T. Furukawa et al. / Chemistry and Physics of Lipids 200 (2016) 133–138
135
Table 1
Our “semi-synthesis” strategy is shown in Fig. 2. As a starting
Product yields for each step and selectivity values for the regioisomers.
point, we chose commercially available diacyl-phosphoethanol-
amine 1 (PE). The protection of the amino functionality and a
subsequent deacylation should afford intermediate 2. A regiose-
lective mono-acylation of this diol 2 with a variety of fatty acid
derivatives, followed by the deprotection of the amino group
should furnish the targeted LPE molecules in only two steps.
For the protection of the amino functionality in commercially
Entry RCOCl (R = )
Yield (%)
2-LPE:1-LPE
Acylation Deprotection
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
C10:0 (capric acid) 7
27
18
18
11
44
26
54
77
69
56
60
47
59
69
37
79
80
3:1
7:3
7:3
7:3
3:1
3:1
3:1
3:1
3:2
7:3
3:1
C16:0 (palmitic acid) 8
C18:0 (stearic acid) 9
C18:1 (oleic acid) 10
C18:2 (linoleic acid) 11
C18:3 (pinolenic acid) 12
available
1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine
(DPPE, 4), we chose the trityl group, which have already
successfully employed in a previous PE synthesis (Aneja et al.,
1969; Plückthun et al., 1985). The protection of the amino group in
4 using tritylbromide and triethylamine proceeded quantitatively,
and the subsequent deacylation under Zemplén conditions
(Zemplén and Pacsu, 1929) afforded the desired amino-protected
diol 6 in 87% yield (Scheme 1).
C18:3 (a-linolenoic acid) 13 10
C18:3 (g-linolenoic acid) 14 26
9
10
11
C20:4 (arachidonic acid) 15 27
C20:5 (EPA) 16
C22:6 (DHA) 17
37
38
Morestericallyfavorablesn-1 OHreactspriortomore hinderedsn-2
OH (Roelens, 1996).
With ready access to intermediate 6, we proceeded to the
subsequent acylation step. Given that the target of this synthetic
route was to synthesize LPE in a highly regioselective manner, we
attempted a tin-mediated activation, given the proven track record
of this method in carbohydrate chemistry (Jäger and Minnaard,
2015). Moreover, this approach has already been successfully
applied to the synthesis of LPCs by Servi et al. (Fasoli et al., 2006).
When we applied this approach to diol 6, we obtained trityl-
protected LPEs 70–170 inyields that were merely moderate (18–44%)
compared to previously reported LPCs (Scheme 2) (Fasoli et al.,
2006; Niezgoda et al., 2013). The results of these experiments are
summarized in Table 1. During these experiments, we realized that
thisacylationstepisverysensitivetowater.Whensolventswerenot
driedenoughpriortouse, decreasedyieldswereobserved(entries 4
and7, Table1). AsolventscreeningrevealedthatDMFaffordedmore
reproducibility than conventional isopropanol (data not shown).
Even though trityl-protected LPEs 70–170 were soluble in CDCl3, we
were unable to obtain useful NMR spectra, and observed only broad
features. Therefore, we proceeded to the final deprotection step
without prior NMR analysis. A subsequent work-up under acidic
conditions afforded LPEs 7–17 in good yield (35–80%) (Table 1).
After deprotection, we observed regioselectivity ratios (2-LPE:1-
LPE) of 3:1–7:3, with the exception of 3:2 for 15 (entry 9, Table 1).
Even though these ratios are not as high as for the previously
reported LPCs (Fasoli et al., 2006; Niezgoda et al., 2013), they are
nevertheless acceptable, considering the aforementioned prob-
lematic acyl migration. Even if the acylation was highly regiose-
lective, the acidic work-up should promote a 1,2-O-acyl migration
and thus lower the selectivity. It is generally considered that the
regioselectivity of tin-mediated reaction is induced by steric effect:
We also tested the Teoc protecting group in order to shield the
amino functionality (Scheme 3), as Teoc can be removed under
milder conditions than the trityl group. Fortunately, this change
increased the yield in the acylation step to 72%. Unfortunately, the
deprotection was not successful at all. A fluoride-induced removal
did not proceed, and treatment with TFA afforded complex product
mixtures. This result indicates that the judicious choice of
protecting group for the amino functionality should be critical
for both acylation and deprotection.
3.2. Analysis of LPE regioisomers by LC/MS
So far, discrimination of regioisomers has been carried out
predominantly by two methods: NMR spectroscopy and mass
spectrometry. While NMR is able to provide a variety of information,
itrequiresrelativelyhighsamplequantities,anditsapplicabilitythus
dependsonthesolubilityoftheLPE,whichinturnlargelydependson
the fatty acid moiety. LPEs with PUFA chains tend to exhibit higher
solubility than those with saturated FA chains. For instance, LPE 17
with a DHA FA chain is soluble in methanol, while LPE 9 with a
stearic acid chain is virtually insoluble, even in chloroform/
methanol or dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO). This difference restricts
the versatility of the NMR approach in our study. Conversely, mass
spectrometry requires very small sample quantities, which renders
solubility virtually irrelevant. Especially liquid chromatography
tandem-mass spectrometry (LC–MS/MS) represents a powerful
approach to distinguish 1/2-LPEs (Han and Gross, 1996; Fang et al.,
2003; Lee et al., 2011).
Scheme 1. Synthesis of common intermediate 6.
Scheme 2. Tin-mediated acylation of 6 and subsequent deprotection of 70–170.