Organic Letters
Letter
Main-group catalysis offers an underutilized and sustainable
alternative to transition-metal catalysis; however, the redox
chemistry of transition metals is not readily translated to main-
group species. Although excellent progress has been made to
impart the entrenched methods of catalysis on the main-group,
the use of oxidative addition and reductive elimination remain
limited beyond the d-block.59 Recently, transborylation has
offered a new approach to main-group catalysis, where
controlled and directed isodesmic ligand interchange is
exploited for catalyst turnover and has enabled previously
stoichiometric reagents to be used as catalysts.60−62
Scheme 2
B−O/B−H transborylation has been used to render the
Midland reduction catalytic.63 If a suitable, secondary organo-
borane catalyst could be identified, then it was postulated that
B−O/B−H transborylation could be extended to the chemo-
selective reduction of enones with HBpin as a turnover reagent
and terminal reductant (Scheme 1c). 1,4-Hydroboration of an
enone by a secondary organoborane would give a dialkyl boron
enolate that could undergo B−O/B−H transborylation with
HBpin to give a Bpin-enolate and regenerate the secondary
borane catalyst. Hydrolysis of the Bpin-enolate on workup
would give the saturated ketone. Alternatively, the Bpin-
enolate could be trapped by an electrophile, resulting in a
reductive α-functionalization of the enone.
Commonly used boranes 1a−c for the stoichiometric 1,4-
hydroboration of enones were assessed as potential catalysts
for the chemoselective alkene reduction of enones using
chalcone 2a as a model substrate and HBpin as the turnover
reagent (Scheme 2a). The commercially available [H-B-9-
BBN]2 1c achieved the best results, giving dihydrochalcone 3a
without any observed ketone reduction. Equal catalytic activity
was observed in several solvent systems including EtOAc,
THF, and toluene. EtOAc was chosen for further study due to
the high product yield and its status as a “green” solvent.64
Cyclic enones, such as cyclohexenone, were unreactive,
presumably due to the inability to orientate into the s-cis
conformation required for 1,4-hydroboration. In accordance
with previous reports,65 α,β-unsaturated esters and amides
a
For further details of the optimization reaction conditions, see Table
1
S1. H NMR yields were calculated from the crude reaction mixture
using 1,3,5-trimethoxybenzene as an internal standard.
To support the proposed mechanism of catalysis, isotopic
labeling experiments were conducted (Scheme 2). The use of
D-Bpin resulted in deuterium incorporation solely at the β-
position, consistent with 1,4-hydroboration of the enone by D-
B-9-BBN D1-1c, generated by B−O/B−D transborylation
(Scheme 2b). The mechanism of B−O/B−H transborylation
was investigated with 10B-enriched H-10Bpin in a single-
turnover experiment with the O-B-9-BBN enolate 4a. The
resulting O-Bpin-enolate 10B-5a was obtained with complete
10B incorporation, showing that the B−O bond of the O-B-9-
BBN enolate 4a was exchanged alongside catalyst regeneration
rather than a ligand redistribution, which would break the B−
C bonds (Scheme 2c).
Having optimized the reaction conditions and confirmed the
mechanism through isotopic labeling, the reaction was applied
to a diverse scope of enones (Scheme 3). Dihydrochalcone, 3a,
was isolated in high yield (92%) with complete chemo-
selectivity for alkene reduction and without the formation of
any allylic alcohol observed. The reaction tolerated the
presence of an excellent array of reducible functional groups
including ester 3b (91%) and 3e (74%), nitrile 3c (52%),
alkyne 3d (68%), nitro 3f (82%), and alkene 3g (55%)
substituents. These functionalities react with stoichiometric
borane reagents and can be reduced by transition-metal-
catalyzed hydrogenation or transfer hydrogenation.66 A benzyl
ether 3h (73%) was retained during the alkene reduction,
demonstrating orthogonality to Pd/H2, which cleaves benzyl
ethers by hydrogenolysis. The inclusion of heteroaromatic
structures was tolerated, including pyridine 3i (65%),
thiophenes 3j (82%) and 3k (57%), and furan 3l (89%)
groups. In the case of pyridine 3i, a 2-bromo substituent was
required to prevent the coordination and deactivation of the
borane catalyst. Aryl halides were also tolerated with substrates
bearing fluoro 3m (93%), chloro 3n (92%), bromo 3o (85%)
and 3p (86%), and iodo 3q (90%) substituents all chemo-
selectively reduced at the alkene without any deleterious side
reactions. This is notable because halide-substituted substrates
can be challenging using transition-metal catalysis due to
unwanted oxidative addition and protodehalogenation.67
The Lewis acidic catalyst achieved good yields in the
presence of substrates bearing Lewis basic functionalities such
as a thioether 3r (87%), dimethylamino 3y (96%), and an
ether 3s (87%) groups. Several dimethoxydihydrochalcones
3t−3w were isolated in good yields with complete selectivity
for alkene reduction. A substrate bearing an unprotected
phenol 3x was successfully reduced (88%) using in situ
protection with an additional equivalent of HBpin. The
2499
Org. Lett. 2021, 23, 2498−2504