Journal of the American Chemical Society
Communication
a,b
When alkyl substituents were present at the 2-position, the
products were obtained with good anti selectivity, including for
cyclohexyl (1j-anti) and methyl (1k-anti) groups. However,
CySH rather than PhSH was necessary to promote
epimerization of these 2-alkyl substituted piperidines, presum-
ably because its S−H bond dissociation energy matches with
the C−H bond dissociation energies for those piperidines that
do not provide aromatic stabilization for the α-amino radical.10
In contrast, PhSH with a weaker S−H bond dissociation
energy resulted only in recovery of 1j-syn.
Table 2. Representative Conversion of 2-anti to 2-syn
We further extended the substrate scope by evaluating more
highly substituted piperidines that also incorporated nitrogen
substituents (Table 1). N-Alkyl substituted piperidines bearing
methyl, ethyl, and isopropyl groups afforded products 1l-anti,
1m-anti, and 1n-anti, respectively, in good yields and with
consistently high diastereoselectivities. Epimerization of N-
phenyl-substituted piperidine 1o-syn proceeded in 95% yield,
albeit with only moderate diastereoselectivity for the anti
isomer. Extending the reaction time for this substrate did not
improve the anti/syn isomer ratio.
a,b
Importantly, α-epimerization is not limited to 2,3-
disubstituted piperidines. For 2,5-disubstituted piperidines
with aryl and alkyl substituents at the 2-position, epimerization
also proceeded in high yields and stereoselectivities as
demonstrated for 1p-anti and 1q-anti, respectively. Addition-
ally, products were obtained in good yields and high
diastereoselectivities for N-methyl (1r-anti) and N-isopropyl
(1s-anti) piperidines with the 2,5-disubstitution pattern.
Piperidines with even higher levels of substitution also
epimerized efficiently. For example, the all syn 2,3,5-
trisubstituted piperidine 1t-syn equilibrated with high
selectivity and yield to 1t-anti. The corresponding tetrasub-
stituted N-methyl (1u-anti) and N-ethyl (1v-anti) derivatives
were similarly obtained with very high selectivity. Moreover,
the 2,3,5-trisubstituted piperidine 1w-syn, which incorporated
an ester at the 3-position, also efficiently epimerized to give
1w-anti.
To this point, only syn contra-thermodynamic piperidines
had been investigated. To demonstrate the potential generality
of α-amino epimerization for contra-thermodynamic anti
stereoisomers, we evaluated a number of 2,4- and 2,6-
disubstituted piperidines 2-anti (Table 2), prepared by an
efficient new method developed by Seidel and co-workers.3b
Under the standard reaction conditions, epimerization with
greater than 95:5 diastereoselectivity for the syn isomer was
observed for both unsubstituted and N-alkyl 2,4-disubstituted
(2a−2c) and 2,6-disubstituted (2e and 2f) piperidines. Only
the N-phenyl substituted piperidine epimerized with modest
diastereoselectivity to give 2d-syn, consistent with that
observed for N-phenyl 2,3-disubstituted piperidine 1o (see
Table 1).
See footnotes a and b for Table 1.
Table 3. Experimental and Calculated Relative Energies
exptl dr
entry substrate anti/syn
exptl ΔGsyn − ΔGanti calcd ΔGsyn − ΔGanti
a
(kcal/mol)
(kcal/mol)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
1a
1j
1k
1l
1p
1o
2e
98:2
83:17
97:3
97:3
97:3
78:22
4:96
2.3
0.9
2.1
2.1
2.1
2.2
1.3
3.6
2.8
1.6
1.9
−2.4
0.8
−1.9
a
ωB97X-D/6-311++G(d,p), SMD (MeOH or MeCN)//ωB97X-D/
6-31G(d), SMD (MeOH or MeCN). Exptl = experimental.
6), while epimerization to the most stable diastereomer
occurred, the relatively modest diastereoselectivity did not
correlate that well with the calculated energy difference
between the two diastereomers. For 2e with a different
substitution pattern (entry 7), reasonable agreement between
the calculated energy difference and experimentally observed
ratio was observed.
In the photoredox-mediated arylation of piperidines, we had
previously observed that the distribution of piperidine isomers
resulted from reversible light-mediated in situ epimerization of
the initially formed α-arylated piperidines.4 To probe the
reversibility of photoredox-mediated epimerization in our
current study, we subjected stereoisomerically pure 1o-anti
1
to the reaction conditions (Figure 1a). By crude H NMR
analysis, we observed a 76:24 syn/anti diastereomer ratio
favoring 1o-anti, in very close agreement to the ratio obtained
starting with 1o-syn (see Table 1). Having each diastereomer
converge to the same syn/anti ratio is consistent with a
thermodynamically controlled process under the photoredox
conditions of the reaction.
To gain further information on the mechanism of
epimerization, we investigated deuterium incorporation for
several piperidines with the reaction performed in methanol-d4,
which results in rapid exchange of PhSH to PhSD (Figure 1b−
d).12 For 1a-syn (Figure 1b) and 1p-syn (Figure 1c), the
diastereomeric products were obtained with complete
deuterium incorporation at the 2- and 3-positions, but without
To compare the diastereomer ratios obtained under
photoredox conditions with the relative stabilities of the
corresponding syn and anti isomers, we used density functional
theory (DFT) to calculate the relative free energies of a
representative set of piperidine diastereomers (Table 3). The
relative energies for piperidine diastereomers for derivatives 1
with a range of different substituents correlated well with the
observed high diastereomer ratios (entries 1−5). For these
piperidines, the lower energy anti isomer displays both
substituents in equatorial positions and the higher energy syn
isomer displays one group axial, causing unfavorable 1,3-diaxial
interactions. For the N-phenyl substituted piperidine 1o (entry
128
J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2021, 143, 126−131