible with the substrates containing a substituent at the
C5-aryl ring of 4-vinyl isoxazoles, which upon cyclization gave
the corresponding products in moderate to good yields [5r−5x
(Scheme 3)].
To gain further insight into the plausible pathways for the
transformations, a variety of studies were carried out (Scheme
4). 3,5-Diphenyl isoxazole (1a) was treated under the standard
conditions in the presence of DMSO-d6, resulting in 3a′ with
complete deuteration at the C4 position, clearly indicating that
C4 of the tetrasubstituted pyridine was derived from DMSO
(Scheme 4a).
A similar observation was made in the case of 4u, which
resulted in the incorporation of D at the C2 position (Scheme
4a), which suggested that DMSO was acting as a one-carbon
surrogate in generating a methylene group during the reaction
to form the pyridine. Copper triflate was found to be necessary
to facilitate the reductive cleavage of 3,5-diphenyl isoxazole
that is also supported by the fact that when the reaction was
carried out with enaminone 1a′ as the substrate, in the absence
of copper triflate, the corresponding tetrasubstituted pyridine
was obtained in good yield (Scheme 4b), whereas in the case
of 3,5-diphenyl isoxazole, no product formation was observed
in the absence of copper triflate (Scheme 4b).
To check the possibility of the involvement of a single-
electron transfer pathway, experiments were carried out in the
presence of radical trap agents under standard conditions
(Scheme 4c). These resulted in the desired tetrasubstituted
pyridine product with almost no inhibition in rate or yield of
the product. This result indicated that a single-electron transfer
pathway may not be involved in the reaction. We also
performed crossover experiments to check if the reaction
depicted in Scheme 2 was intra- or intermolecular. When the
reaction was performed with an equimolar mixture of 1h and
1k, it resulted in the crossover product 3hk, along with the
tetrasubstituted pyridines 3b and 3f (Scheme 4d), which
indicated that the reaction was intermolecular. To check
whether 7 was an intermediate in the reaction, 6 was
synthesized20 and treated with 1a as well as 1h under the
standard conditions (Scheme 4e). In both cases, the product
arising from 6 was obtained, indicating that 7 was a likely
intermediate in this transformation (see the Supporting
Scheme 4. D Labeling Studies and Control Experiments
On the basis of these observations and literature reports,21
plausible mechanisms for the transformations are proposed in
Scheme 5. The isoxazole, in the presence of Cu(OTf)2, may
exist in equilibrium with its ring-opened nitrene form (Cu-
imido) at 130 °C, which in the presence of the protic
conditions may undergo a protodemetalation to give the
corresponding enaminone 1a′. At this moment, the exact
pathway for this first step is not very clear to us. It is quite
possible that a disproportionation process to give Cu(I) and
Cu(III) may be involved, and this Cu(I) species could be
responsible for the reductive cleavage of the N−O bond of the
isoxazole. However, during the optimization studies, we found
that Cu(I) salts were not very effective in carrying out this
transformation. Therefore, a much more detailed study is
necessary to delineate this first step. In addition, DMSO in the
presence of acetic acid generates a methyl(methylene)-
sulfonium intermediate that on reaction with enaminone 1a′
results in A (path II, Scheme 5), which upon α-elimination
yields B.22 This on further reaction with enaminone 1a′ gives
intermediate C, which in protic media is in equilibrium with
intermediate D. Intermediate C is converted into its
corresponding enamine (E) (path IIB, Scheme 5), followed
by intramolecular 1,4-addition to give cyclic intermediate F,
which on deamination gives the Hantzsch pyridine (H), and
subsequent oxidation by Cu(II) gives the corresponding
tetrasubstituted pyridine 3 as a major product.
Intermediate D can give rise to the corresponding
tetracarbonyl intermediate (I) (path IIA, Scheme 5), which
further in the presence of ammonia generated during the
course of reaction forms an ammonium ion intermediate J at
the more electrophilic carbonyl carbon, leading to L, and
C
Org. Lett. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX